Case file
University of San Diego Phi Gamma Delta (Alpha Pi) — February 2016 Hazing, Alcohol, Sexual Misconduct and Sanctions
Phi Gamma Delta at University of San Diego · CA
- Reporting basis
- University of San Diego original March 31 2016 Phi Gamma Delta notice and April 20 signed sanction (archived in USD Vista original primary documents); USD Vista May 4 and May 11 reporting; USD May 6 Alpha Phi appeal decision; USD 2026 FIJI chapter page/IFC; 2024 university FSL report.
- Incident type
- Sustained university organizational hazing, pledge alcohol, sexually abusive/inappropriate activity and officer responsibility
- Allegation status
- Phi Gamma Delta FOUND RESPONSIBLE under II.E; II.C.6,11; II.F.1; III.C. Other notice counts II.C.12 and II.F.2 not listed in final FIJI finding. Exact individual acts, victims and judicial outcome not published.
- Investigation status
- Two events on or about Feb8 2016; notice March31; full FSLSB hearing April19; final responsible finding and sanctions April20. Social restriction to Dec31 2016, excluded from fall recruitment, 2016 national review and education.
- Legal status
- University organizational conduct decision; no identified case-specific individual criminal conviction, court judgment or separately published victim settlement.
- Incident start date
- 2016-02-08
- Incident end date
- 2016-02-08
Account
01. Scope and original adjudication. GLW-REF-284 is the University of San Diego (USD), NOT San Diego State University or UC San Diego, investigation of Phi Gamma Delta's Alpha Pi chapter for its involvement in two hazing-related events on or about February 8, 2016 involving members of the Alpha Phi Eta Rho sorority and Delta Tau Delta. The original USD notice dated March 31 and signed final university sanction letter dated April 20, both preserved in the USD Vista's original 2016 primary-document packet, identify FIJI's organizational charges and final findings. This case is ONE spring 2016 campus disciplinary matter; no separate suspected act is counted as an adjudicated independent second case.
02. Chapter identity and campus. USD's original Alpha Pi chapter was founded at the University of San Diego in 2011, as the university's 2026 chapter-specific profile states. The neighboring SDSU Phi Gamma Delta Sigma Delta chapter and UCSD's Phi Gamma Delta record have distinct identifiers and conduct histories, including the 2019 Dylan Hernandez tragedy at SDSU. None of those other schools' evidence is imported as wrongdoing of USD's Alpha Pi chapter.
03. Hazing of new members. USD's March 31 notice of hearing refers explicitly to allegations that new members were hazed at two distinct events around February 8, 2016. The same campus disciplinary proceeding ended with Phi Gamma Delta found responsible under the USD Fraternity/Sorority Guidelines' hazing provision II.E. This is a completed organizational finding, not solely press speculation.
04. Alcohol at both events. The hearing notice says both events involved alcohol. The April 20 final decision sustains USD Guidelines II.C.6 and II.C.11 for FIJI. The campus newspaper interpreted these as alcohol-related rules including alcohol during pledge/associate activity. The precise drinks, purchase mechanism, amounts consumed, whether any individual was forced to drink, and personal intoxication or medical records were not specified in the published original case document.
05. Sexual misconduct was part of the institutional findings. USD's original notice uses 'sexual misconduct' for the February incidents, while the final FIJI letter specifically sustains organizational sexually abusive, lewd or otherwise inappropriate activity under II.F.1. The university's separate March 4 internal communication (reported by the Vista) called aspects of the events 'sexual exploitation'. Neither the official letters nor published hearing summary establishes an identifiable sexual-assault victim, assault mechanics, an individual Title IX outcome, or a criminal conviction. The archive uses the university's actual organizational policy category rather than inventing a specific physical crime.
06. Alpha Phi Big Sister/Little Sister connection. The March 31 notice specifically connects both alleged incidents to Alpha Phi's Big Sister/Little Sister program. This places the fraternity's organizational misconduct in joint events with another Greek-life organization; it does not automatically assign every practice or injury to every participant or prove that each Alpha Phi new member attended both events.
