Case file
University at Buffalo Sigma Pi (Epsilon-Omicron) — Sebastian Serafin-Bazan, 2019 Fatal Suspected Hazing, Disciplinary Findings and $665,000 Civil Settlement
Sigma Pi at University at Buffalo · NY
- Reporting basis
- UB first-party April 2019, August 2019, April and August 2020 announcements; Sigma Pi April 2019 original national statement; Erie County DA no-charge statement through local reporting; Westchester 2021 verified complaint index 57952/2020 and September 2023 Spectrum independent court review
- Incident type
- Fatal physical-exertion hazing allegations; cardiac arrest, student death and reported blunt-force injuries; university student-conduct discipline; civil wrongful-death settlement
- Allegation status
- Death following reported cardiac arrest confirmed; alleged compelled calisthenics and delayed aid attributed to police records/civil allegations; UB several-student discipline later confirmed but not count/person-specific; prosecutor closed criminal case without charges
- Investigation status
- Buffalo Police completed criminal investigation and Erie County DA declined charges Apr 2020; UB opened conduct proceedings against eight Aug 2020 and confirmed several disciplined by 2023; chapter charter revoked Jan 2020; private-party civil claims settled Aug 2023, separate state claim status unknown
- Legal status
- No criminal charges filed; university acknowledged student conduct discipline without individual names/sanctions; national Sigma Pi chapter charter revoked January 2020; $665,000 civil settlement with six private defendants Aug 2023; separate claim against NY State/UB reported pending in 2023
- Incident start date
- 2019-04-11
- Incident end date
- 2019-04-17
Account
01. Case identity, chapter and victim
Sebastian Serafin-Bazan was an 18-year-old freshman at the University at Buffalo, a graduate of Port Chester High School and a Sigma Pi Epsilon-Omicron prospective member. He suffered a medical emergency early April 12, 2019 and died in Buffalo General Medical Center on April 17, 2019. UB and Sigma Pi original April 2019 statements identify him and the chapter. The case concerns that single fatal episode, the resulting investigation, university conduct findings, the fraternity's loss of recognition and the family's civil litigation.
02. Evening of April 11 and early April 12 activity
University Police records obtained by The Spectrum and statements recounted in contemporary Buffalo news describe prospective members ordered to perform extended physical exercises inside the Sigma Pi house at 69 Custer Street in Buffalo, from Thursday evening April 11 through Friday early April 12. Exercises included burpees or similar calisthenics. The original investigative interviews and the full surveillance file are not available in the reviewed public sources, so descriptions of specific orders are attributed to police-interview-based reporting.
03. Reported physical pressure in the chapter-house basement
The Spectrum's 2023 review of police records reports pledges were directed to do burpees in the basement. Sebastian was described as exhausted, ill, and having difficulty after a sustained period of exercise. The mother's lawsuit alleges coercive and degrading treatment and a failure to supervise the medical risk. Reporting of an organizational hazing pattern is not a criminal conviction, because the Erie County DA declined charges.
04. Prior respiratory illness reported by neighbors
Contemporaneous neighbors told reporters that Sebastian had recently suffered a respiratory illness or infection. That reported context may be medically relevant but is not a proven signed autopsy diagnosis or a license to blame Sebastian's health. No exact disease, treatment regimen or causal contribution is established in the public medical records obtained for this review.
05. Reported fall and head impact
Contemporaneous reporting said the student collapsed or fell and struck his head on a coffee table inside the fraternity house. Neighbors recalled fraternity members explaining that he had been taken outdoors for fresh air. This is police/neighbor account information, not a complete forensic reconstruction. The Spectrum later stated an Erie County medical examiner autopsy listed blunt impact injuries on several parts of the body.
06. Student discovered in front yard
Buffalo Police and University at Buffalo say Sebastian was found unresponsive on the lawn of the fraternity-associated Custer Street house early Friday, April 12. The contemporaneous report calls this a cardiac arrest and states he was transported for emergency treatment. The case does not substitute the moment of collapse or arrest for the date of death.
07. Emergency response, medical crisis and hospitalization
First responders treated Sebastian after reported cardiac arrest, and he was hospitalized at Buffalo General Medical Center in critical condition. UB identified him publicly April 13 but did not provide personal medical records because of privacy obligations. Some 2019 headlines mistakenly described him as already dead immediately after the first event; the university and subsequent hospital reporting establish the April 17 fatality.
08. April 17 confirmed death
On Wednesday April 17, 2019, UB President Satish Tripathi announced Sebastian's death after five days of hospital care. Sigma Pi national headquarters posted condolences the same day and reiterated the chapter's provisional suspension. A death occurring days after the initiation event is one fatal case, not two separate incidents.
