Case file
UCF Alpha Epsilon Pi (Nu Delta) — Fall 2019 Hazing, Physical Abuse and Degrading Pledge Practices; 2020 UCF Investigation, Interim Suspension and Disaffiliation
Alpha Epsilon Pi at University of Central Florida · FL
- Reporting basis
- Original UCF Office of Student Conduct investigator April17 2020 redacted investigative summary containing 31 surveys and 17 interviews; KnightNews May15 original reporter's analysis and quotes from AEPi/National; UCF official present chapter statuses and original Sep1 2021 signed family notice; WFTV March21 2013 prior adjudicated case; AEPi national historical Nu Delta roll; UCF organization conduct procedural rules.
- Incident type
- University investigation found preponderance evidence hazing occurred; interim suspension and voluntary disaffiliation before verified final hearing
- Allegation status
- OSC investigator found under preponderance standard a hazing EVENT and other misconduct occurred; recommended 22 code subprovisions for formal review. No authenticated final chapter hearing order on each charge; eyewitness corroboration of slapping/trust activity/binders amid disputed severe forced-consumption claims; reported unwanted sexual touching not final Title IX adjudication.
- Investigation status
- Anonymous Feb27 2020 report; Feb28 UCF interim suspension, 31 surveys and 17 witness interviews; Apr17 UCF investigator recommends formal disciplinary review. May14 voluntary disaffiliation prior to verified final June hearing. Current UCF lists unrecognized, suspension through Spring2022 historically.
- Legal status
- Formal university investigatory evidence and interim protection, national-backed voluntary disaffiliation May2020; no final post-investigation organizational responsibility verdict or individual criminal conviction verified for 2020 case. Separate March2013 prior accepted-responsibility hazing sanction through Summer2014.
Account
01. Correct entity and lead. Alpha Epsilon Pi (AEPi) NU DELTA chapter historically affiliated with University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida. The incident is FALL 2019 new-member experiences investigated during Spring2020, followed by MAY2020 voluntary withdrawal from UCF. AEPi's own national chapter roll identifies Orlando Nu Delta as founded in 2000 and warns its list includes historically chartered groups regardless of campus recognition. Existing South chapter ID chap_alpha_epsilon_pi_university_of_central_florida reused.
02. Investigative authority and document. The primary document is UCF Office of Student Conduct (OSC) Assistant Director Xavier Shannon's REDACTED original internal investigative summary dated APRIL17, 2020, addressed to director Michael Gilmer. Independent KnightNews journalists acquired and posted the document in May2020. It gives incident categories, the report narrative, chronology, 31 student surveys, 17 witness interviews, investigator findings and recommended formal charges.
03. Date integrity. The alleged misconduct spanned FALL2019, with some witnesses describing Spring2020 new-member practices. UCF received its original complainant report FEBRUARY27, 2020, imposed interim organizational suspension FEBRUARY28, completed investigative memo APRIL17, and chapter leadership gave notice of withdrawal around MAY14. The 2013 disciplinary action is a separate episode. Exact individual Fall2019 activity days are not independently identified by the redacted report.
04. Initial anonymous complainant and safety concern. A person who said he was a member or new member provided 18 pictures, seven videos and a detailed timeline, describing fear of retaliation and a desire to protect other pledges. The university released the account in redacted form; do not attempt to identify that person, any woman mentioned, or the interviewed members. The photographs/videos themselves were not available for direct independent content verification.
05. Alleged coerced alcohol and drug exposure. The complainant described offering potential recruits alcohol and marijuana to influence joining, underage drinking, forced chugging, being ordered to drink bong water, vinegar shots and disgusting food mixtures, including a blended drink with cooking spray. These are COMPLAINANT ALLEGATIONS and require comparison with the 17 later interviews rather than asserting every described act was sustained.
06. Alleged physical assault and intimidation. The initial report said brothers assaulted pledges, physically threatened anyone revealing misconduct and selected intimidating members to deliver warnings. Some witnesses later corroborated ritual slapping and verbal pressure, while others denied violent/forced hazing. No individual criminal assault conviction appears in the original report.
07. Degrading binder requirement. Both the original complaint and several independent interviewees said pledges were REQUIRED to assemble binders of pornography by categories and bring them during interviews/meetings. Several members called this an icebreaker or a joke, but the practice itself was consistently described in witness interviews. The investigator specifically identified the binder as a concern.
08. Pledge interviewing as control mechanism. According to the report, new members were tasked with interviewing initiated brothers, often asked to complete 'favors' such as obtaining food, buying supplies, performing cleanup or consuming items. Multiple interviewees described an expectation that refusing tasks could lead to being 'balled'—removed from the pledge process.
09. Burden and sleep deprivation allegations. The complainant described back-to-back meetings and late-night tasks until 2 a.m., early morning assignments and little sleep. A witness reported spending 25 or more hours weekly at the fraternity house and suffering academic stress and threatened scholarship eligibility. These are sourced student accounts, not independently obtained academic or medical records.