07. Alleged participation by chapter officers. The university's March 31 FIJI notice states some involved members were or had been officers. The final sanction sustained III.C concerning responsibilities of chapter officers. An organizational officer responsibility finding is not a list of individually adjudicated defendants, and the school did not publish detailed findings naming particular officers who committed each act.
08. Distinct gendered and organizational power dynamics. The episodes reportedly involved sorority new members in connection with established members from multiple Greek organizations. A new member's membership aspirations and power imbalances contextualize the campus's hazing and sexual misconduct policies. The original university file does not publish individual coercion narratives or separate finding for each alleged victim, so those are not invented.
09. Late-February report to university. USD vice president Cynthia Avery's May 6, 2016 response to Alpha Phi's appeal states the university's Director of Student Leadership and Engagement learned in late February of incidents earlier that month. The Alpha Phi chapter president and national headquarters were notified. Exact original complaint day, complainant identity and referral sequence for FIJI beyond the March 31 notice were not published.
10. March 4 immediate Alpha Phi restriction—not a FIJI closure. The May 4 USD Vista investigation quotes a March 4 campus communication from Avery directing ALPHA PHI to cease all chapter activities, meetings and planned March 6 initiation after confirming hazing allegations; that communication cites alcohol, blindfolds and sexual exploitation. It is an early interim step against Alpha Phi, not an independently verified written March 4 shutdown order imposed on Phi Gamma Delta.
11. March 31 Phi Gamma Delta notice. USD Director Mandy Womack issued a specific hearing notice addressed to the FIJI chapter's president. The letter named two February events, alcohol, sexual misconduct, hazing, Alpha Phi's Big Sister/Little Sister context and officer involvement. It cited II.E; II.C.6, 11, 12; II.F.1, 2; III.C as proposed policy counts. The final finding differed and must be coded from the April 20 letter instead.
12. Alleged counts versus sustained counts. The notice initially mentioned II.C.12 and II.F.2, but the April 20 FIJI decision found responsibility only under II.E; II.C.6 and II.C.11; II.F.1; and III.C. The proposed additional II.C.12 alcohol-sale provision and II.F.2 protected-class harassment provision are not listed as sustained findings against FIJI. This distinction prevents incorrectly claiming a confirmed racially motivated attack or sale of alcohol by FIJI.
13. Phi Gamma Delta used full hearing. The USD Vista's May 11 follow-up confirms both FIJI and Delta Tau Delta elected full administrative hearing procedures rather than Alpha Phi's expedited responsibility-acceptance process. A completed FIJI responsibility finding followed a separate April 19 hearing. Choosing the full hearing is not a later dismissal or successful appeal.
14. April 19 organizational hearing. USD's final sanction letter precisely dates FIJI's hearing April 19, 2016 before the Fraternity/Sorority Life Standards Board. The 2016 hearing minutes and witness statements remained confidential while individual cases were being handled. No individual testimony or unredacted internal packet is published in GLW.
15. April 20 final decision. Katelin Rae, USD assistant director of Fraternity and Sorority Life, signed a final sanction letter April 20 finding Phi Gamma Delta responsible for hazing, alcohol during new-member activity, organizational sexually abusive/inappropriate behavior and chapter officer responsibility under exact sections II.E; II.C.6, 11; II.F.1; III.C. This date is the actual organization outcome day and should not be left imprecise as the earlier Research Library draft did.
16. Formal social-event suspension. The April 20 decision immediately suspended FIJI social events through December 31, 2016. The text explicitly allowed chapter meetings, brotherhood events, the chapter's own philanthropic events and attendance at other chapters' philanthropy. It prohibited co-hosting or co-sponsoring philanthropic events with other chapters. Therefore FIJI was NOT completely expelled from USD or barred from all chapter activity.
