Case file
UW–Madison Delta Upsilon — March 2012 Bottle-Throwing Confrontation, Safety Findings and Two-Year Suspension
Delta Upsilon at University of Wisconsin–Madison · WI
- Reporting basis
- May 23, 2012 original Committee on Student Organizations signed decision No.1112-20 reproduced by FIRE; UW–Madison March 21 and May 24 official releases; FIRE June 1 analysis; UW current FSL directory
- Incident type
- University-sustained organizational health/safety misconduct; reported racial intimidation and glass-bottle confrontation
- Allegation status
- Two students' allegations of racial taunts/targeted bottle; university sustained organizational codes 4 and 5 but NOT discrimination code 2, alcohol-event code 10 or law-violation code 3
- Investigation status
- Received March 20; emergency suspension; formal hearing May 11; organizational adjudication completed May 23, 2012. Appeal eligibility acknowledged; actual appeal outcome not recovered
- Legal status
- University organizational sanctions; no individual criminal adjudication established
- Incident start date
- 2012-03-16
- Incident end date
- 2012-03-16
Account
01. Original signed organizational determination
UW–Madison Committee on Student Organizations case No. 1112-20, dated May 23, 2012 and signed by chair James N. Luo, is the central first-party evidence. Its reproduced ten-page decision identifies a March 16 incident involving two women and Delta Upsilon members; it contains six charge votes, the majority's reasoning, a two-phase suspension and multiple written dissents. This original decision—not early allegations or later advocacy commentary—controls descriptions of which university rules were sustained.
02. March 16 confrontation involving two Black women
Two female UW–Madison students, identified by the university as African American, reported that fraternity members on the porch of Delta Upsilon's 644 N. Frances Street property directed racial/class-related insults toward them while they were on the fraternity's Lakeshore property. University officials reported the two tried to leave and a glass object was thrown in their direction. The original committee decision says the students were on private DU property and characterized them as trespassing; both this context and the students' reported harassment are retained.
03. Student allegations and disputed targeting
The women believed chapter members directed offensive language at them because of race and that a bottle was aimed at them. Members disputed parts of the account and one described accidentally knocking a bottle from a shelf. The committee found some offensive class-oriented words were used, but did not substantiate racial motivation, an attempt to strike the women, or physical injury. Nothing in the outcome authorizes naming private students or asserting intentional targeted battery.
04. Discrimination code No. 2 not sustained, 0–10
After reviewing conflicting accounts, the committee found the reported words related to perceived social class, including terms invoking wealth and 'one percent,' rather than an established racial basis. On its interpretation of the organization code, socioeconomic status was not a covered category. The committee voted 0–10 on responsibility under nondiscrimination code 2. This is a specific NOT RESPONSIBLE disciplinary outcome, not a finding that the reported confrontation never happened.
05. Glass bottle and code No. 5 sustained, 8–2
The original decision concluded a glass bottle shattered during the altercation and believed it was actively thrown in response to the exchange. The committee said the direction or target could not be established but found the bottle created serious danger to the two students and nearby pedestrians. Delta Upsilon was found responsible under organizational health and safety code 5 by an 8–2 vote. The student reports of a bottle aimed directly at them remain allegations rather than a committee finding.
06. Chapter representation code No. 4 sustained, 8–2
The committee reasoned that members living at the fraternity residence acted on behalf of Delta Upsilon when responding collectively to nonmembers they perceived as being on chapter property. It therefore found organizational responsibility for actions by members representing the chapter under code 4 (8–2). Individual membership alone was not made a blanket basis for guilt; the finding was tied to these members' actions during this particular incident.
07. Other alleged codes not sustained
The committee did NOT sustain code 3, alleged separate legal violations (5–5); code 9, organization representative false statements (2–8); or code 10, alcohol at organizational functions (3–7). It did not substantiate a neighbor's allegation about routine bottle throwing, and the police officer cited in the committee record did not know of relevant bottle-throwing calls. These are distinct from the codes 4 and 5 findings.
08. Alcohol was contextual, not a sustained event-alcohol charge
The committee believed two participants were likely intoxicated during the altercation despite denials and noted concern about the chapter's alcohol culture. However, it could not determine that a formal fraternity function was taking place or that the organization supplied the alcohol; code 10 was therefore NOT sustained. It also did not hold the organization responsible under code 9 for the individuals' later statements to university investigators.
09. Distinct 2011 alcohol violation and probation
The May 2012 decision refers to a prior December 2, 2011 ruling concerning underage drinking and alcohol restrictions; it says the March 16 confrontation occurred 22 days after that earlier probation ended. The prior violation influenced the May 2012 sanction severity, but its underlying incident date and full ruling remain outside this file. Do not count it as the March 2012 act or invent a separate victim.
