Case file
UT Knoxville Phi Kappa Psi (Tennessee Epsilon) — 2021 Hazing, On-/Off-Campus Alcohol and Underage Provision
Phi Kappa Psi at University of Tennessee, Knoxville · TN
- Reporting basis
- First-party UT Knoxville Campus Hazing Transparency Report last updated 2026-08-21 (Phi Kappa Psi Spring/Fall2021 section: Community Member report, investigation 2021-10-13 to 2022-02-08, Alternative Resolution 2022-02-11, four charges and specific sanctions) crosschecked against university Office of Sorority & Fraternity Life Chapter Conduct history (same incident, UT Student reporter, four categorized counts and same sanctions). Original Tennessee Epsilon university chapter profile, SOFE ratings definitions, UT Student Organizational Misconduct and Student Code of Conduct, original Clery/SCHA transparency explanation, and Phi Kappa Psi national anti-hazing policy provide identity/procedure background only; the chapter's separate Fall2022 and Sep2024 campus proceedings retained as independent history.
- Incident type
- University-confirmed student-organization hazing and on-/off-campus alcohol misconduct, including furnishing alcohol to persons under 21
- Allegation status
- University-resolved organizational violations (10) Hazing, (18) Alcohol on campus, (19) Alcohol off campus/prohibited by law and (20) alcohol provided to a person under 21. No individual named charges or actual detailed acts published in original summary.
- Investigation status
- Spring and Fall2021 incident period with no exact original offense day. Case reported and investigated 2021-10-13; UTK hazing transparency report investigation closed 2022-02-08; voluntary organizational Alternative Resolution dated 2022-02-11. Probation until 2022-06-01; mandated monthly OSFL executive-board meetings, Big Brother program and accountability board, Hazing EDU due 2022-03-15, sober monitor training due 2022-06-01. Neither university summary supplies actual compliance completion dates. Reporting source description conflict: Community Member vs UT Student.
- Legal status
- University administrative student-organization hazing/alcohol responsibility finding and voluntary Alternative Resolution; no named criminal defendant, arrest, legal charge or court disposition in original official excerpts.
Account
01. University finding and the independently dated case. The University of Tennessee Knoxville's official Campus Hazing Transparency Report and its Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life Chapter Conduct register record a distinct Phi Kappa Psi (Tennessee Epsilon) organizational case spanning Spring and Fall 2021. The institution lists Hazing (10), Alcohol-Related Conduct (18), Alcohol-Related Conduct Prohibited by Law (19), and Providing Alcohol to a Person Under 21 (20). The chapter entered a voluntary Alternative Resolution on February 11, 2022, with probation and educational sanctions. These are official campus conduct findings, not unsourced claims about fraternity initiation.
02. Safety and unequal power in member education. Hazing involves institutional power imbalances that may pressure newer members to comply with practices they would otherwise reject. Providing alcohol to people under 21 creates a separate recognized safety problem. The university's sanctions specifically address mentorship, accountability, hazing education, and sober event supervision. The publicly released 2021 case summary does not describe individual pledging tasks, alcohol quantities, particular injuries, or an identified affected person, so these are risk categories rather than invented incident anecdotes.
03. Spring and Fall 2021 is a university-defined period. Both campus reports use the wording Spring and Fall 2021. They do not name one calendar day or establish that a single fraternity function accounts for every conduct category. The period may encompass more than one episode examined under a single organizational resolution. GLW keeps one original institutionally unified case and does not invent a day of occurrence.
04. On-campus and off-campus settings were documented. The university expressly identifies the case locations as on-campus and off-campus. That dual location is significant because organizational rules applied across both settings. Neither page provides a particular fraternity house address, apartment number, campus facility, venue name, or the locations of individual acts. The modern chapter mailing address is not retroactively assigned as an incident location.
05. Reporting began on October 13, 2021. UT Knoxville lists October 13, 2021 as the reported date and the investigation start in its chapter conduct archive. This is not evidence that the hazing and alcohol acts occurred on October 13. A case reported during the fall term can cover conduct from earlier in 2021.
06. Reporter descriptions differ across two official records. The Campus Hazing Transparency Report describes the original report as coming from a Community Member. The separate official Chapter Conduct page labels Reported By UT Student for the same October 13, 2021 case. Both can be preserved without disclosing a person or speculating whether the categories refer to one individual; they are inconsistent descriptions in official documentation.
