Case file
UT Knoxville Phi Sigma Kappa (Xi Deuteron) — Spring 2024 Hazing, Underage Alcohol, Probation and 90% Hazing-Education Requirements
Phi Sigma Kappa at University of Tennessee, Knoxville · TN
- Reporting basis
- Original UT Knoxville Campus Hazing Transparency Report and OSFL Chapter Conduct history; UT first-party Phi Sigma Kappa Xi Deuteron chapter profile and national Phi Sigma Kappa Cardinal Journey program description. Reviewed November 15, 2026.
- Incident type
- University-confirmed organizational hazing and alcohol supplied to underage students
- Allegation status
- Formal organizational Hazing(10), unlawful/off-campus Alcohol(19), Underage Provision(20); university Transparency additionally lists Alcohol(18) while Chapter Conduct omits it.
- Investigation status
- Community report and investigation initiated 2024-02-04; investigation ended 2024-03-07; case resolved by Resolution Agreement 2024-03-11.
- Legal status
- Institutional chapter resolution and disciplinary probation, no documented individual criminal judgment
Account
01. University case identity and original evidence. UT Knoxville's original Campus Hazing Transparency Report and Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life Chapter Conduct history both record a Phi Sigma Kappa hazing and alcohol disciplinary proceeding involving Spring 2024 activity. A March 11, 2024 university Resolution Agreement imposed chapter sanctions. These are official findings of organizational responsibility, not merely media claims or an open investigation. The precise underlying signed agreement and investigator file are not public in the sources reviewed.
02. The affected organization and established chapter designation. The campus first-party IFC directory identifies Phi Sigma Kappa's UT Knoxville organization as Xi Deuteron, founded locally in 1925. The South chapter relationship already exists at chap_phi_sigma_kappa_university_of_tennessee_knoxville. GLW retains that canonical identifier and existing chapter path rather than creating a duplicate.
03. Spring 2024 period, not a precise misconduct date. Both university incident entries say Spring 2024, without specifying the day or days when the underlying hazing or alcohol conduct took place. February 4, 2024 is the reporting and investigation-start date, not a substantiated offense date. Incident Start and End cells are left blank rather than assigning the report day to the act.
04. Off-campus setting without an identifiable residence or event. The transparency report says Off-Campus and the detailed Chapter Conduct history likewise records Location: Off Campus. Neither identifies the relevant party venue, chapter member residence, address, start hour or precise number of events. UT's present chapter profile gives a current campus address at 1800 Fraternity Park Drive, but the disciplinary report does not locate Spring 2024 events there.
05. Community member report and investigative commencement. OSFL prints Date Reported 2/4/2024, Reported By Community Member, and Investigation Start Date 2/4/2024. The transparency report independently agrees on reporter classification and opening date. The original records do not specify whether the community member was a victim, parent, neighbor, witness or fraternity participant.
06. Full investigative interval and resolution date. The dedicated transparency report gives February 4 to March 7, 2024 as the university investigation and March 11 as the Case Resolution Date. Chapter Conduct publishes March 11 as both the Notice of Allegations Date and Sanction Date. These process labels must remain separate from the undated original Spring misconduct period; no earlier or later hearing day is manufactured.
07. Hazing Code (10) sustained by both reports. Both official registers identify code (10), Hazing. The finding is against the organization and implicates the physical and psychological safety of people undergoing membership or affiliation activities. The Spring 2024 public summary gives no named survivor, witness quotation, individual accused officer, exact rite or medical injury, and no specific calisthenics, servitude, forced intoxication or violent method is attributed without first-party evidence.
08. Underage provision Code (20) confirmed in both registers. Code (20), Providing Alcohol to Underage Person, appears in both UT 2024 entries. This is an official chapter-level finding about access to alcohol by a person younger than 21. The records do not identify recipients, precise counts, providers, beverage type, amount, BAC, hospitalization or associated charges against an individual.