10. UCF interim suspension. The original investigative timeline explicitly says OSC imposed INTERIM ORGANIZATIONAL SUSPENSION on FEBRUARY28, 2020 because of severity of the allegations. An interim restriction protects campus community during review and is NOT the same as completed formal responsibility adjudication or a national charter withdrawal.
11. Initial university evidence collection. On February28, 2020, UCF obtained 31 written surveys from new members, pledges and former pledges in the Neptune Community. The investigator wrote that initial survey results did not support the full anonymous report, which led investigators to conduct follow-up interviews. That contradictory evidence must be preserved rather than erased from historical investigation.
12. Subsequent 17 witness interviews. The university named interviewees only by redacted witness numbers and summarized 17 conversations spanning Fall2019 and Spring2020 pledges and chapter executives. Interview responses diverged on whether participation was voluntary, whether drug use was restricted in formal pledge meetings and which members engaged in abusive acts.
13. Face-slapping at Big/Little reveal independently confirmed. Witnesses described pledges being SLAPPED during introductions to assigned big brothers. One witness said he was shocked; another said all or most pledges were slapped as a family tradition. Other witnesses denied being slapped. The investigator's conclusion highlighted independent testimony of face-slapping—distinct from unproven claims that every member physically assaulted every new member.
14. Deceptive Trust Activity. Multiple witnesses described a fraternity-controlled exercise where pledges were led to believe shot glasses held alcohol or water when the cups contained salt water, vinegar, ordinary water or other liquids. Witnesses differed in whether this was humiliating, unsafe or an educational trust exercise. The university investigator explicitly considered the DECEPTION significant.
15. Bong-water allegation disputed. Witness Five said he saw a brother compel a pledge to drink water left after smoking marijuana; another witness denied the allegation, saying he had consumed it and invented the story. The investigator recorded these contradictions rather than deciding the specific allegation was definitively established. GLW preserves the seriously reported incident without presenting it as a final judicial finding.
16. Force-fed blended drink and other consumption allegations. One interviewee described a pledge required to drink a disgusting shake made from assorted foods for the purpose of making the pledge sick. Others referenced vinegar, alcohol, maple-syrup family traditions and alleged marijuana use. These are detailed investigative witness statements with varying firsthand basis; no medical hospitalization or toxicology outcome is established from the disclosed summary.
17. Underage alcohol and marijuana activity. Multiple student interviewees admitted seeing underage drinking and marijuana use in or associated with the chapter house, including some by chapter leaders. Some distinguished a purported 'dry' formal pledge process from recreational member activity; others described chapter-sponsored social events with minors drinking. UCF's investigator treated alcohol/drug allegations as part of the broader recommended formal charges.
18. Member duties and involuntary labor. Several witnesses described carrying large water containers, buying food for fraternity members, cleaning the house and cars, home maintenance and other menial services under membership pressure. Witness Five described pledges as being treated like slaves in the amount of labor expected. These are attributed first-person experiences, not an invented slavery-related legal claim.
19. Compulsory visits to adult-entertainment venue reported. Multiple witnesses said the pledge class traveled to Lido's Cabaret and was given entertainment money. Some disagreed whether the trip was officially sponsored, allowed refusal or was simply group recreation. UCF recorded this controversy but did not publish a final venue-specific misconduct adjudication.
20. Member fear of removal and retaliation. A complainant described threats for reporting fraternity practices; witnesses independently acknowledged fear of being removed from the fraternity if they refused requests. These accounts matter when interpreting why survey responses and witness narratives diverged. Do not claim a named person committed criminal retaliation without specific findings.
21. Separate unwanted sexual touching allegation. The anonymous reporter alleged a pledge touched a woman's breast during a photo at a fraternity party and that chapter officers warned pledges/brothers not to speak about an alleged 'Title IX' matter. Another interviewee independently referred to unwanted touching and claimed the chapter tried to conceal it. The record does NOT contain a university Title IX case decision, the woman's personal statement, a charge disposition, or a criminal conviction, and no person's identity is exposed. The claim is accurately labeled a reported sexual-misconduct allegation, not a verified adjudicated offense.
22. Investigator's finding under preponderance. In the formal CONCLUSION dated Apr17, UCF OSC wrote it believed, on a 'preponderance of the evidence', a HAZING EVENT and other organizational rule violations occurred during Fall2019. The report recommends bringing the matter into the FORMAL REVIEW PROCESS. This is a substantive investigative conclusion stronger than an anonymous tip but not equivalent to a final responsibility hearing decision.
23. Formal charge recommendation was broad. The investigator's original summary enumerates 22 recommended code subprovisions under theft/misuse of property, false/misleading information, disruptive conduct, harmful behavior, alcohol, drugs and hazing; including Hazing 10a–10f and harmful-behavior threats/physical violence. These are PROPOSED organizational charges; the university did not publish final per-count outcomes for the withdrawn organization's proceedings.
24. Timing of planned hearing. KnightNews May15, 2020 reported a FORMAL DISCIPLINARY HEARING was expected in June2020 and that the investigative memo supported it, but AEPi withdrew its university affiliation before a completed final institutional adjudication could be located. Neither the initial 31 surveys nor the detailed investigator conclusion should be misrepresented as a jury verdict.