17. Fall 2016 recruitment ban. The USD sanction independently prohibited Phi Gamma Delta from participating in membership recruitment during fall 2016. The exclusion covered intake/recruitment as a defined term, separate from the social-event suspension and from later university-recognized status. Original exact fall term dates and enforcement completion have not been found.
18. National membership review required. USD ordered Phi Gamma Delta International to conduct a membership review by September 30, 2016. Members leaving to study abroad during the fall needed review before May 9, 2016. The letter does not report how many chapter members were expelled, their identities, whether national headquarters completed the review on time, or individual student outcomes; no supposed national charter revocation is invented.
19. Anti-hazing/assault education. FIJI was ordered to host an educational program or speaker on one of hazing, bystander intervention or sexual assault by December 20, 2016, with 95% chapter attendance. The required program is documented, but its chosen topic, actual attendee roster and completed compliance report were not publicly recovered. The requirement itself underscores the campus's organizational finding.
20. Other involved chapter—Alpha Phi. USD separately found Alpha Phi Eta Rho responsible under II.E, II.C.6, 11, 12, II.F.1, 2 and III.C and issued an April 14 closure letter, making Alpha Phi eligible to apply for extension no earlier than fall 2019. The university made the sorority's administrative outcome independent of the sanction applied to FIJI. No earlier unverified permanent expulsion is attributed to the fraternity.
21. Alpha Phi's appeal and institutional rejection. Alpha Phi members filed an April 21 appeal contesting procedural fairness and sanction proportionality, signed by 99 members according to the Vista. Cynthia Avery's original May 6 four-page response reviewed its arguments and denied the appeal; the May 11 follow-up reports she relied on the chapter's election to assume responsibility through an expedited hearing. This is Alpha Phi's appeal; FIJI did not separately obtain or lose such an appeal in the reviewed materials.
22. Other involved chapter—Delta Tau Delta. USD's separate April 25 letter documents Delta Tau Delta's April 22 full hearing and responsible findings under II.E and II.C.11 only, with probation through May 31, 2017, a national membership review and two educational sessions. Its sexual-misconduct and chapter-officer allegations were not sustained in the same way as FIJI. The Beta Rho/other DTD chapter's sanctions are NOT added to this FIJI case as if imposed on it.
23. Six FIJI members reportedly involved. In its May 11 story, the Vista quotes FIJI chapter president Jack Kelly confirming six of the fraternity's members were involved. The university supplied 94 total chapter members, of whom 72 were active. These contemporaneous figures describe the FIJI organization in 2016, not the number of assault survivors or persons judicially convicted; the student reporter did not identify six individual offenders.
24. Chapter president contested wording and penalty. In that published interview the president argued FIJI's sanction was too severe relative to the limited number of involved members, objected to the characterization of 'sexual exploitation', and said individual actions were not representative of the whole organization. When asked for a more precise description he declined. His objection is part of the documentary record and does not overturn the university's final sexual-misconduct-related organizational finding.
25. Early May journalism and transparency. The USD Vista published its original multi-source investigation on May 4, 2016 after obtaining and reviewing hearing notices, sanction decisions and Alpha Phi correspondence. Reporters identified that the university did not release confidential FSLSB witness statements or individual disciplinary files. The original article carries a correction concerning the wording of Alpha Phi's II.C.12 rule; that guideline was not a FIJI sustained count.
26. Press interference reported after publication. The Vista's May 11 follow-up says about 3,000 copies of the May 4 edition vanished from distribution racks shortly after release; reporters retrieved some from trash. The article describes threatening and vulgar messages directed at newsroom personnel and Public Safety investigation. No original investigation in the reviewed sources identifies who removed newspapers or sent threats, so GLW does not attribute those acts to FIJI, Alpha Phi, Delta Tau Delta, or any named student.
27. Academic and chronological aftermath. USD's original spring 2024 Fraternity and Sorority Life grade report lists Phi Gamma Delta among fraternity organizations with 89 reported members and 23 new members that semester, reflecting later campus participation. These are 2024 people and membership numbers, not evidence that 2016 participants remained or that the original case was reversed.
