Account
01. Case boundaries and original university findings
This case concerns Alpha Sigma Phi Kappa Chapter's December 2, 2023 initiation activity at UW–Madison. The original university Campus Hazing Transparency Report lists a December 4 report, December 5 investigation opening and December 15 organizational responsibility finding. Unlike the earlier Fall 2018 case, this case also sustained specific 10(a)–10(d) violations and stated alcohol was involved. A subsequent February 2024 Kappa decision is not merged into it.
02. Initiation-house stays before membership
UW reported prospective new members were encouraged to remain at the fraternity house in the week before their initiation. This contextualizes the hazing environment. The public description does not reveal exact individual stay durations or whether every pledge was prevented from leaving the building.
03. Repeated children's music
The original university findings describe prospective members made to listen to children's music on repeat. The university classified the activities as stereotypical hazing-related pranks. No invented song titles, decibel levels or hours of forced listening are attributed.
04. Compulsory silly-song learning and performance
The university says new members were required to learn a silly song and subsequently perform it for initiated members. The power imbalance and performative requirement form part of the reported hazing program. The institutional summary does not disclose particular lyrics or participant identities.
05. Trivia games with verbal punishment
Prospective members had to participate in trivia games and were yelled at when giving wrong answers. The university identified this as part of its hazing account. The exact questions, number of sessions and identities of those directing the games were not released.
06. Physical brutality code 10(a) sustained
The university found violation 10(a), hazing involving physical brutality. The short public account does not itemize every underlying physical act. It would be inaccurate to infer punching, paddling, shocking or specific bodily injury from that code label alone.
07. Forced consumption code 10(b) sustained
UW separately sustained hazing under 10(b), forced consumption. The public account does not explicitly identify which material or quantity was ingested, despite stating alcohol was involved. It cannot be definitively described as compelled drinking of alcohol without original underlying evidence linking the two fields.
08. Hazing planning and solicitation 10(c)
A third university-sustained violation concerns planning or soliciting hazing. This finding establishes an organizational element of design or direction beyond spontaneous individual conduct, but the public record does not enumerate a private planner, organizer or communication thread.
09. Forcing policy or law violation 10(d)
The institution also found 10(d), forcing others to violate university policy or law. This is an administrative conduct-code category and is not a judicial criminal verdict against individual students. The exact policy and potential legal provisions triggered by each alleged act are not detailed in the summary.
10. Alcohol involvement confirmed
UW's official 2023 transparency entry answers Yes to alcohol involvement. Because the summary lists forced consumption without specifying what was ingested, GLW must record both facts separately rather than treat the substance as identified. No blood-alcohol measurements, medical transports or poisoning cases are provided in the original entry.
11. 72-hour confinement described in independent student-email reporting
The Daily Cardinal's January 22, 2026 investigation describes a December 2023 email exchange: a student asked a professor for extra time on coursework because he was required to stay in a locked room for 72 hours during a hazing ritual. The paper observed the reported dates matched Kappa Chapter's disclosed incident window. This is substantial victim-related reporting but it is not a university public finding attributing every detail to Kappa Chapter.
12. Academic interference and coercive effect
The student email described in The Daily Cardinal depicts a hazing requirement interfering with an academic deadline. The reported 72-hour duration is directly from the newspaper's account of the student's words, not a calculated figure. Full emails and any campus academic, disciplinary or medical response have not been independently obtained.
13. Exact Dec 2 event and December reporting
The university gives December 2, 2023 as its incident date, December 4 as the date reported and December 5 as the investigation initiation. Those three dates are distinct. The university's disclosure does not provide full interview schedules, an original case number, interim cease-and-desist order or details of any police involvement.
14. December 15, 2023 responsibility finding
UW confirmed organization-level responsibility for four separate hazing-code categories December 15. This is substantially more than a pending accusation. It does not by itself establish individual criminal liability or the factual truth of every extra detail described in subsequent reporting.
15. Officially contradictory probation chronology
The university website says disciplinary probation ran February 15, 2023 through June 15, 2024, even though its same entry dates the underlying incident December 2, 2023 and organization decision December 15. February 2023 therefore cannot be treated without verification as the post-decision beginning of this December case's probation. Both original dates are retained in GLW with the explicit contradiction; no unverified December 2023 or February 2024 replacement is inserted.
16. Mandated educational sanctions
UW ordered a virtual anti-hazing program and an additional anti-hazing education meeting with a university staff member. The public document does not provide completion certificates, participant attendance or effectiveness measures. The sanctions are requirements rather than verified completed education.
17. Later February 2024 repeat case
UW separately sustained hazing against Kappa Chapter for February 13, 2024, including pledge lineups, yelling, sorting sprinkles and children's songs, with no alcohol indicated in that subsequent finding. This later offense is GLW-REF-472, and is not merged or marked transferred as part of the current two-case batch.
18. Independent press and current chapter listing
The Daily Cardinal's 2026 analysis of nine hazing findings includes the separately obtained student email and official data, and the university FSL profile still lists Alpha Sigma Phi Kappa as an IFC chapter. Both contemporary reporting and current roster standing should accompany, not erase, the original university finding.
19. Individual charges, medical records and national authority
No original case-specific criminal conviction, civil judgment, medical injury diagnosis or national Alpha Sigma Phi charter revocation has been located for the December 2023 investigation. Student and respondent identities are not inferred from chapter membership or the separately reported private email.
20. Unresolved original evidence leads
Request the December 2023 university complaint, investigator findings and signed decision, original student-to-professor December email and any independent attribution, underlying facts supporting 10(a)–10(d), details of alcohol and forced consumption, correction of the February 15 2023 probation date, appeals and education completion, and any national Alpha Sigma Phi response.
21. Chronological separation
December 2 incident, December 4 report, December 5 investigation, December 15 formal responsible finding, February 15 2023 anomalous published probation start, June 15 2024 listed end, January 22 2026 investigative reporting and November 12 2026 chapter status review. The first-party date contradiction is flagged rather than corrected on speculation.
Official listed probation February 15, 2023–June 15, 2024 starts before Dec 2, 2023 incident. Preserve exactly and flag contradiction. Separately reported student email of 72-hour locked-room ritual does not establish signed university finding of that detailed confinement. Later February 2024 chapter case is GLW-REF-472.