09. Alcohol prohibited by law Code (19) found by both. Both sources also publish Code (19), Alcohol-Related Conduct Prohibited by Law. The Chapter Conduct page's detailed count list and hazing transparency report support describing the off-campus/unlawful-alcohol violation at the university conduct level. UT does not supply a criminal court case number, police alcohol citation, statutory adjudication or convictions tied to individual members.
10. Material original-source discrepancy on Code (18). The university's Campus Hazing Transparency Report includes a fourth code, (18) Alcohol-Related Conduct, alongside hazing (10), prohibited-by-law alcohol (19), and underage provision (20). The detailed Chapter Conduct entry for the same Spring 2024 case lists only three codes: (10), (19), (20), omitting (18). GLW identifies the difference as a published first-party discrepancy; it does not silently remove the transparency-report count or claim that all four appear in the signed final agreement, which was not recovered.
11. Distinguishing code 18 from code 19 and code 20. Code (18), if part of the adjudicated record, is a general alcohol-related conduct category. Code (19) concerns alcohol-related conduct prohibited by law, and Code (20) concerns supplying alcohol to an underage person. These are separately numbered institutional classifications, not independent evidence of three distinct social events or three criminal counts. There is no reason to fabricate a fourth venue or new incident to explain the source discrepancy.
12. Resolution Agreement rather than deferred or actual suspension. The university categorizes the March 11, 2024 disposition as a Resolution Agreement. The expressly stated organization status penalty is disciplinary probation through September 1, 2024. For this Spring 2024 case, neither original source states an immediate campus suspension, charter revocation, or deferred-suspension term; the latter does appear in the separate October 2024 case and is not retroactively imported here.
13. Probation through September 1, 2024. Both university pages agree the chapter was on Disciplinary Probation through September 1, 2024. According to the chapter-conduct site, disciplinary probation permits continued university registration, signals that the chapter is not in good disciplinary standing, and may be paired with education. The scheduled endpoint is not an independently verified signed release, workshop-completion certificate or indication that future investigations were terminated.
14. Monthly OSFL executive-board supervision March to September 2024. The chapter executive board had to meet monthly with the Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life to discuss member health and safety, beginning March 2024 and continuing through September 2024. The schedule provides repeated university monitoring, not a single informational presentation. Actual attendance records and agendas for each month were not published.
15. Cardinal Journey ordered for Spring 2024 and beyond. UT required the chapter to participate in Phi Sigma Kappa International Headquarters' standardized Cardinal Journey New Member Education Program from Spring 2024 onward. The national fraternity's own original Cardinal Journey webpage identifies Brotherhood, Scholarship and Character as phases of an ongoing member-development curriculum, including associate-member meetings and growth activities. That current program description is context, not proof of what a specific student did in Spring 2024.
16. New-member educator and executive council review due April 1. For one monthly campus oversight session, the New Member Educator and Executive Council officers for Spring 2024 had to discuss the chapter's new-member education programming with OSFL and national headquarters by April 1, 2024. The campus record does not publish the revised lesson plan, attendee names, written critiques or proof of completion.
17. Social-event planning and risk management meeting due May 1. The chapter's Executive Board, Social Event Planning Team and Risk Management Team were directed to meet with OSFL to discuss events involving alcohol, risk mitigation, university event registration and behavior expected of the entire membership. This discussion had to occur by May 1, 2024. It is a specific organizational governance requirement, not verification that the chapter held a particular underage drinking event on May 1.
18. Internal accountability board to be developed by July 1. UT required an internal accountability plan for Spring 2024 and beyond, with chapter leaders meeting OSFL and Phi Sigma Kappa International Headquarters to establish and implement a chapter accountability board by July 1, 2024. This targets the internal leadership structures through which member misconduct can be prevented or addressed. UT's public summary does not show the adopted plan or disciplinary procedures.
19. Fall 2024 new-member education plan and committee review due July 1. The Executive Board, Judicial Board, New Member Committee and Recruitment Committee had to review and discuss the Fall 2024 new-member program with OSFL and furnish a documented plan by July 1, 2024. This is separate from the April 1 review of the Spring 2024 program. Nothing in this order establishes that the chapter met each original condition by the deadline.
