Case file
West Virginia University Kappa Sigma (Gamma-Phi) — Nolan Burch 2014 Fatal Hazing, Criminal Charges and 2018 Civil Settlement
Kappa Sigma at West Virginia University · WV
- Reporting basis
- Original Morgantown Police news release, Kappa Sigma national statement, judicial order 15-C-638, WVU statements and contemporary case reports
- Incident type
- Fatal alcohol-related hazing
- Allegation status
- Fatal poisoning established; civil negligence allegations settled without trial; individual criminal cases charged, final disposition unverified
- Investigation status
- Police investigation and 2015 criminal filings; January 2018 civil settlement
- Legal status
- 2015 misdemeanor hazing and conspiracy charges; 2015-2018 wrongful-death civil action settled
- Incident start date
- 2014-11-12
- Incident end date
- 2014-11-14
Account
01. Subject and evidence hierarchy. Nolan Michael Burch, an 18-year-old West Virginia University freshman from Williamsville, New York, participated in the November 12, 2014 Kappa Sigma Gamma-Phi Big/Little initiation and died November 14 at Ruby Memorial Hospital. Original police and court documents provide the incident, fatality, and civil disposition; contemporaneous criminal reporting and university/family accounts provide independent developments.
02. Chapter already suspended before initiation. Kappa Sigma national headquarters stated November 14 that it had suspended chapter operations since mid-October 2014 due to previous, unrelated violations of its Code of Conduct. It notified the chapter and university November 10 that the charter was withdrawn and chapter operations closed. This means November 12 was an event of an already unchartered group, not a university-sanctioned recognized chapter.
03. November 12 Big/Little ceremony. The January 27, 2015 Morgantown police release reports Burch and nineteen other pledges were summoned to 200 Belmar Avenue, blindfolded, and led by fraternity members to 305 Glendon Street. They were presented to a Big, a senior member or alumnus, and given liquor. The police confirmed Burch consumed a large quantity; the exact number of drinks he personally consumed was not quantified by police.
04. Return to the fraternity residence. Police determined Burch was moved from the Glendon Street site back to 200 Belmar Avenue due to severe intoxication and laid on a table. Family counsel later alleged members failed to obtain timely medical care while he was in distress. Treat expert claims about preventability as the family's attorney's account rather than a criminal-court conclusion.
05. Emergency call. Police recorded that at about 11:50 p.m. November 12 another member noticed Burch's face was blue and found him without a pulse. Officers responded at approximately 11:52 p.m. An individual was conducting CPR, which first responders continued until emergency medical personnel took over.
06. November 14 death and toxicology. Burch was transported to Ruby Memorial Hospital and died November 14. The police-reported blood-alcohol result was 0.493. Contemporary court and university reporting describe acute ethanol intoxication; the Gordie Center documents death at age 18 and subsequent organ donation. The first police investigation update noted the medical examiner report then remained pending.
07. University's immediate response and recognition distinction. Following his death, WVU imposed an extraordinary pause on fraternity and sorority activities, later described in university policy retrospective. The university separately states the Kappa Sigma organization was unrecognized at the time, after national charter revocation. Historical campus affiliation before charter withdrawal must not be described as current university recognition.
08. February 11 2015 criminal allegations. Morgantown authorities charged Richard Schwartz, assigned as Burch's Big, with misdemeanor hazing and conspiracy to commit hazing. Reporting attributed a liquor bottle to Schwartz and documented $10,000 bond. These are charges, not a conviction.
09. February 13 2015 second criminal defendant. Jordon Parrish Hankins, identified by reporting as directing the pledge ceremony, was charged with hazing and conspiracy to commit hazing. The charge and alleged ceremony role are sourced to police and court reporting; neither person should be given an invented guilty plea or final verdict.
10. Criminal litigation through February 2016. WV MetroNews reported that on February 23, 2016 Monongalia County Circuit Court Judge Susan Tucker denied Hankins's motion to dismiss his misdemeanor hazing case. Reporting described an April trial setting; no authoritative subsequent criminal conviction, acquittal, dismissal, or final sentence was located in this review.
11. October 8 2015 wrongful-death suit. Nolan's parents sued in Monongalia County Circuit Court, case 15-C-638. Fraternal Law identifies defendants as Kappa Sigma national, Gamma-Phi chapter, its house association, WVU, individual former fraternity members, property owners, and Doe parties. The complaint alleged negligent, reckless and unlawful acts; those allegations are not a trial verdict.
12. January 17 2018 civil order. Judge Susan B. Tucker approved a negotiated settlement in the original court record. The order listed payments from Richard Schwartz, Jordon Hankins, Kappa Sigma Fraternity, WVU Board of Governors, and property owners Thomas and Linda Richey, and reported separate charitable contributions. Amounts in the supplied court order were redacted or under seal. The order dismissed the wrongful-death suit and crossclaims with prejudice as settled. The settlement does not itself constitute a jury liability finding.
13. January 18-19 public reporting. Contemporary regional reporting quoted counsel on delayed emergency aid and confirmed a confidential multidefendant resolution. The family's fatal-hazing account is kept separate from judicially established procedural findings.
14. November 2018 public university insurer disclosure. Subsequent Associated Press coverage reported the state's risk insurer agreed to pay $250,000 on behalf of WVU, while WVU denied liability, with $20,000 for hospital critical care and $5,000 for organ recovery reported separately. This public WVU amount must not be treated as the overall sealed 2018 settlement total.
15. WVU reforms and public remembrance. University statements in 2018 and 2019 describe new fraternity oversight and the Would You? intervention campaign, including medical-amnesty education and the documentary Breathe, Nolan, Breathe, designed to teach bystander intervention and early medical help.
16. Continuing prevention legacy. WVU reported the documentary won an Emmy in 2020. Its 2024 university magazine interviewed the Burch family about advocacy and prevention efforts. University materials describe a November 2025 required hazing eLearning module and the 2026 Nolan Burch Advocacy Academy, while the Remember Nolan Project continues family-led programs.
17. Current chapter status. As checked November 20, 2026, WVU's official chapter-status directory lists Kappa Sigma Gamma-Phi as Not Registered with No plan for reinstatement. The record therefore adds a missing historical canonical chapter relationship, not an active university-recognized organization.
18. Evidentiary boundaries. Age 18 and November 14 date follow the original police release, victim memorial, and court order, rather than occasional incorrect 19-year-old news accounts. No unverified full criminal dispositions, precise single-person liquor volume, global settlement total, or allegation against all chapter members is asserted.
Kappa Sigma's national charter was withdrawn November 10, 2014 before the November 12 event. Gamma-Phi remains Not Registered, no reinstatement plan, according to WVU directory.
Recorded outcome
Court-approved sealed wrongful-death settlement dismissed with prejudice January 17, 2018; publicly reported WVU insurer $250,000 in November 2018, not entire settlement total; criminal charges filed but final dispositions unverified
Kappa Sigma at West Virginia University
Gamma-Phi
Morgantown
WV