07. The university investigated for nearly four months. The hazing transparency report states the investigation opened October 13, 2021 and ended February 8, 2022. It documents months of university review before the February resolution. The public summary does not disclose interview schedules, respondent cooperation, notice timing, investigator identity, or any law-enforcement investigative process.
08. Resolution was February 11, 2022. UT Knoxville identifies February 11, 2022 as the case resolution date, three days after the listed investigation end. Both first-party pages call the disposition an Alternative Resolution, and the chapter conduct record says the chapter voluntarily entered into it. The university's finding and accepted sanctions are publicly recorded; the actual signed agreement and individual disciplinary files are not displayed.
09. Organizational Hazing, code 10. The university lists (10) Hazing. That is a formal organization-level university violation and warrants accurate naming. The record does not identify physical calisthenics, forced servitude, sleep deprivation, violent initiation, drinking rituals, sexualized acts, or other specific mechanisms for this chapter's 2021 case. Those descriptions may appear in unrelated or later fraternity histories but are not case-specific evidence here.
10. On-campus alcohol-related violation, code 18. UT Knoxville's Chapter Conduct archive describes (18) as Alcohol-related on-campus misconduct. The Hazing Transparency Report uses the broader heading Alcohol-Related Conduct. The on-campus distinction is supported by the chapter-specific conduct page, but the actual drinks, ages, participant actions, venue, and enforcement response are not publicly itemized.
11. Off-campus unlawful alcohol-related violation, code 19. Both university records include (19) Alcohol-Related Conduct Prohibited by Law, with the chapter conduct register specifying off-campus alcohol-related misconduct. It is a university code classification that references prohibited alcohol conduct, not evidence of a personal criminal conviction. The transparency page does not identify a statute or criminal case number.
12. Underage alcohol provision, code 20. The university lists (20) Providing Alcohol to Underage Person, with the detailed conduct page describing a person under 21. This institutional finding is relevant to student safety beyond a generic registration or social-party paperwork problem. The official entry does not identify a recipient, whether a minor was intoxicated, or whether an injury or hospitalization resulted.
13. Four code headings remain part of one case. Hazing (10), on-campus alcohol (18), off-campus alcohol (19), and underage provision (20) are four separate conduct categories in the same Spring/Fall 2021 alternative resolution. They must not be published as four incidents or merged with 2022 drug or harm-to-others violations; the number of headings does not establish how many students were affected.
14. Probation until June 1, 2022. The university imposed Disciplinary Probation until June 1, 2022. That is the original 2021 case's specified end date, not the later, more extensive 2022 deferred suspension or the probation that followed the September 2024 hazing case. The fact that the scheduled endpoint has passed does not independently show compliance with every educational condition.
15. Recurring executive-board oversight. The chapter's Executive Board was required to meet monthly with UT Knoxville's Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life to address chapter health and safety, organizational operations, mentorship, and internal accountability. The public entry does not list exact meeting dates, attendance rosters, agreed follow-up actions or a formal supervisory closure letter.
16. Big Brother mentorship program expressly ordered. One ordered agenda item was to discuss and build a program around mentorship and what it means to be a supportive Big Brother. This targeted the institution's expectation for older members who guide newer students. It is a significant fraternity governance requirement, but the campus did not publicly find that a particular named Big Brother committed a given act.
17. Protective mentorship versus authority and coercion. Effective mentorship should be measured by whether a new member can refuse unsafe practices or report inappropriate demands without retaliation. The university's requirement to design a supportive Big Brother program addresses fraternity leadership responsibilities, rather than treating established customs as a defense of hazing. No adopted 2022 written mentorship protocol or independent quality assessment is publicly reproduced.
18. Internal accountability board or plan. The Executive Board was separately instructed to develop and follow an internal accountability board or plan. A functioning process should be able to document complaints, assign responsible officers and enforce consequences independent of fraternity image-management. The original source provides neither the completed plan nor a roster or minutes of the chapter's board.
19. Internal accountability cannot replace university oversight. A fraternity-controlled accountability board can be part of remediation but does not replace university sanctions or reporting channels for affected students. UT Knoxville itself retained monthly OSFL oversight. The campus does not state that it delegated decisions about the original 2021 misconduct entirely to chapter leadership.
20. Hazing EDU deadline, March 15, 2022. The university required UT Knoxville's Hazing EDU workshop by March 15, 2022. This is a precise remedial deadline established after the February resolution. The original case entry does not specify the attendance threshold, number of participants, delivery method, or documented completion day. Those details should not be transferred from the separate 2024 Highwire or other fraternities' courses.
