Case file
UC Merced Pi Lambda Phi (California Alpha Upsilon) — 2022 Hazing, Threats and Substance Violations; 2023 Four-Year Closure
Pi Lambda Phi at University of California, Merced · CA
- Reporting basis
- Original UC Merced 2022–23 Conduct Findings (updated Feb 12 2025); signed UC Merced–Pi Lambda Phi institutional close-and-return agreement Aug 4 2023; UC Merced chapter and unrecognized registry (updated Sep22 2026); Pi Lambda Phi official chapter locator/expansion roadmap; UC Merced Fall2022 and Spring2023 official fraternity reports.
- Incident type
- Sustained university organizational hazing, safety/threats, harassment, drug/alcohol and obstruction findings; subsequent chapter closure
- Allegation status
- Ten organization-level findings in 2022 under UC Merced code provisions including hazing, broad assault/threat/safety category, harassment, controlled substances, alcohol, dishonesty, obstruction, rule violations and prior conduct action. Individual underlying methods and physical assault claims not itemized.
- Investigation status
- Official conduct register lists Deferred Suspension Sep22 2022 to Oct1 2024 and responsibility Oct1 2022 (chronology unexplained); international fraternity ceased chapter operations under signed Aug4 2023 four-year closure/return plan; no recognized return documented Nov2026.
- Legal status
- Organizational administrative conduct responsibility, deferred university suspension and later international chapter cessation; no verified individual criminal conviction, court judgment or personal injury award.
Account
01. Chapter and incident identification. GLW-REF-137 concerns the California Alpha Upsilon chapter of Pi Lambda Phi at the University of California, Merced (UC Merced), not Pi Kappa Phi or an unrelated Pi Lambda Phi chapter at San Francisco State. The original UC Merced Fraternity and Sorority Life conduct-finding register records TEN separate organizational code violations associated with a 2022 conduct proceeding. The university and the national fraternity later negotiated a four-year closure/restart arrangement in August 2023, preserved as a subsequent organizational outcome in this one published case.
02. Original institution-level findings control the facts. UC Merced's 2022–23 Conduct Findings listing specifically identifies Pi Lambda Phi as responsible on October 1, 2022 under provisions 702.08, 702.00, 702.02, 702.09, 702.12, 702.13, 702.16, 702.17, 702.18 and 702.21. This is a completed university organizational responsibility finding, not an anonymous internet complaint or assumption inferred from the chapter's later closure. The official public listing supplies policy categories but no detailed narrative of each incident.
03. Important distinction in institutional chronology. The conduct page specifies a DEFERRED suspension from September 22, 2022 through October 1, 2024 while separately reporting organizational responsibility on October 1, 2022. The starting date precedes the responsibility date as the original page states; the public source does not reconcile the administrative sequence. Neither is established as the actual first day a student was hazed, threatened or exposed to alcohol or controlled substances.
04. The original incident period is not established to a specific day. Although the findings appear in the 2022–23 academic year, the campus page does not disclose the underlying offenses' first/last date, location, witness chronology, investigative start date, medical treatment dates or precise complaint filing day. Incident Start Date and Incident End Date are deliberately left blank. The reported October 1, 2022 responsible date is recorded as the institutional decision date, not a manufactured offense date.
05. Sustained hazing — Code 702.12. The university specifically marked Pi Lambda Phi responsible for hazing. That substantive finding means the organization's treatment of members or prospective members met the institution's hazing prohibition; it is not a generalized assumption about fraternity culture. However, no original institution-specific incident account establishes paddling, forced eating, exercise, blindfolding, sexual simulation, confinement, deprivation or coerced alcohol as the exact mechanism for THIS specific 2022 proceeding.
06. Safety, threatened violence or assault category — Code 702.08. The university separately sustained 702.08, whose category covers assault, threats of violence OR conduct threatening health or safety. The public record does not state which prong was proved, whether any member was physically assaulted, or whether any person required medical care. The sustained organizational safety category is therefore reported precisely without converting its broad label into proof of a specific physical assault.
07. Harassment — Code 702.09. The campus confirmed an organizational harassment violation. Its public list does not identify whether the conduct involved humiliation, verbal abuse, intimidation, repetitive unwanted contact, protected-class discrimination or another variety of harassment. The incident is coded as confirmed harassment at chapter level, not an unverified accusation of a particular sexual, racial or other specific offense.
08. Controlled-substance rule — Code 702.17. The university sustained its rule concerning unlawful possession, use OR distribution of controlled substances. The campus listing does not identify a particular drug, quantity, method of administration, individual purchaser or trafficker, police report, or court charge. It establishes a university drug-policy violation; it does not support claiming every new member consumed cannabis, stimulants or another specific substance.
09. Alcohol rule — Code 702.18. The school found the chapter responsible for possession, use OR distribution of alcohol in violation of policy. No original report provides alcohol type, age of drinkers, blood-alcohol concentration, whether the event was a party, or whether alcohol was coerced into any individual. The alcohol violation is an independent sustained category but must not be narrated as a verified alcohol-overdose emergency without actual records.
