Case file
Utah State Sigma Nu (Epsilon Upsilon) — Michael Starks's 2008 Fatal Initiation Hazing, Criminal Proceedings and Charter Revocations
Sigma Nu at Utah State University · UT
- Reporting basis
- Logan Police and Utah State Medical Examiner findings through contemporaneous reports; quoted Cache County prosecutor charging affidavit and district-court reporting; original university disciplinary statement quoted Jan 2009; national fraternity first-party 2026 dormant roster; 2009 and 2011 civil and criminal reporting
- Incident type
- Fatal fraternity initiation hazing; extreme alcohol poisoning; student death; sorority-assisted mock abduction; dismissed criminal hazing charges and lesser offense convictions
- Allegation status
- Death medically established as fatal acute alcohol intoxication; initiation details and individual participation in prosecutor affidavits/witness accounts; national and university sanctions confirmed; criminal hazing prosecutions ended without convictions while lesser offense convictions obtained
- Investigation status
- Logan Police investigation Nov–Dec 2008; Jan–Aug 2009 Cache County prosecutions with lesser pleas and hazing dismissals; independent Sigma Nu and Chi Omega university/national sanctions; Greek confidential 2009 civil settlement and USU Jan 2011 nonmonetary policy settlement
- Legal status
- Five jail dispositions for lesser furnishing alcohol/obstruction offenses, one hazing plea in abeyance and no final hazing convictions per Aug 2009 reporting; both chapters' recognition/charters withdrawn 2009; separate family settlements 2009/2011; Sigma Nu Epsilon Upsilon dormant 2026
- Incident start date
- 2008-11-20
- Incident end date
- 2008-11-21
Account
01. The victim and historic chapter
Michael Starks was an 18-year-old freshman from Salt Lake City attending Utah State University in Logan. He was a candidate for the Epsilon Upsilon chapter of Sigma Nu, a chapter first chartered in 1938. He died on November 21, 2008, following a night of fraternity initiation-associated alcohol consumption. His identity and medical fatality were documented by Logan police, the Utah Medical Examiner and contemporaneous campus reporting. The 2008 Epsilon Upsilon chapter is now listed dormant by Sigma Nu headquarters; this is a historical case, not a currently operating USU chapter.
02. November 20: candidate selection and capture ritual
Prosecutors' January 2009 charging account says Sigma Nu members selected Michael and another pledge for a staged 'capture' ritual involving members of Chi Omega, a neighboring sorority. Accounts describe a pretext that the pledges would help move furniture; Chi Omega participants then took them to an off-campus Logan residence. The capture was linked to Sigma Nu initiation and was reportedly a longstanding activity. Because the university's criminal hazing charges later were dismissed or resolved differently, the minute-by-minute story is attributed to charging documents and witnesses, rather than described as a completed criminal hazing verdict.
03. Second pledge's distinct role
The other new member, Mackenzie Perry, was present during the episode. The 2009 account names him as the second pledge at the mock capture. Some accounts say the event's organizers instructed the women not to let him drink too much. He was not the deceased student and public sources do not establish an alcohol-related hospitalization for him. The second pledge is treated as an eyewitness/participant in the incident description, not a charged perpetrator or separate fatality.
04. Forced stripping, paint and physical restraint
Contemporaneous probable-cause reporting says the two recruits were told to strip to their underwear and were painted in Utah State's blue-and-white colors. Some published accounts also describe cords or duct tape restraining them. The source supports allegations of humiliating treatment as part of a staged initiation activity. Exact physical restraints and their duration are not independently established by a signed criminal judgment.
05. Vodka bottles and high-risk drinking
The 2009 charging documents describe sorority members bringing and providing vodka, including an approximately one-liter bottle. Witness reports say women held bottles to the pledges' mouths when their hands were covered in paint and that Michael later drank directly from the larger bottle. Other reports use 'most of a fifth' to summarize his consumption; these are different estimates rather than an independently authenticated volume consumed. The central documented finding is a fatal level of acute alcohol intoxication.
