Case file
Washington State University Alpha Tau Omega (Gamma Chi) — Sam Martinez's 2019 Fatal Hazing, 15 Criminal Cases, Sam's Law and 2026 Supreme Court Ruling
Alpha Tau Omega at Washington State University · WA
- Reporting basis
- WSU organizational findings and press statements; Washington Supreme Court 2026 and Court of Appeals 2025 judicial records; Whitman County prosecutor and coroner findings as reported; enacted Washington anti-hazing law
- Incident type
- Fatal alcohol poisoning following fraternity hazing
- Allegation status
- WSU organizational responsible findings for hazing, physical abuse and reckless endangerment; 15 individual liquor-furnishing charges with eight guilty pleas and seven conditional cases; family civil negligence allegation against WSU unresolved
- Investigation status
- WSU organizational investigation began November 15, 2019, concluded May 18, 2020; official recognition withheld through May 15, 2026; 2021 liquor-to-minor prosecutions resulted in eight guilty pleas and seven conditional deferrals; WSU civil claim remanded after July 2026 Supreme Court ruling
- Legal status
- Estate's claims against ATO and individual defendants settled at dates and amounts not verified; WSU wrongful death negligence case returned to King County Superior Court following July 30, 2026 supreme decision on duty; no final breach or damages judgment verified
- Incident start date
- 2019-11-11
- Incident end date
- 2019-11-12
Account
01. The student and the historical chapter
Samuel H. 'Sam' Martinez, 19, of Bellevue, Washington, entered Washington State University in fall 2019 as a first-year student interested in business and entrepreneurship. He pledged the Gamma Chi chapter of Alpha Tau Omega (ATO), then recognized by WSU and chartered by ATO National. The chapter maintained a recognized chapter house in Pullman and a separate off-campus live-out where members held events. This historical chapter is identified by existing GLW chapter ID; publication of historic events must not imply it currently holds campus recognition.
02. Years of warnings before the fatal event
The 2025 Washington Court of Appeals opinion and 2026 Supreme Court record describe repeated university awareness of alcohol misuse and hazing within the Greek system. WSU had investigated a 2016 video showing drinking on chapter property and received a 2017 parent report describing physical and emotional mistreatment, forced drinking and one pledge leaving the university. WSU said evidence then was insufficient to find a chapter violation. A 2017 administrative meeting raised further concerns, and ATO National conducted a 2018 membership review that expelled 38 Gamma Chi members. These reported warnings differ from later adjudicated 2019 violations.
03. Individual and live-out incidents in 2018–19
Court records describe a 2018 incident in which incoming chapter president Luke Hawksford was found intoxicated outside a WSU residence hall after drinking at a chapter live-out and was sanctioned as an individual. Another student was injured after consuming alcohol at the live-out before a November 2018 event. In 2019, officials received reports of intoxicated students, including at the shared Delta Chi live-out. WSU had known of the use of off-site 'live-outs' for alcohol-centered functions. Allegations involving Sigma Nu at a shared property are background about university oversight, not misconduct findings against every ATO member.
04. Summer 2019 recruitment and nondisclosure claim
Sam and his parents Jolayne Houtz and Hector Martinez attended WSU orientations where university materials described fraternities' social and leadership benefits. The parents later asserted in litigation that they were not informed of Gamma Chi's hazing and alcohol history. Sam elected to pledge Gamma Chi. A university-approved-housing and student-organization recognition system gave WSU authority to review and sanction fraternities under school rules. These recruitment and nondisclosure facts are documented in sworn testimony quoted by appellate courts.
05. November 11 Big–Little reveal begins at the live-out
On the night of November 11, 2019, members summoned pledges to a house under the stated pretext of cleaning. The gathering was a Big–Little reveal, pairing pledges with their 'big brothers' and 'Greek families.' Members were expected to share an alcoholic drink brought by a big brother. Family, police and appellate accounts describe a half-gallon of rum given to Sam and another pledge to share during the event. This episode was part of an initiation process, not a routine unrelated social gathering.
06. Movement to the chapter house and worsening intoxication
Within approximately one hour the group moved from the live-out to the ATO Gamma Chi fraternity chapter house and continued drinking, according to the Supreme Court's record. Sam showed pronounced signs of intoxication. Family and police accounts report he was later left unconscious on a couch in a basement chapter room. Statements about what any particular member knew at a specific moment must be tied to the public record and individual criminal proceedings, not inferred from membership.