10. Other dishonesty — Code 702.02. The campus responsible findings include other forms of dishonesty. This code does not reveal whether the alleged dishonesty was a false statement to investigators, membership misrepresentation, forged documents or other conduct. Do not invent an institutional cover-up by named chapter officers or claim specific witness intimidation based solely on the name of the broad policy category.
11. Violation of law — Code 702.00. The university included a category for violations of local, state or federal laws not covered by its other conduct provisions. This is an organizational campus-code determination. It does not identify the law, name a police agency, provide a criminal docket or establish an individual criminal conviction. Its relevance remains substantive without being rewritten as a felony verdict.
12. Obstruction or disruption — Code 702.13. The findings list obstruction or disruption as another sustained campus conduct category. This could cover a range of disruptions or interference; the source gives no specific actions, disrupted proceeding, persons or incidents. It cannot be attributed to a named survivor or tied to the national fraternity's 2023 decision as an established causal explanation.
13. Failure to comply with officials — Code 702.16. The chapter was found responsible for failure to comply with directions of an official, resisting or obstructing an official. The public source does not disclose whose instruction was disobeyed or the date or circumstances of noncompliance. It must not be inflated into a police-resistance allegation or individual prosecution.
14. Violation of previous conduct action — Code 702.21. The university separately sustained a violation of conduct action. That demonstrates at least one applicable institutional conduct directive existed at the relevant time, but the public register does not identify the previous order, its initial violations, duration, or whether it involved the same members. Avoid inventing a repeat hazing episode or extra unrecorded disciplinary case solely from this line.
15. Combined organizational findings. These ten categories document more than a minor fraternity paperwork violation: hazing, safety threats, harassment, alcohol and controlled-substance violations occurred alongside dishonesty, obstruction and failure to comply with institutional requirements. The breadth of the findings is the university's own conclusion. A public summary of categories is still not a substitute for the full investigative record or individualized victim accounts.
16. Deferred suspension is not immediate expulsion. UC Merced called its September 2022–October 2024 organizational sanction 'Deferred Suspension.' That label differs from an immediate campus loss of recognition. The later August 2023 national decision actually ceased chapter operations. The case separates those administrative authorities and dates rather than declaring the chapter was physically closed in September 2022.
17. Fall 2022 membership and university data. UC Merced's original Fall 2022 Social Fraternity Community Grade Report lists Pi Lambda Phi among its social fraternities with sixteen members. This is a snapshot of reported members in the term when the conduct finding was announced; it is not evidence all sixteen participated in, organized, witnessed or suffered a specific form of hazing or threats.
18. Spring 2023 report does not give a valid member count. The university's Spring 2023 social-fraternity report displays Pi Lambda Phi with N/A for its current membership and semester metrics while retaining its prior fall GPA for comparison. An N/A row does not prove the chapter had zero students, had already been formally closed in spring 2023, or completed the remaining deferred-suspension obligations.
19. Chapter origin and identity. UC Merced's chapter profile says Pi Lambda Phi joined the campus in spring 2016. Pi Lambda Phi's national locator separately records California Alpha Upsilon as founded in 2016 and inactive since 2023. Both primary institutional and national records agree on the school and chapter identity; a contradictory unofficial list's 2018 establishment date is not adopted.
20. National fraternity halts chapter operations. An August 4, 2023 memo from Pi Lambda Phi's International Executive Council says the chapter was not meeting national expectations and that international leadership had suspended operations. It sets out a university-fraternity agreement for closure and eventual recolonization. The memo does NOT explicitly state that the 2022 university findings, alone, were the exclusive cause of the national closure; any such single-cause interpretation would exceed the published record.
21. Signed August 4, 2023 institutional agreement. The UC Merced-hosted 'Institutional Close & Return Agreement Merced' names the California Alpha Upsilon chapter and outlines a four-year departure from the campus with a proposed fall 2027 re-entry. It identifies Hayley Montoya, interim assistant director of Fraternity and Sorority Life at UC Merced, and Calvin Carie, assistant executive director of Pi Lambda Phi, as institutional signatories. They signed as organizational representatives, not as alleged individual offenders.
22. Immediate cessation of ALL operations. Under the closure agreement, the chapter was not to meet, host events, advise, recruit, advertise, hold social events or perform community service as an operating chapter. The proposal required a joint closure announcement and an attempt to recover/store fraternity ritual equipment and other paraphernalia. These explicit restrictions show the 2023 closure was more than a temporary social-event probation.
23. Planned four-year absence. The national organization described leaving UC Merced for four years, with planned staff-led return at the beginning of fall 2027. A four-year plan beginning 2023 and pointing to 2027 is not proof the later recolonization is guaranteed. The university's current unrecognized listing confirms the old chapter has not been documented as actively re-recognized in November 2026.
24. Return not automatic: on-site planning. To pursue a return, Pi Lambda Phi committed to coordinating with university officials ahead of fall 2027 and proposed a spring 2027 on-campus visit to build relationships and develop a restart schedule. The original document establishes planned steps only; it provides no future verification that spring 2027 staff visits occurred, since that date had not yet arrived.