06. An off-campus home, not the fraternity house, was the drinking site
The vodka-centered activity occurred at a private residence off campus after the students were collected at a sorority house. They were then transported back to Sigma Nu. The fact that intoxication occurred away from the fraternity house did not remove the fraternity initiation connection reported by prosecutors or the university's subsequent organizational discipline.
07. Return to Sigma Nu, showers, and intoxication
Prosecutorial accounts say fellow new members or fraternity members returned both intoxicated pledges to the Sigma Nu house around an hour later. Several people tried to shower the pledges and assist with washing. Michael reportedly was still talking for a period, then lost consciousness as his condition deteriorated. Exact intervals varied in retrospective reports and are not treated as proven without the original emergency records.
08. Poison Control call before emergency transport
The Salt Lake Tribune obtained a recording/transcript of a call to the Utah Poison Control Center made by a fraternity member approximately four hours before Michael's death. Reporting says the caller characterized Michael as 21 instead of 18 and declined to give his name, saying he was heavily intoxicated but conscious. The center advised hospital transport if he could not be awakened or aspirated vomit. The published transcript report does not establish the caller's state of mind or make every fraternity member responsible for the call.
09. Delay before 911 and attempted CPR
After being put to bed, Michael was found unconscious and not breathing during the early hours of November 21. Original reporting says students began CPR and phoned 911, with first responders performing resuscitation. Police and the campus paper place the emergency around 3–4 a.m. The timing of the earlier Poison Control consultation is documented by contemporaneous reporting, but the precise time between medical danger signs and ambulance contact is not given an invented exact figure.
10. November 21 death at Logan Regional Hospital
Emergency medical personnel transported Michael to Logan Regional Hospital, where he was pronounced dead before approximately 4 a.m. on November 21, 2008. This is the established fatal outcome, not merely an unconfirmed police suspicion. Family statements and local student journalism recount the effect on his classmates, siblings and parents.
11. Medical examiner's confirmed cause and reported BAC
On December 24, 2008 Logan police publicly relayed a Utah state medical examiner finding that Michael died from alcohol poisoning. Police described blood-alcohol concentration above 0.35 percent; contemporaneous January 2009 reporting more precisely used 0.373 percent. Both correspond to over four times the 0.08 driving threshold. The final signed laboratory report was not retrieved, so the exact 0.373 figure is attributed to reports summarizing the medical finding.
12. Distinguish death from individual criminal verdicts
A state medical death determination and evidence of an initiation ritual do not by themselves establish that any particular attendee was convicted under Utah's specific hazing statute. Prosecutors ultimately were unable to obtain hazing convictions from the twelve originally charged students or two organizations. Their lesser alcohol and obstruction convictions, individual dismissals, and one plea in abeyance are recorded below. This distinction is important because it explains the family's public criticism without erasing the fatal event.
13. Initial campus and national suspensions
Immediately after the November death, Utah State and the fraternity and sorority headquarters halted activities of Sigma Nu and Chi Omega pending investigation. Sigma Nu's national executive director publicly condemned hazing, and the university opened separate student conduct proceedings. The early suspension must be differentiated from the formal national charter revocations announced in January 2009.
14. January 2 2009 felony chapter and individual charges
Cache County prosecutors announced third-degree felony hazing charges against the Sigma Nu and Chi Omega organizations and misdemeanor hazing counts against twelve named people. The group included fraternity and sorority members, with additional alcohol-furnishing and obstruction counts for some. A further person involved in the alcohol purchase was charged separately, raising the total number of individual defendants reported later to thirteen. These were initial allegations, not thirteen hazing convictions.
15. January 2009 university organizational findings
The January 28 Deseret News article reproduces a Utah State statement that the university's internal evaluation found both chapters willfully engaged in serious conduct-code violations, and that USU discontinued recognition. This campus administrative action is separate from, and not invalidated by, the later difficulty prosecutors had proving statutory hazing to a criminal standard.