07. Death, 911 call and coroner findings
The Whitman County coroner placed Sam's death at approximately 4:30 a.m. November 12, 2019. Fraternity members made a 911 call around 8:30 a.m. after finding him unresponsive and reported attempts at CPR. Later toxicology established acute ethanol intoxication as cause of death and accidental manner; a 0.372 blood alcohol concentration was reported in the coroner record. The four-hour interval measures estimated death time to the 911 call, and must not be described as proof the callers had known of his death throughout that interval.
08. Initial police and university responses in November 2019
WSU publicly reported the death on November 12 and announced that campus Greek organizations had suspended social events for the rest of the semester. Early Pullman Police remarks were skeptical that the incident legally constituted hazing, whereas WSU said its own hazing review remained open. On November 15, WSU issued an interim loss-of-recognition notice to Gamma Chi. The police, university conduct and national fraternity processes must be distinguished.
09. WSU organizational investigation and responsible findings
The WSU Center for Community Standards transparency report records investigation November 15, 2019–May 18, 2020 and a May 18 hearing. Its findings against the organization included hazing, abuse/physical assault or intimidation, reckless endangerment and alcohol/drug policy violations. The report says fall pledges were required to drink alcohol, perform wall sits, clean without proper supplies and were assaulted; chapter collected cash social fees for alcohol. These are formal findings of organizational misconduct.
10. Campus sanction through May 15, 2026 and charter loss
A May 18, 2020 signed conduct agreement ended WSU recognition of Gamma Chi through May 15, 2026. Conditions for possible re-recognition included 18 months' social probation, two years' alcohol-free house rules, multi-year faculty/staff meetings, anti-hazing education and additional monitoring. ATO National separately revoked Gamma Chi's charter in 2020 after the death. Expiration of a defined campus sanction does not itself reinstate university recognition or the national charter.
11. Police investigation and missed hazing charging window
Pullman Police investigated extensively, with a reported 177-page file and referrals to Whitman County prosecutors. The family's public criticism and 2021 coverage report that by the time authorities considered criminal charges, the one-year statute of limitations for then-misdemeanor hazing had elapsed. No individual was ultimately criminally prosecuted for hazing in this incident; the 2021 criminal cases alleged furnishing liquor to a minor. A university organizational hazing finding uses a different process and standard.
12. Fifteen liquor-furnishing charges filed June 2, 2021
Whitman County Prosecutor Denis Tracy charged 15 current/former Gamma Chi members with furnishing alcohol to underage pledges during the Big–Little initiation event. Only Wesley Oswald was specifically charged with providing alcohol to Sam Martinez; the other charges related to other pledges. The original filing was a gross-misdemeanor prosecution, with individualized outcomes; the fact of a charge does not imply each defendant directly caused Sam's death.
13. Criminal pleas and sentences
Court reporting identifies Maxwell Rovegno, Cameron Thomas and Nolan Valcik as among seven other defendants who pleaded guilty to furnishing alcohol to a minor; these defendants were not accused of directly furnishing Sam. Seven such defendants reportedly received one day in jail, $500 fine, eight months' supervised probation and alcohol/drug class. Oswald pleaded guilty to furnishing alcohol to Sam and received 19 days in jail, a $500 fine, alcohol education and two years' supervised probation. Sentences did not include homicide convictions.
14. Seven conditional prosecutions, not established final convictions
An October 22, 2021 prosecutor account described seven remaining defendants entering conditional agreements with required tasks and an April 2022 review. It anticipated dismissal on compliance or expedited prosecution if not. No verified final April 2022 docket for each individual was obtained; those seven are not categorized as convicted, acquitted or finally dismissed. Total reported resolution was eight guilty pleas and seven conditional cases.
15. Family wrongful-death suit and party settlements
Sam's parents, personally and as estate representatives, filed a King County Superior Court civil action in July 2020, No. 20-2-11998-9. Their claims included WSU, ATO National, Gamma Chi, Richmond Property Group and individual former members/officials. The January 2025 Court of Appeals opinion states the estate settled claims against the fraternity, property company and individually named non-WSU defendants; dates, money and contractual terms were not disclosed in the reviewed public appellate record. The WSU negligence claim remained actively litigated.
16. March 24, 2022 trial-court ruling
King County Superior Court granted WSU summary judgment on March 24, 2022, concluding WSU had no legally cognizable duty to protect Sam under the negligence theories raised. A summary-judgment dismissal against WSU at that stage was later overturned. It did not resolve individual criminal case guilt, WSU's disciplinary findings, or the settled fraternity parties.