20. Tightrope Hazing Education with minimum 90 percent completion. The chapter was required to complete Phi Sigma Kappa headquarters' online Tightrope Hazing Education Program. At least 90 percent of new members and active members had to finish by May 15, 2024. This is a quantitative campus-imposed requirement; it does not document how many individual brothers finished or furnish an attendance roster.
21. Separate UT Hazing EDU Workshop requiring 90 percent attendance. After completing the national Tightrope program, the chapter was required to attend UT Knoxville's Hazing EDU Workshop with the university Hazing Prevention Team. The in-person educational requirement also had at least 90 percent new-and-active-member attendance and was due May 15, 2024. These are two different programs, not one duplicated sanction. The apparent sequencing with a shared deadline is presented exactly as written.
22. Importance of sequence and shared May 15 deadline. The sanction wording makes completion of the online Tightrope program a precursor to the campus workshop, yet both activities show the same May 15, 2024 due date. The university's public summary does not give an hour-by-hour schedule or whether an extension was approved. GLW will not assume that required education was completed or that the two mandates were consolidated into one.
23. What UT did and did not publish about physical harm. The fact of organizational hazing and underage alcohol access is institutionally documented. The primary case entry does not supply a student injury report, intoxication level, medical transport, assault classification, psychological evaluation, names of students targeted or an exact scene. Student safety is implicated by the sustained rules, without creating medical or criminal facts absent from the primary account.
24. Fall 2024 is a later separate institutional proceeding. The same campus transparency report independently lists a later Phi Sigma Kappa Fall 2024 case, started September 27, closed October 24, and resolved October 31, 2024. It included hazing, alcohol-related misconduct, furnishing alcohol to underage people, and violation of sanctions and university policy. That October case is a separate investigation, not an additional count attached to the Spring resolution.
25. Fall 2024 university records disagree on code 27 wording. The later Fall 2024 transparency entry lists (27) Violation of University Policy or Rule, whereas OSFL's current conduct record describes (27) Violation of Disciplinary Sanctions. This difference belongs to the later case and is preserved as a source discrepancy. The Fall 2024 code (25) sanctions violation does not establish exactly which Spring 2024 term the chapter breached.
26. Later 2024 deferred suspension and probation. Unlike the Spring 2024 resolution, the October 31, 2024 case did impose Deferred Suspension through February 1, 2025 and Disciplinary Probation through September 15, 2025. These sanctions covered the later incident; chapter operations were limited to dry brotherhood or approved recruitment events until February 1, with conditional access to 13 Spring 2025 alcohol socials following headquarters' membership review. None of those conditions is a March 2024 sanction.
27. Fall 2024 headquarters membership review and safety reforms. Under the later October 2024 case, the chapter was subject to an International Headquarters membership review, standardized Spring 2025 Cardinal Journey use, monthly OSFL oversight, national/university training, and a 90-percent attendance risk-management reset due December 1, 2024. The separate later program helps explain repeated institutional concern without proving the same members committed misconduct in both cases.
28. Fall 2026 is yet another distinct hazing proceeding. UT's current Chapter Conduct page documents a separate Fall 2026 Phi Sigma Kappa case reported August 18, investigated August 19–September 2 and resolved September 2, 2026. That institutional finding separately lists hazing (10), on-campus alcohol (18), off-campus alcohol (19), and underage provision (20). Its administrative probation through March 15, 2027 belongs only to that newer resolution.
29. The 2026 case's new training thresholds are not Spring 2024 terms. The later September 2026 sanctions mandated risk-management/event-planning review by October 1, a university Hazing EDU Workshop with at least 80-percent attendance by November 1, leadership transition by December 1 and Spring 2027 new-member plan review by January 15, 2027. The later 80-percent threshold must not replace the two separate Spring 2024 requirements of 90 percent.