16. January 2009 national charter revocations
On or before January 27, Sigma Nu's High Council revoked Epsilon Upsilon's charter after an internal investigation; executive director Brad Beacham confirmed the decision and the chapter's 1938 identity. Chi Omega's national organization also shut down its Utah State Alpha Gamma chapter. Residents were directed to leave fraternity and sorority facilities. Utah State's school recognition loss and national charter revocation are distinct outcomes.
17. March 2009 Grant Arthur Barney's obstruction plea
Grant Arthur Barney, a Sigma Nu member and the reported host of the off-campus home, pleaded guilty in March 2009 to misdemeanor obstruction of justice. His hazing count was dismissed under the plea resolution. A July 2009 courtroom summary states he received eight days in jail. The conviction is for obstruction, not criminal hazing or homicide.
18. March 2009 Sadie Green's hazing plea in abeyance
Chi Omega member Sadie Green accepted a plea in abeyance to misdemeanor hazing in March, conditional on completion of twelve months of probation. A plea in abeyance is a deferral of conviction and could be expunged or dismissed upon compliance. Reporting did not establish a later final hazing conviction, and the case is not categorized as a sustained criminal hazing conviction.
19. April 2009 dismissal of Bell and Weber charges
Prosecutors dropped hazing charges against Chi Omega member Brittany Bell and Sigma Nu vice president Timothy Weber, citing limited involvement. Separate charges against another sorority participant were also dismissed. These dismissals are distinct from criminal convictions for supplying alcohol and from the university's findings against the organizations.
20. May–June 2009 Whitney Miller's criminal outcome
Chi Omega member Whitney Katherine Miller pleaded guilty in May to supplying alcohol to a minor, in exchange for dismissal of hazing charges. Subsequent June reporting states a judge ordered thirty days in jail, three years of probation, a monetary fine and community alcohol-education work. Her original felony or misdemeanor labels in some reports differed; the substantiated final conviction was alcohol-furnishing, not hazing.
21. July 2009 Christopher Ammon's criminal outcome
Sigma Nu member Christopher Ammon entered a no-contest plea after the hazing charge was amended to a misdemeanor count of unlawful supply of alcohol to a minor. A July 6 courthouse report states First District Judge Thomas Willmore imposed fourteen days in jail, 200 hours of community service and a $500 fine. The 2009 court disposition does not establish a criminal hazing conviction.
22. July 2009 Erin Anthony's criminal outcome
Erin Anthony, separately reported as the person who bought the vodka, pleaded guilty to furnishing alcohol to a minor and was sentenced July 13 to eight days in jail. Anthony was the additional individual counted in later reports beyond the original twelve hazing defendants. The published record does not show a hazing conviction against Anthony.
23. July 2009 Brittany Packham's criminal outcome
Chi Omega member Brittany Packham pleaded guilty to furnishing alcohol to a minor after dismissal of the hazing charge. Late July reporting states the court imposed eight days in jail and ordered an apology letter to Michael's family to be rewritten. Her legal disposition is a lesser alcohol offense, not an adjudicated hazing or homicide conviction.
24. August 2009 final dismissals and limits of criminal hazing law
By August 5, the first district court had dismissed the remaining hazing cases, including the one against Sigma Nu president Cody Littlewood, with the prosecution no longer opposing dismissal. The court had also dismissed felony charges against the two organizations after their charters were revoked. Final reports say no criminal hazing conviction resulted despite five individuals serving jail terms for lesser alcohol- or obstruction-related offenses. The family objected to the outcome; prosecutor Tony Baird said his office could not meet the applicable elements/burden.
25. May 5 2009 separate Greek-organization civil settlement
Michael's family reached out-of-court civil settlements involving Sigma Nu and Chi Omega by May 5, 2009, according to family attorney Charles Thronson and contemporary courthouse coverage. The terms were confidential and the payment amounts not verified. The agreement must not be conflated with the university's January 2011 prevention-only settlement or a later insurer reimbursement suit.
26. August 2009 wrongful-death suit against Utah State
Parents George and Jane Starks filed suit against Utah State alleging negligent oversight, inadequate warnings of Sigma Nu's history, and failure to prevent dangerous off-campus fraternity initiation activities. The university publicly disputed that it knowingly allowed misconduct and asserted that off-campus organizations were not institutionally operated. These claims were resolved in a settlement rather than a published merits verdict finding the university liable.
