University of Delaware Sigma Alpha Mu (Delta Lambda) — Brett Griffin's 2008 Fatal Alcohol Poisoning, $50,000 Hazing Fine and 2013 Civil Verdict

Brett J. Griffin, 18, a University of Delaware freshman and Sigma Alpha Mu Delta Lambda pledge, died November 8, 2008 of acute alcohol poisoning following a fraternity Big Brother Night at 28 Annabelle Street, Newark. Newark Police documented a 2:52 a.m. 911 call and emergency resuscitation; later trial coverage reported blood alcohol 0.341. Six students were separately arrested in March 2009 for alcohol/drug-related charges, and the local chapter was charged with misdemeanor hazing and received a reported $50,000 judicial fine after nonappearance. Brett's parents sued the national and local fraternity and seven members (Delaware Superior Court 09C-04-067). Most defendants reached private settlements. On November 15, 2013 a jury found former chapter president Jason Aaron and former pledge master Matthew Siracusa not liable for his death; detailed contemporary reporting says the jury found Siracusa hazed Griffin but did not find the hazing proximately caused his death.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning University of Delaware Sigma Alpha Mu (Delta Lambda) — Brett Griffin's 2008 Fatal Alcohol Poisoning, $50,000 Hazing Fine and 2013 Civil Verdict. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 13, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Original 911 and fatality[02] Separate individual arrests[03] Family files wrongful-death case[04] Chapter hazing fine[05] Police evidence privilege opinion[06] Procedural case opinion[07] Texts and testimony[08] Civil deliberations[09] Jury verdict and hazing finding[10] Historical chapter relationship verified[11] 6abc: Delta Lambda chapter charged with hazing in March 2009[12] University of Delaware The Review original November 2008 campus report[13] Associated Press report on November 2013 civil trial allegations and defense[14] UD The Review November 19 2013 original campus civil outcome reporting[15] Associated Press November 15 2013 civil jury verdict[16] Fraternal Law: chapter judicially fined $50,000 for hazing
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Original 911 and fatalityNewark Police DepartmentPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictNovember 8, 2008

Newark Police reports 2:52 a.m. emergency, cardiopulmonary arrest, hospital death

[02]Separate individual arrestsNewark Police via University of DelawarePolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictMarch 27, 2009

Six members or pledges arrested on alcohol/drug-related charges; final individual dispositions not established

[03]Family files wrongful-death caseThe Review / Brittany HarmonPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictMay 19, 2009

Parents' April 2009 suit challenges fraternity alcohol safeguards and emergency response

[04]Chapter hazing fineChild Injury Lawyer NetworkPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictDecember 4, 2009

Legal reports confirm organizational $50,000 judicial fine after nonappearance; not settlement

[05]Police evidence privilege opinionDelaware Superior CourtPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictApril 26, 2011

Original court opinion addresses release of criminal-investigation evidence; not liability ruling

[06]Procedural case opinionDelaware Superior CourtPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictMarch 15, 2012

Court documents nine original defendants and multistate discovery, not causation merits

[07]Texts and testimonyDelmarva Public Media / Don RushPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictNovember 7, 2013

Court testimony covers incapacitated pledges and concerns regarding medical danger

[08]Civil deliberationsAssociated Press / CBS PhiladelphiaPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictNovember 14, 2013

Jury weighs hazing and causal responsibility, defense denies compulsion

[09]Jury verdict and hazing findingHNGNPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictNovember 15, 2013

Neither remaining defendant liable for death; Siracusa hazed Griffin per detailed reporting but not proximate cause

[10]Historical chapter relationship verifiedDelaware Superior CourtPolice, criminal organization outcome, procedural court or civil verdictNovember 13, 2026

Canonical Delta Lambda chapter linked; its current campus recognition is unverified

[11]6abc: Delta Lambda chapter charged with hazing in March 20096abc / WPVIPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingMay 21, 2009

Chapter hazing charge; July 27 arraignment scheduled; six individual arrests are separate

[12]University of Delaware The Review original November 2008 campus reportThe Review / Samantha BrixPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingNovember 18, 2008

28 Annabelle residence was off-campus and not officially a fraternity house; approximately 40 people

[13]Associated Press report on November 2013 civil trial allegations and defenseAssociated Press / Legal NewsPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingNovember 7, 2013

Trial arguments over coerced food/drink pledge rituals, chapter leadership, and voluntary alcohol consumption defense

[14]UD The Review November 19 2013 original campus civil outcome reportingThe Review / Matt ButlerPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingNovember 19, 2013

Original campus student-newspaper report after individual liability trial

[15]Associated Press November 15 2013 civil jury verdictAssociated Press / CBS PhiladelphiaPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingNovember 15, 2013

Aaron and Siracusa not found civilly liable for Griffin death; national and other defendants previously settled

[16]Fraternal Law: chapter judicially fined $50,000 for hazingFraternal LawPrimary record or contemporary attributed reportingDate not recorded

Chapter misdemeanor hazing charge and $50,000 fine after nonappearance; separate from civil settlement

Case context & supporting details

Case file

University of Delaware Sigma Alpha Mu (Delta Lambda) — Brett Griffin's 2008 Fatal Alcohol Poisoning, $50,000 Hazing Fine and 2013 Civil Verdict

Sigma Alpha Mu at University of Delaware · DE

Reporting basis
2008 original Newark Police release; University of Delaware 2009 police arrests; Delaware Superior Court 2011 and 2012 original rulings; contemporaneous AP November 2013 trial and verdict; Fraternal Law $50,000 fine; UD The Review original reports
Incident type
Fatal alcohol poisoning after Big Brother Night; chapter misdemeanor hazing fine; family civil wrongful-death case
Allegation status
Organizational hazing charged and judicial fine reported; civil family's allegations of coercion and delayed care; 2013 jury hazing finding regarding Siracusa but no proximate cause or wrongful-death liability
Investigation status
Police death inquiry; March 2009 six separate alcohol/drug arrests; local chapter misdemeanor hazing prosecution and fine
Legal status
Chapter-level misdemeanor hazing fine of $50,000; private civil settlements with fraternity and some members; November 15 2013 jury finds Aaron and Siracusa not liable for death
Incident start date
2008-11-07
Incident end date
2008-11-08

Separate police arrests, chapter hazing prosecution, private settlements and 2013 individual jury verdict. Historical chapter publication does not imply present recognition.