09. Toxicology: no alcohol or drugs detected in preliminary reporting
Police and local reporting in 2019 said preliminary toxicology did not find alcohol or drugs in Sebastian's system. The legal record therefore should not characterize his death as drinking or alcohol poisoning, nor import other universities' fraternity alcohol cases. The final signed Erie County autopsy and toxicology report were not retrieved; 'none detected' is attributed to contemporary reports rather than declared an independent laboratory verification.
10. Reported autopsy injuries
The Spectrum's September 2023 investigation cites an Erie County medical examiner autopsy describing blunt-force injuries to Sebastian's head, chest and extremities. Other civil-complaint reporting identifies bruising to the back, arms and scalp and rectal ulcer findings. These descriptions are taken from journalist-reviewed medical and court documents, and the archive does not infer a particular instrument, perpetrator, intentional sexual assault or precise source of each injury without corresponding findings.
11. Cardiac arrest versus independently identified cause of death
Cardiac arrest is the emergency described in police records. No complete final signed medical-examiner report giving a separately verified causal diagnosis or official manner-of-death classification was obtained in this pass. The archive reports the medically serious collapse, trauma evidence in published autopsy reporting and death five days later, but does not manufacture a definitive medical mechanism beyond those reliable public accounts.
12. April 12–17 Sigma Pi national temporary suspension
Sigma Pi Fraternity International's original April 17 notice identifies the chapter as Epsilon-Omicron and says national headquarters placed it on temporary suspension as soon as the April 12 incident was reported. The fraternity said it would cooperate with Buffalo Police and university officials. That initial measure is different from the later January 2020 charter revocation.
13. April 2019 UB Greek-life moratorium
President Tripathi ordered a broad suspension of official Greek-letter fraternity and sorority activities in April 2019, pending university review of policies, practices and hazing prevention. This campus-wide measure prohibited new-member events and other official activities for months. The later decision to restore other chapters' activities did not revive Sigma Pi's status.
14. UB's August 21, 2019 systemic reforms
A university Greek Life Review Committee, chaired by Suzanne Rosenblith, issued 14 reforms on oversight, early warning and reporting, training, hazing definitions and public disciplinary scorecards. The August 21 statement lifted the general Greek-life pause for all but one organization, which continued to face separate restrictions. This was a campus-wide regulatory response to Sebastian's death, not a new personal disciplinary finding.
15. January 2020 national charter revocation and UB nonrecognition
UB's August 2020 original announcement states that Sigma Pi International revoked Epsilon-Omicron's national charter in January 2020 and that the chapter was no longer a recognized fraternity at UB. This original university statement is the clearest dated authority for formal charter termination. A current campus page may omit the ceased chapter from a list of groups attempting to operate unrecognized; absence from that particular list does not reinstate it.
16. April 2020 DA closes the criminal investigation
After Buffalo Police completed their investigation, Erie County District Attorney John Flynn's office confirmed on or about April 7–8, 2020 that it would not file criminal charges in Sebastian's death. The absence of prosecution is accurately recorded. The university's separate disciplinary process and family's civil claims proceeded under different standards and are not rewritten as criminal convictions.
17. August 24, 2020 UB initiates conduct proceedings against eight students
After reviewing Buffalo Police interviews, University Police and UB Student Conduct found enough information to initiate misconduct proceedings concerning suspected hazing against eight students. UB explicitly said final sanctions could only follow substantiated violations under its preponderance standard. The August 2020 announcement is a formal investigative/charging stage, not a published adjudication against all eight.
18. By September 2023 UB confirms several students disciplined
The Spectrum obtained a September 2023 statement from UB communications confirming that several students were disciplined for student code violations after the institutional investigation. UB declined to provide the students' names, exact number, offense breakdown or penalties because of federal student privacy rules. One former chapter member separately said three students were suspended; that is his account, not a university-confirmed count.
19. Civil wrongful-death action filed July 31, 2020
Sebastian's mother Juana Correa, individually and as estate administrator, filed a New York Supreme Court, Westchester County civil action on July 31, 2020, index 57952/2020, against chapter and national fraternity entities, the property owner, students and other named parties. The later August 26, 2021 second amended verified complaint, NYSCEF document 129, states detailed negligence, premises liability and failure-to-protect allegations. These are plaintiff allegations, not court findings of individual criminal wrongdoing.
20. Claim of delayed treatment and prior chapter risk
The civil complaint alleged that participants and property owner allowed dangerous hazing and did not obtain prompt appropriate medical treatment, notwithstanding prior concerns about fraternity activity. The available court docket text and police-interview-based news support the filing and pleaded accusations; they do not establish that every named defendant personally directed every exercise or knew Sebastian's precise medical condition.