21. Hazing education addressed member-protection failures. The mandated hazing workshop confirms that the university viewed more explicit safety training as necessary for the organization. An educational course can provide prevention information and reporting options, but the order alone does not establish that chapter culture changed. The published report does not include survey results or an independent follow-up assessment.
22. OSFL Sober Monitor Training deadline, June 1. The second named education obligation was OSFL Sober Monitor Training by June 1, 2022, matching the probation endpoint. Sober monitoring is directly relevant to preventing alcohol-related harm at fraternity events. No 2021-22 roster of trained monitors, training certificates, or actual party safety records is provided.
23. Sober event oversight is an institutional requirement. The sober-monitor requirement assigned a practical future risk-control role, not simply a generic statement that a fraternity opposes unsafe drinking. The existing university entry gives no precise monitoring ratio or attendance threshold for this 2021 case, so other cases' percentage requirements are not imported.
24. The university did not list a five-year suspension in 2021. Unlike other campus organizational cases and the chapter's later 2022 proceeding, the original February 2022 Phi Kappa Psi outcome lists probation and educational sanctions. There is no 2021-case line imposing five years of university non-recognition, chapter-house closure or a fine. That distinction is necessary to report university sanctions faithfully.
25. The separate Fall 2022 incident expanded the misconduct record. UT Knoxville subsequently documented a Fall 2022 Phi Kappa Psi case encompassing Harm to Others (5), Hazing (10), on-campus alcohol (18), two off-campus alcohol counts (19), two underage provision counts (20) and Drugs/Drug Paraphernalia (21). This later matter was reported in October 2022 and resolved November 16, 2022. Its additional findings are relevant to repeated organizational misconduct but are NOT charges from Spring/Fall 2021.
26. Fall 2022 imposed more restrictive sanctions. The Fall 2022 resolution imposed deferred suspension until February 15, 2023 and disciplinary probation until December 15, 2023, with initially restricted social events, new-member redevelopment, board education, headquarters-led training and a mock social event. Those are consequences of a distinct later case. The 2021 Alternative Resolution should not inherit its deferred suspension, drugs finding or revised limits.
27. A 2022 reporting date discrepancy is separate from this case. The 2022 Hazing Transparency entry lists October 3, 2022 as its investigation start, while the current Chapter Conduct page prints October 4, 2022 as the reported and start dates. This discrepancy pertains to the separate 2022 incident only; the 2021 case consistently has an October 13, 2021 start. No combined investigation timeline is inferred.
28. September 14, 2024 is another independent hazing case. The university separately dated a September 14, 2024 Phi Kappa Psi hazing and on/off-campus underage-alcohol proceeding. That case was reported February 14, 2025 and concluded in a March 28, 2025 Resolution Agreement, with new probation, headquarters Highwire modules, a redevelopment retreat, and oversight of 2025 new-member education. It is already published in South as GLW-REF-085.
29. 2024 training and probation may not be backdated. The September 2024 case imposed probation through October 15, 2025, Highwire training and a 2025 chapter redevelopment plan. None was a condition of the February 2022 Alternative Resolution. Keeping the separate disciplinary sequence allows students to assess whether repeated education orders corresponded with safer outcomes without manufacturing a causal chain between different membership cohorts.
30. Repeated organizational responsibility deserves public scrutiny. The official university chronology documents 2021 hazing and underage alcohol, new harm/drug/hazing findings in 2022, and another hazing and underage-alcohol case in 2024. These repeated findings warrant scrutiny of Phi Kappa Psi leadership systems, prevention promises and university oversight. The chronology does not identify the same individuals in every case or establish that one specific ritual continued unchanged.
31. Current Good Standing with historical sanctions. The current UT Knoxville Chapter Conduct archive lists Phi Kappa Psi Good Standing with two asterisks, which denotes a chapter with prior conduct sanctions in the university's reporting period. That present recognition status and the serious historical findings coexist: recognition cannot be presented as a clean disciplinary history.
32. Current SOFE performance rating differs from conduct standing. UT Knoxville's current chapter profile calls Phi Kappa Psi Tennessee Epsilon 'Unacceptable Year 1' under its Standards of Fraternal Excellence performance rubric. This is a distinct assessment from Good Standing in the conduct archive. UT's SOFE standards explain that unacceptable performance can trigger a performance improvement plan; they do not make the profile a new hazing charge or automatic suspension.