27. University task force and January 2011 settlement
President Stan Albrecht established an institutional task force addressing hazing and alcohol after the death. On January 26, 2011, the family and Utah State agreed to settle the wrongful-death action with no monetary payment from the university to the family, emphasizing preventive changes. The university agreed to pursue task force recommendations; reporters documented these as policy commitments, not an admission of liability.
28. Concrete prevention terms and Good Samaritan advocacy
The prevention framework called for student input to alcohol and hazing education; campus and local police involvement in training; making students responsible for peers' welfare, with greater awareness of hospital, emergency aid and police-notification procedures; survey cooperation regarding substance use; and consideration of annual hazing/alcohol updates for Greek organizations, athletes and student groups. The Starks family publicly advocated Good Samaritan protections and prompt calls for help, subsequently praising other students and the university's emergency response efforts.
29. April–May 2011 insurer reimbursement settlement
After the insurer RSUI Inc. paid a wrongful-death claim for the fraternity, it brought a separate reimbursement action against four former Sigma Nu-linked persons, seeking reported $50,000 contributions. A judge was notified April 20, 2011 that that insurer-versus-members dispute had been resolved; terms were undisclosed. The insurer suit was not a new prosecution for Michael's death, nor evidence that those four individuals had been convicted of criminal hazing.
30. Chapter status in 2026 verified by its national organization
Sigma Nu's current first-party national chapter roll identifies 'Epsilon Upsilon — Utah State University (1938)' as a dormant chapter. The active listing does not include Utah State. A September 14, 2026 Utah Statesman account of the then-recognized campus fraternities similarly lists Alpha Tau Omega, Pi Kappa Alpha, Sigma Phi Epsilon and Alpha Sigma Phi (with Phi Delta Theta entering) but not Sigma Nu. The original Epsilon Upsilon relationship is re-created as historical and Published in West for case coverage, not as a presently recognized chapter.
31. Victim and family public account
Michael was a first-year university student who had attended Judge Memorial Catholic High School in Salt Lake City and was remembered by classmates and teachers for filmmaking, creative interests and friendships. His parents and siblings became outspoken in anti-hazing advocacy following the death. The case names Michael as the deceased victim but does not publish private addresses, witnesses' nonpublic identities, or unsubstantiated claims about substance-use history.
32. Careful scope of Chi Omega
The sorority Chi Omega's Alpha Gamma chapter and participating women were integral to the reported mock capture, vodka supply, organizational closure and court proceedings. They are described explicitly throughout the incident and outcome chronology. Since GreekLifeWatch's configured regional directory covers historically white and Jewish social fraternities and does not publish sorority chapter relationships, the case retains one primary chapter connection to Sigma Nu without fabricating a Chi Omega chapter ID or a false second fraternity case.
33. Records not obtained and further research directions
The archived university sources include press accounts, prosecutors' quoted affidavits and police/medical examiner summaries, but not the signed medical examiner's toxicology report, every individual first-district criminal disposition, final university hearing letters, original national High Council order, full May 2009 confidential Greek settlements, the January 2011 agreement, or the April 2011 insurer case closing order. These documents would improve a later archival audit but are not prerequisites for distinguishing the well documented fatality and outcomes already reported.
Chi Omega members' documented involvement is included but no sorority chapter link is created. No criminal hazing convictions, despite one hazing plea in abeyance; several alcohol/obstruction guilty pleas and jail sentences. Campus policy findings are separate from criminal outcomes. National Epsilon Upsilon remains dormant.
Recorded outcome
2008 fatal alcohol poisoning; 2009 national charter revocation and USU disaffiliation of Sigma Nu and Chi Omega; Aug 2009 no criminal hazing convictions despite several lesser guilty pleas; confidential Greek civil settlement May 2009 and prevention-focused USU agreement Jan 2011 with no payment from USU to family.
Sigma Nu at Utah State University
Epsilon Upsilon
Logan
UT