25. May14, 2020 withdrawal. Contemporary KnightNews reported AEPi sent UCF a letter on Thursday May14 announcing voluntary DISAFFILIATION with the university, criticizing what the chapter called procedural unfairness. That is the organization's stated rationale; it does not itself reverse the OSC preponderance conclusion or prove that allegations were invented.
26. National fraternity supported off-campus continuation. An AEPi international former president stated headquarters would support Nu Delta's mission and comply with national health/safety rules outside UCF. The university's authority over OFFICIALLY RECOGNIZED campus fraternity activity ceased, while privately organized alumni/student activity remained possible. This is not a restored UCF chapter registration.
27. University retrospective suspension notation. UCF's current official FSL chapter-status page places AEPi under UNRECOGNIZED GROUPS, records 'May 2020 Voluntary disaffiliation' and 'suspension through Spring 2022.' It gives no dated final UCF Spring2022 disciplinary order, so the entry is accurately attributed as university status notation rather than a signed post-withdrawal hearing verdict.
28. September1, 2021 university family warning. In an ORIGINAL signed UCF letter, interim VP Adrienne Frame explicitly states AEPi is not a university-registered chapter and cannot participate in IFC or UCF FSL sponsored programs, co-sponsor with recognized campus Greek organizations, participate in official activities or intramurals, reserve campus space, or use university branding. The same notice names unrelated Sigma Pi and Gazoni Family groups separately.
29. Current campus recognition status remains absent in 2026. The university's live status index still lists AEPi under the unrecognized organizations, and its recognized IFC roster omits AEPi. There is no current publicly verified UCF reinstatement, regardless of the nationally listed 'Orlando Nu Delta' chapter.
30. Headquarters historical chapter roll and status distinction. The AEPi International chapter roll gives Nu Delta Orlando charter year 2000, while its own disclaimer states that listed chapters include ALL historical colonizations and do NOT imply current UNIVERSITY recognition. National listing alone cannot override a UCF disaffiliation notice or affirm present 2026 operation.
31. Separate documented 2013 hazing adjudication. On March21, 2013, WFTV reported campus LETTERS showed AEPi accepted responsibility for HAZING, DISRUPTIVE CONDUCT, HARMFUL BEHAVIOR and alcohol misconduct, with campus suspension through SUMMER 2014 and required anti-hazing programming. This is an earlier, independent adjudicated organizational episode, not part of the Fall2019 preliminary hearing. The related Sigma Chi drinking-photograph story was a different fraternity and must not be attributed to AEPi.
32. 2013 separate incident deserving its own case. University paperwork from 2013 and exact hazing methods should be retrieved for future standalone case research. This GLW-REF-404 card retains the 2013 finding as accurately distinguished history but does not manufacture a duplicate, unsourced 2013 hazing death or claim all chapters' penalties identical.
33. No survivor or accused-person identification. The original UCF report redacts witness names and the student complainant said he hid his identity for safety. GLW does not deanonymize the complainant, witness numbers or woman mentioned in sexual misconduct allegation, nor list identifiable current members as personally responsible for 2019 behavior.
34. Records still to obtain. Seek the 18 submitted photographs and seven videos from UCF with appropriate privacy/redaction, original Feb27 complaint, all 31 written surveys, underlying 17 interviews or signed transcripts, February28 interim order, full April17 investigative memo if any attachments omitted from public copy, any June2020 hearing file or closure memo, withdrawal letter and exact campus national recognition correspondence through 2026.
35. Pro-victim accountability. The university's own investigator concluded sufficient evidence that hazing occurred, witnesses documented ritual physical humiliation and coercive fraternity chores, and the chapter left the university ahead of a reported hearing. This evidence deserves detailed public scrutiny even without a later completed formal verdict. Record confirmed investigator findings and serious reported member harms without conflating initial allegations with every sustained charge.
36. Research and publication integrity. UCF Alpha Epsilon Pi Nu Delta GLW-REF-404 is distinct from USF AEPi Psi Phi, University of Florida AEPi Phi Gamma, other UCF chapters, and separate UCF AEPi 2013 action. Existing South UCF chapter row2490 is corrected, not duplicated. The Research Library is marked Transferred only AFTER the South case, linked primary report, events and updates are read back.
2020 original UCF evidence summary concludes hazing occurred, but pending formal charges are not same as finalized administrative adjudication. Initial negative 31 surveys and conflicting witness accounts expressly documented; specific alleged sex-related incident not a verified Title IX finding. 2013 accepted responsibility is separate university case. National historic chapter listing not proof UCF recognition.
Recorded outcome
Following interim suspension and an investigator's preponderance conclusion recommending formal hazing and other code charges, Nu Delta withdrew UCF recognition around May14 2020. UCF's official registry lists AEPi unrecognized and suspension through Spring2022, and signed university Sep1 2021 letter confirms no campus/IFC privileges; national roll retains Nu Delta as historical Orlando chapter.
Alpha Epsilon Pi at University of Central Florida
Nu Delta
Orlando
FL