33. Tennessee Epsilon chapter identity is confirmed. UT Knoxville's original IFC profile identifies this undergraduate organization as Phi Kappa Psi's Tennessee Epsilon chapter, founded at UT in 1967. The already-published GLW chapter record and September 2024 case use that same canonical designation. No duplicate chapter is created or changed to a different university's Phi Kappa Psi affiliate.
34. National fraternity's anti-hazing policy is not case exoneration. Phi Kappa Psi headquarters publicly states an anti-hazing policy and provides a confidential reporting hotline and incident submission process. Its stated general prohibition shows headquarters' published expectations, not that those rules were successfully followed by Tennessee Epsilon in 2021, 2022 or 2024. The university's actual organizational conduct findings control this investigation.
35. Student organization responsibility is distinct from individual guilt. UT Knoxville's Student Conduct & Community Standards policy considers whether misconduct is fairly attributable to an organization, including leadership knowledge and relation to membership activity. The university's records do not name a criminal defendant or identify every individual participant in the Spring/Fall 2021 case. GLW attributes the confirmed university findings to the chapter without criminalizing all members.
36. No verifiable act-level details or court outcome. The reviewed primary institutional records do not provide specific hazing practices, identities of affected students, recorded intoxication, a hospital visit, police report, criminal indictment, civil case number or actual court judgment associated with this original 2021 case. An archive centered on students harmed by fraternity practices should not invent them; instead the documented hazing and underage-alcohol findings remain prominently visible.
37. Documentary accountability leads. The most useful outstanding original records are the initial October 13, 2021 report; case investigation and interviews; the February 11, 2022 signed Alternative Resolution; the actual Big Brother mentorship and internal accountability plans; monthly OSFL meeting records; and proof of Hazing EDU and sober-monitor completion. Such records could support more specific impact and compliance reporting in future updates.
38. Source discrepancy on reporting person preserved. The original hazing report's 'Community Member' and current Chapter Conduct's 'UT Student' descriptions may be different levels of classification, but neither supplies a source for that reconciliation. The case therefore quotes each only as an attributed institutional description and does not assert they necessarily refer to different reporters or that any person was directly victimized.
39. Resolution date versus deadline dates clearly separated. February 11, 2022 was the original organizational alternative-resolution date. March 15 was the Hazing EDU deadline, June 1 both the sober-monitor and probation endpoint. No source establishes those program completion times or a later extension; deadlines remain ordered compliance milestones, not actual completion events.
40. Why documented institutional history matters. Students, families and affected community members should be able to see organizational hazing and underage-alcohol findings alongside the actual mandated corrections, regardless of a fraternity's recruitment messaging or present campus listing. UT Knoxville publishes these cases specifically to inform student decisions. Reporting the full disciplinary record prioritizes accountability and potential victim safety over chapter reputation.
41. Conclusion. UT Knoxville held Phi Kappa Psi's Tennessee Epsilon chapter responsible for Spring/Fall 2021 hazing and three alcohol-related code categories, including underage provision. Its investigation ran October 13, 2021–February 8, 2022; it resolved February 11 via Alternative Resolution imposing probation until June 1 and monthly university oversight, supportive Big Brother mentorship, internal accountability planning, Hazing EDU by March 15 and Sober Monitor Training by June 1. Official reporter classifications conflict; 2022 harm/drug violations and 2024 hazing sanctions remain separately reported subsequent cases.
Original Hazing Transparency Report records reporter Community Member, current Chapter Conduct reports UT Student; describe as official source discrepancy, never identify individual. Both agree on October13 2021 investigation start and Feb11 2022 alternative resolution. Subsequent Fall2022 Phi Kappa Psi Harm5/Hazing10/Alcohol18/19x2/Underage20x2/Drugs21 with deferred suspension through Feb15 2023 and probation through Dec15 2023 is a DIFFERENT university incident. Sep14 2024 hazing/underage alcohol with Mar28 2025 resolution is independently published GLW-REF-085 South row129. Campus current Good Standing** (historical sanctions) and chapter profile SOFE Unacceptable Year1 measure different standards, not exoneration.
Recorded outcome
Alternative Resolution February11 2022: organizational disciplinary probation until June1 2022; executive-board monthly OSFL health and safety meetings to develop a supportive Big Brother mentorship program and internal accountability board/plan; UT Hazing EDU workshop deadline March15 2022; OSFL Sober Monitor Training deadline June1 2022. No training completion record, attendance threshold or adopted program text publicly supplied.
Phi Kappa Psi at University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Tennessee Epsilon
Knoxville
TN