25. Excluding all former initiated undergraduate members. The agreement explicitly prohibits any previously initiated member who might still be enrolled from participating in the restarted chapter's activities. Recruitment is to begin with non-affiliated undergraduates and a completely new class of 'Re-Founding Fathers.' This is a particularly significant accountability provision and a stronger reset than an ordinary probation extension.
26. Replacement chapter coach. Any restart requires a chapter coach mutually agreeable to UC Merced and Pi Lambda Phi's national staff. That is an independent safeguard identified by the signed document, not proof a specific replacement was selected in 2023 or by November 2026.
27. On-site national staff for two semesters. The agreement requires an international headquarters staff member to live in Merced for two semesters, lead the first semester's recruitment and new-member education, oversee operations and meet regularly with UC Merced's Fraternity and Sorority Life office. This oversight is intended to reduce recurrence; there is no completion certification while the chapter remains closed.
28. New chapter coaches board. The proposed reformed organization must have a chapter coaches board of at least six volunteer coaches, including a faculty/staff adviser identified with university assistance. Headquarters personnel are to train coaches, who will then coach chapter officers weekly. These are future conditions, not evidence that a six-person board already existed in 2026.
29. New-member education and ritual approval. The agreement says the national fraternity's approved education program will be used, national staff will supervise the initial recruitment/education process, and all rituals must receive headquarters approval with coaches participating. This condition matters because future initiation should not rely on unmonitored legacy customs; it does not identify the precise practices that produced the 2022 hazing finding.
30. New membership and academics standards. The restart plan specifies a minimum 2.7 cumulative GPA for new bids and continuing members, with restrictions and removal if GPA deficiencies are not cured, plus membership in a non-fraternity student organization and at least 15 hours of service per semester. It also expects three annual Leadership Institute attendees. These are planned controls, not findings that the 2022 case involved academic dishonesty or failure to volunteer.
31. Current university status as of September 22, 2026. UC Merced's updated Unrecognized Groups page still lists Pi Lambda Phi as closed or suspended, says the chapter and international fraternity decided to end operations, and identifies a possible fall 2027 return. The same page has other organizations' separate suspensions and closures; none should be attributed to California Alpha Upsilon.
32. Current national status and expansion roadmap. Pi Lambda Phi's chapter locator labels California Alpha Upsilon an Inactive Chapter, founded 2016 and inactive 2023. A separate national expansion-roadmap article explicitly lists University of California at Merced for fall 2027; promotional planning remains future intent, not 2026 campus recognition or a verified restarted undergraduate chapter.
33. Hazing transparency versus older reporting. UC Merced's federal Stop Campus Hazing Act transparency page says it found no NEW qualifying hazing findings in the December 2025–June 2026 report window and links to the earlier pre-act conduct register. That does not negate or expunge the documented 2022 Pi Lambda Phi finding. Modern hazing policy examples—forced alcohol, confinement, degrading games—are generic examples, not established details of this chapter's specific 2022 conduct.
34. Victim privacy and missing case documents. The original university public listing names the organization, codes and outcome but does not release harmed students' identities, number of complaints, witness interviews, alleged individual conduct, clinical injuries, police reports, disciplinary-hearing transcript or an appeal. No survivor interview or filed criminal case was independently obtained. The public case is extensive about confirmed institutional actions and honest about unverified underlying specifics.
35. GLW deduplication and separate UC Merced investigations. The campus separately found Pi Kappa Phi responsible in July 2023 for safety, hazing and alcohol under a different chapter. Its research entry GLW-REF-138 remains a distinct incident; its dates, students, officers and disciplinary outcomes are not part of Pi Lambda Phi's October 2022 responsibility or August 2023 closure. The West canonical university, national fraternity and California Alpha Upsilon chapter IDs already exist and require no replacement card.
36. Accountability and historical persistence. UC Merced sustained ten conduct findings involving hazing, safety threats, harassment, drugs, alcohol and interference with institutional rules; national leadership subsequently required a total operations shutdown and an entirely new membership for any future return. A student-centered historical record must not obscure these outcomes with the fraternity's current recruitment ambitions, while still accurately stating that the exact individual conduct and any criminal or medical outcomes remain undisclosed.
2022 policy 702.08 is a BROAD assault/threat/safety category, not evidence of a specific proven beating; 702.17 does not specify controlled substance or individual users. Sep22 deferred start predates Oct1 university responsibility date in source; no invented correction. August2023 national closure agreement does not assign exclusive causal responsibility to 2022 finding. Fall2027 is planned and conditional, not current reinstatement.
Recorded outcome
Ten sustained organizational policy violations, deferred suspension 2022–24 as university lists; national fraternity suspended activities and signed Aug4 2023 four-year closure with conditional Fall2027 fresh-member staff-led recolonization. As of Sep2026 UCM still unrecognized and national locator inactive since2023.
Pi Lambda Phi at University of California, Merced
CA Alpha Upsilon
Merced
CA