17. January 21, 2025 Court of Appeals reverses
Washington Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 83853-9-I, reversed dismissal on January 21, 2025. The court held WSU had a special relationship with the recognized fraternity that created a duty of reasonable care against foreseeable hazing and alcohol misuse, and remanded. This was a legal-duty ruling, not a trial verdict that WSU breached duty or caused damages.
18. October 23, 2025 high-court argument
The Washington Supreme Court heard argument about WSU's ability and obligation to oversee recognized fraternities, including off-campus live-out parties, and the parties' competing theories under Restatement (Second) of Torts §315(a). WSU argued university recognition did not create sufficient direct control; the family emphasized the agreements, historic warnings and university sanction powers.
19. July 30, 2026 Supreme Court precedent
On July 30, 2026, the Washington Supreme Court ruled 5–4 in No.104108-0 that WSU owed Sam a duty to exercise reasonable care to address foreseeable harm from Gamma Chi hazing and alcohol use. The majority reasoned that WSU granted benefits to recognized fraternities while retaining enforceable oversight authority. The court affirmed the appellate reversal and remanded the WSU wrongful-death claim for further proceedings. It expressly did not decide whether WSU breached the duty, whether its acts caused the death, comparative fault, or damages.
20. Dissent and university response
A four-justice dissent argued WSU lacked the type of direct control of off-campus conduct necessary to impose the asserted duty and pointed to ATO National's direct role. WSU's July 30 statement acknowledged the family's loss and said the case could move to a possible trial; it did not report a final merits result. Distinguishing the majority's binding duty ruling from the dissent's contrary reasoning preserves the judicial record without mischaracterizing a final liability verdict.
21. Chapter status as of 2026
An April 2026 report quoted a WSU spokesperson stating there was no plan to reinstate ATO. The conduct sanction's May 15, 2026 end allowed the chapter to seek new recognition, not automatic restoration. WSU's transparency page last updated October 28, 2026 still documents the historical ban and conditions. No new charter and campus recognition were independently confirmed through November 9, 2026; the preexisting GLW chapter directory row is preserved rather than overwritten.
22. Sam's Law enacted 2022
The family advocated for Washington's HB 1751, signed March 30, 2022 and effective June 9, 2022. The Sam's Law Act expanded the statutory hazing definition (including coercive consumption regardless of consent) and established prevention education, institutional public reporting, and other oversight obligations. These post-incident protections did not apply retroactively to the 2019 criminal charging decision.
23. 2023 Sam Martinez Stop Hazing Law
HB 1002, signed May 1, 2023 and effective July 23, 2023, created gross-misdemeanor hazing liability and a class C felony for hazing causing substantial bodily harm; RCW 28B.10.901 also provides specific organizational civil liability. This is a second, separate Washington reform bearing Sam's name, not a restatement of the 2022 transparency law.
24. Federal act and research legacy
Sam's parents campaigned for the federal Stop Campus Hazing Act, signed December 23, 2024; the family and research partners also advanced the Samuel Martinez Hazing Prevention Fund and HazingInfo database to improve awareness of hazing incidents. University and national transparency initiatives in 2026 concern broader prevention, not evidence of fresh misconduct by the defunct Gamma Chi chapter.
25. Evidence boundaries and context
Authoritative evidence includes WSU's own disciplinary findings, Washington judicial opinions, state statutes, contemporaneous police/prosecutor reporting and family statements. Court opinion quotes prior affidavits and case filings but does not adjudicate every fact alleged against all parties. No sealed settlement contract, certified 15-defendant criminal docket corpus or new post-July 2026 trial verdict was obtained in research through November 9, 2026. Do not turn a charged person's name, a conditional prosecution or a court's threshold duty ruling into an individual criminal conviction or final damages judgment.
Distinguish WSU disciplinary hazing findings from 2021 criminal charges (liquor-furnishing only). 2026 high-court decision establishes duty, not completed negligence merits finding. Sanction end date does not imply ATO automatically re-recognized.
Recorded outcome
WSU organizational sanction through May 15 2026; 2021 criminal proceedings included eight guilty pleas and seven conditional resolutions; family reached confidential non-WSU settlements; July 2026 Supreme Court affirmed WSU owed legal duty and remanded for litigation