10. March 20 interim suspension and March 21 campus announcement
Following receipt of the report March 20, the dean placed Delta Upsilon on interim suspension during investigation. The March 21 university statement publicly acknowledged two students' reports, a broader review of members, the organization and IFC judicial processes, and an emergency restrictions order. Interim status was precautionary, not itself a final guilt determination.
11. Formal review April 20 and May 11
The committee formally notified Delta Upsilon on April 20, 2012 that a hearing would be held and conducted the hearing May 11. The original decision describes varying witness accounts, investigative evidence, and the need to decide what happened, which members represented the organization, and what organizational responsibility should follow.
12. Six charge tallies in final May 23 decision
The May 23 2012 original decision records: code 2 discrimination NOT RESPONSIBLE 0–10; code 3 separate law violation NOT RESPONSIBLE 5–5; code 4 conduct of representatives RESPONSIBLE 8–2; code 5 organizational safety RESPONSIBLE 8–2; code 9 false statements NOT RESPONSIBLE 2–8; code 10 event alcohol NOT RESPONSIBLE 3–7. The vote tallies are not independent criminal findings or criminal-jury verdicts.
13. Full suspension through Spring 2013
A 6–3 committee vote sanctioned DU with two semesters of FULL SUSPENSION through the end of Spring 2013. Under the order, the fraternity could not reserve campus space, hold ordinary organizational functions or participate in Greek activities; only one executive-board meeting and one chapter meeting per week were specifically permitted. Although the order was effective May 23, its academic-term timeline began on the first day of Fall 2012 instruction.
14. Structured suspension Fall 2013 through Spring 2014
The sanction's second year was STRUCTURED SUSPENSION for Fall 2013 and Spring 2014: approved recruitment and recruitment-associated events only, upon an application at least five school days in advance to the appropriate university leadership. This is not an unrestricted reinstatement beginning in Fall 2013. The two-phase design explains the university's shorthand description of a 'two-year suspension.'
15. Oversight and national membership review conditions
During the structured suspension, chapter leaders were required to meet personally with university involvement staff; national Delta Upsilon International had to conduct a Wisconsin Chapter membership review in Spring 2014; and the chapter had to submit a detailed statement of membership requirements and values. The reviewed sources do not establish the precise completion of each condition.
16. Termination proposed in dissents but not imposed
The decision contains dissenting committee opinions, including members who preferred outright chapter termination, and another who disputed chapter representation. Those personal views were expressly nonbinding. The majority imposed the two-phase suspension and did not terminate the chapter. A public case must never misstate a dissent as the final sanction.
17. University's May 24 2012 public explanation
UW–Madison announced the action May 24 as a two-year suspension and explained the core findings: safety risk from the thrown bottle, chapter-level representation by members, prior alcohol probation and unsubstantiated racial targeting. The university also noted the decision could be appealed. No original appeal order or later modification was found in this research pass.
18. Independent legal commentary and protected-speech framing
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression reviewed the university ruling June 1, 2012 and emphasized the 10–0 rejection of the discrimination charge while criticizing other grounds for the sanction. FIRE's views constitute independent commentary, not a substitute for the university's actual finding that codes 4 and 5 were sustained.
19. Current chapter identity is a different time point
UW–Madison's Fraternity & Sorority Life directory lists Delta Upsilon, Madison Chapter, within its fraternity community in 2026, confirming a present organizational relationship. Current directory inclusion does not establish the exact day an appeal ended or the chapter completed all 2012–14 remediation requirements. Existing Midwest chapter relationship chap_delta_upsilon_university_of_wisconsin_madison is reused without creating a new chapter.
20. Open records and follow-up priorities
Obtain the full March 2012 evidence packet; the original December 2011 underage-alcohol decision; any Madison Police incident or charging document; an appeal petition or ruling; 2013–14 structured-suspension approvals; national membership-review correspondence; and final restoration/compliance records. Preserve later sourced updates as new entries. Nothing identifies a private injured person, criminal conviction, or a sustained racial-motivation finding from this organizational record.
Distinguish reports of racial motivation and directed bottle from non-sustained discrimination and targeting elements; no injuries; 2011 prior alcohol case separate; dissenting requests for termination were not imposed; 2026 FSL listing reflects later recognition, not immediate appeal outcome.
Recorded outcome
Committee: codes 4 and 5 responsible (8–2 each); codes 2 (0–10), 3 (5–5), 9 (2–8), 10 (3–7) not responsible. Full suspension two semesters to Spring 2013; structured recruitment-only suspension Fall 2013–Spring 2014; membership review and oversight conditions.