28. Current university recognition in 2026. USD's current chapter-specific Phi Gamma Delta webpage lists its Alpha Pi chapter, founded in 2011, as Good Standing–2026; the contemporary IFC directory also lists FIJI. That status establishes later recognition but does not erase the April 20, 2016 responsibility determination or retroactively turn social suspension into permanent expulsion.
29. Historical and current rules. USD publishes its Fraternity and Sorority Guidelines explaining categories for hazing, alcohol, harassment/abusive behavior, officer duties, standard-of-proof requirements and organizational rather than individual discipline. The current online version is useful institutional context but may have undergone revisions since 2016; exact historical 2016 case counts derive from USD's signed 2016 letters, not an assumption that today's section numbering remained unchanged.
30. Individual misconduct is distinct from chapter responsibility. USD's original documents explicitly contemplate a separate student-conduct process for individuals. The known FIJI materials establish organizational findings and university-imposed sanctions, not a named offender list, Title IX investigator outcome, police arrest, criminal judgment, exact consent finding or damages award. The full inquiry's underlying witness reports remain unavailable to this archive.
31. What cannot be inferred from sexual exploitation wording. The March 4 university letter, quoted by the USD Vista, referenced blindfolds and 'sexual exploitation' in connection with these incidents. It did not reveal whether any person was physically touched, photographed, coerced into a particular sexual act, threatened with retaliation, or received emergency care. GLW does not fill those details with imagined victim stories; the proven organizational policy count remains serious.
32. Dates and code accuracy. The February 8 incident date is approximate—the original hearing notice uses 'on or about'. Public reporting of the internal inquiry began late February, the Phi Gamma Delta notice is March 31, hearing April 19, sanction April 20, May 4 initial journalism and May 11 follow-up. The early March 4 Alpha Phi interim action, April 14 Alpha Phi dismissal and April 25 Delta Tau Delta probation belong to other organizations' own procedural records.
33. Missing evidence. The complete FIJI hearing transcript, individual conduct determinations, original witness and survivor interviews, precise chronology of the two individual February events, individual medical or police case numbers, proof of membership-review completion, signed 95% education attendance rosters, and later campus order formally lifting 2016 sanctions were not located in publicly available primary materials. The full original organization outcome is nevertheless documented directly.
34. Preserve identity and avoid unrelated college substitution. The university's own 2026 profile names this FIJI chapter Alpha Pi. SDSU FIJI Sigma Delta's 2019 hazing death and 2020 expulsion and UCSD Phi Gamma Delta's 2019–2020 warning are different chapters/campuses and must never be imported to USD or counted as additional victims in this case. Related Alpha Phi and Delta Tau Delta 2016 proceedings remain distinct student organizations with different sanctioned guideline sections.
35. Victim-centered public accountability. USD's formal hazing and sexually inappropriate organizational findings emerged from new-member activities around February 2016. The institution imposed meaningful but limited restrictions on FIJI while closing Alpha Phi and imposing other sanctions on Delta Tau Delta. The archive makes institutional differences and response to sexual misconduct visible, respects anonymous affected new members and does not replace documented wrongdoing with chapter promotional text.
Original notice says 'on or about Feb8'; FIJI notice includes allegations II.C.12 and II.F.2 absent from FINAL decision. Separate Alpha Phi preliminary action and appeal and Delta Tau Delta probation must not be merged. Six FIJI members reportedly involved per chapter president, not six adjudicated criminal offenders. 2026 status good standing doesn't erase 2016 findings.
Recorded outcome
FIJI social-event suspension immediately through Dec31 2016 (not complete chapter closure); fall 2016 recruitment excluded; national membership review deadline Sept30 (May9 for fall study-abroad); one education program with 95% attendance by Dec20 2016. Separate Alpha Phi closure and Delta Tau Delta probation not attributed to FIJI.
Phi Gamma Delta at University of San Diego
San Diego
CA