30. Repeated findings over three distinct 2024–2026 cases. The official OSFL record therefore shows Spring 2024, Fall 2024 and Fall 2026 Phi Sigma Kappa organizational hazing findings. Documenting repeated conduct findings across different semesters supports student awareness of chapter history. It does not supply evidence that every participant, complainant, or chapter officer was the same across three periods, or that any specific named member participated.
31. Present campus listing and live disciplinary probation. UT's current Xi Deuteron profile uses 'Good Standing: One Star,' while the more detailed present OSFL conduct page heads Phi Sigma Kappa 'Disciplinary Probation**' and lists a March 15, 2027 probation end date. The 2026 live case-specific status takes precedence for identifying current sanctions, while the profile confirms organizational identity. Neither 2026 label erases the completed Spring 2024 hazing finding.
32. Institutional campus recognition versus 2024 punishment. Phi Sigma Kappa remains in the contemporary university IFC directory, despite historical sanctions. The Spring 2024 case's probation ended on its printed date; later findings imposed new terms. Historic continuing chapter affiliation and each dated disciplinary outcome are separate fields, not a single undated suspension extending through 2027.
33. Local chapter house address not the incident venue. The original Xi Deuteron campus profile lists 1800 Fraternity Park Drive, Knoxville, Tennessee, as a chapter address. The Spring 2024 report identifies the offense location only as off campus. No original investigative entry ties the event to that address, so it is not presented as the scene, and no unverified off-campus property or residence is named.
34. Current national fraternity curriculum as contextual evidence only. The national Cardinal Journey page describes associate-member induction, recurring brotherhood and service activities and broad character development. It supports the existence and purpose of the required standardized program; it is not an original May 2024 completion log, a finding of remediation or evidence refuting the university's earlier hazing determination.
35. Actual original adjudication versus current federal transparency law. The Spring 2024 case was resolved by UT on March 11, 2024, before enactment of the federal Stop Campus Hazing Act on December 23, 2024. The federal law later strengthened reporting and disclosure; it was not the legal basis of the March 2024 decision. University hazing/organization rules existing at the incident and the school's later publication of the findings remain distinct.
36. Original disciplinary documents and compliance proof not recovered. The signed March 11, 2024 resolution, original complaint, investigator chronology and witness statements, complete evidence underlying code 18's disputed inclusion, internal accountability plan, Spring/Fall new-member education plans, monthly OSFL meeting logs, Tightrope certificates, campus Hazing EDU attendance sheets, and any appeal or completion notice are not included in the publicly accessible summaries reviewed. Those are further original-evidence leads.
37. Scope limitations for criminal and civil matters. Neither original campus source identifies a police criminal case, individual arrest, prosecution, civil claim or court result specifically arising from the Spring 2024 Phi Sigma Kappa organizational proceeding. The sustained organizational findings stand on their own; no unverified personal names, criminal convictions or medical outcomes are appended.
38. Archival record and case independence. GLW-REF-088 is published as the independent Spring 2024 Phi Sigma Kappa Xi Deuteron case; the preexisting South Fall 2026 case and original chapter metadata remain unchanged. Fall 2024 is acknowledged as a separate institutional case in the chronology, but its sanctions are not merged into this March 2024 disposition. Dates shown in case updates distinguish original action, future deadlines, and November 15, 2026 editorial source review.
Public official charge discrepancy: transparency includes Code 18, detailed OSFL Chapter Conduct does not. Exact Spring 2024 incident day unknown. Distinct Oct 2024 and Sept 2026 Phi Sigma Kappa hazing outcomes retained as independently dated proceedings; Good Standing: One Star marketing profile conflicts with live 2027 disciplinary probation in conduct register.
Recorded outcome
Disciplinary Probation through September 1, 2024; monthly OSFL executive oversight March–September; Cardinal Journey new-member education from Spring 2024 forward; Spring program review by April 1; event-planning review by May 1; online Tightrope education and UT Hazing EDU workshop each with minimum 90% new/active participation due May 15; accountability-board and Fall new-member program reviews due July 1.
Phi Sigma Kappa at University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Xi Deuteron
Knoxville
TN