21. Who was named in the civil pleadings
The complaint names Sigma Pi national and Epsilon-Omicron, UB Heights Housing LLC and multiple individuals described as fraternity officers or tenants, as well as university/state defendants in the family dispute. Public naming in pleadings is not itself evidence that each defendant participated in hazing or settled. The archive separately identifies three individuals who paid documented amounts in the 2023 compromise and does not create a supposed fraternity-wide criminal roster.
22. 2021 second amended complaint and insurance/cross-claims
The August 26, 2021 verified amended complaint carries Westchester index 57952/2020 and NZSCEF document 129. The national organization filed answers to cross-claims in August 2021 disputing allegations. This is ordinary adversarial civil litigation, not judicial proof that the fraternity was innocent or liable. Earlier claims against one student named Yuvraj Tiwari were dismissed in January 2022, according to The Spectrum; no adverse finding against him is asserted.
23. August 15, 2023 private-defendant settlement order
A Westchester County Supreme Court order filed August 15, 2023 concluded the civil action as to the national fraternity, local Epsilon-Omicron, property owner and three former members for a combined $665,000. The Spectrum independently reviewed court documents and published the confirmed breakdown September 6. The amount is the private-party wrongful-death settlement, not a jury damages verdict, fine or university payment.
24. Exact breakdown of the 2023 $665,000 settlement
The Spectrum reports $274,000 by Sigma Pi national, $206,000 by the Epsilon-Omicron chapter, $125,000 by Joshua Harasimowicz, $40,000 by Ethan Grauer, $5,000 by Ian Buchman and $15,000 by UB Heights Housing LLC. Those six contributions total exactly $665,000. Payment reflects settlement of civil claims and is not a determination that any particular participant committed a criminal offense.
25. Separate $20 million state/university claim
As of September 2023, the mother was pursuing a separate roughly $20 million wrongful-death claim against the State of New York and UB in the New York Court of Claims. Its existence and unresolved status were reported independently of the private-defendant settlement. A March 2025 New York Law Journal calendar also lists Westchester index 57952/20, but is not a dispositive ruling. No reliable final judgment or settlement of the separate state claim was found; it should remain unverified rather than deemed resolved.
26. Impact on university recognition and national franchise
The charter revocation and loss of UB recognition continue to be supported by original 2020 UB public statements and the national fraternity's initial 2019 notice. The current university public 'unrecognized groups' page lists groups attempting to function locally, not a comprehensive historical registry of every abolished chapter; Sigma Pi is absent there but also not listed as a currently recognized chapter. The existing Northeast chapter row is updated in place and remains Published strictly as a historical case record.
27. Medical records and lawsuit evidence not independently filed in this archive
The original Erie County signed autopsy, Buffalo Police full interviews and body-camera/911 records, photograph and incident reconstruction, actual August 15, 2023 signed settlement order, individual UB conduct decision letters and any final Court of Claims judgment have not been physically obtained. The archive cites contemporaneous UB releases, national HQ statements, the public amended pleading index and independently reported settlement records, while keeping allegations and institutional findings separated.
28. Personal history and public memorial
Sebastian was originally from Peru and arrived in the United States as a child; he graduated from Port Chester High School in Westchester County in 2018 and studied medical technology at UB. Contemporary university statements and the 2023 UB student newspaper's victim profile recognize his life and family. This section does not disclose private family contact information or suggest that a fraternity's reputation is the central issue.
29. Why this is a single distinct case
The April 11–12 2019 hazing-related medical incident, April 17 death, 2020 criminal non-prosecution, later university discipline, January 2020 charter revocation and August 2023 civil settlement form one continuous case file. Future reporting of the separate New York State claim belongs as an update to this case, not a second duplicate death case. Other Sigma Pi incidents elsewhere, including the unrelated Ohio University death, are not merged into Sebastian's record.
No BAC/alcohol poisoning allegation: preliminary toxicology negative for alcohol/drugs. Cardiac arrest reported, final signed medical cause unavailable. Blunt injuries are from journalist's autopsy reporting and court descriptions; no particular assault inferred. August 2020 conduct cases were pending but 2023 UB confirmed some disciplinary actions, details protected. Westchester $665k partial settlement vs separate state claim clearly distinct.
Recorded outcome
Death Apr17 2019, five days after overnight physically demanding alleged hazing. Police closed case without prosecution Apr2020. National chapter charter revoked Jan2020; UB confirmed several disciplined students by Sep2023. Aug2023 $665,000 settlement (national $274k, local $206k, 3 former members $170k, property owner $15k); separate state claim final resolution unverified.
Sigma Pi at University at Buffalo
Epsilon-Omicron
Buffalo
NY