SDSU Phi Gamma Delta — Dylan Hernandez Death, Confirmed Hazing and 2020 Expulsion

After 19-year-old SDSU freshman Dylan Hernandez attended a November 6, 2019 Phi Gamma Delta-associated gathering, he suffered a fatal head injury from a dormitory bunk-bed fall and died November 8. The county medical examiner classified his death as accidental blunt-force head trauma. SDSU's August 13, 2020 organizational decision sustained aiding-and-abetting, alcohol, hazing/conspiracy-to-haze, health/safety, illegal-drug and conduct-procedure violations, expelled Phi Gamma Delta and barred IFC expansion eligibility until August 2030. Its international fraternity indefinitely suspended the Sigma Delta charter. In March 2025 SDSU confirmed a $7.9 million settlement with Hernandez's family.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning SDSU Phi Gamma Delta — Dylan Hernandez Death, Confirmed Hazing and 2020 Expulsion. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 10, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Dylan Hernandez attended a November 6, 2019 fraternity-associated gathering[02] The following morning brought a fatal head injury in a residence hall[03] The medical examiner identified blunt-force head trauma and an accidental manner of death[04] SDSU publicly documented the emergency and suspended its Interfraternity Council[05] The university clarified that Phi Gamma Delta had not been individually suspended in early November[06] Hernandez's family publicly challenged aspects of the police investigation[07] SDSU established task forces and expanded safety expectations[08] University police and the district attorney completed their criminal review by July 2, 2020[09] SDSU opened its separate administrative review after the police investigation[10] The international fraternity's board held an August 7 chapter trial[11] The national fraternity permanently suspended Sigma Delta's charter[12] The national organization requested that SDSU cancel a scheduled August 14 conference[13] The August 13 university decision relied on police reports, member admissions and images[14] SDSU formally sustained aiding-and-abetting and alcohol violations[15] SDSU expressly sustained hazing or conspiracy-to-haze violations[16] SDSU also sustained health/safety and illegal-drug policy violations[17] The university found a conduct-procedure violation for case-related misrepresentation[18] Phi Gamma Delta was expelled and barred from applying for expansion until August 2030[19] Former chapter members were barred from future SDSU undergraduate chapter involvement[20] The university said its chapter decision did not determine individual proceedings[21] The Hernandez family brought a civil wrongful-death lawsuit[22] News reporting preserved the national fraternity's dispute with aspects of the lawsuit[23] A $7.9 million settlement with SDSU was reported in March 2025[24] The current university disciplinary registry still lists Phi Gamma Delta as unrecognized[25] National chapter records independently confirm the Sigma Delta charter identity and closure[26] Earlier university discipline is documented in independent reporting but requires separate original-file review[27] The first original PDF is available, but several supporting original records remain to be obtained[28] GreekLifeWatch editorial: a substantiated hazing case and a student's death demand a durable record
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Dylan Hernandez attended a November 6, 2019 fraternity-associated gatheringLos Angeles Times / San Diego Union-TribuneFraternity Event and Student FatalityDate not recorded

The 19-year-old SDSU freshman and Phi Gamma Delta prospective member attended a November 6, 2019 fraternity-associated big/little event. Contemporary police-related reporting describes significant alcohol consumption followed by another member taking him to his dormitory. Reported conduct at the event, university findings and the precise medical cause of his later death must be separately attributed rather than described as one undifferentiated allegation.

[02]The following morning brought a fatal head injury in a residence hallSan Diego State UniversityNovember 7 Medical EmergencyDate not recorded

Hernandez reportedly fell from an upper bunk at his dorm on the morning of November 7, 2019. He suffered a serious head injury, was found unresponsive and received medical attention after a 911 call. SDSU University Police confirmed a medical emergency at a Montezuma Road residence hall and transportation to a hospital. He died on November 8. The family later questioned the adequacy of the emergency response and investigation.

[03]The medical examiner identified blunt-force head trauma and an accidental manner of deathABC 10News San Diego (KGTV)Medical Examiner Cause of DeathDate not recorded

The San Diego County Medical Examiner determined that Hernandez died of blunt-force head injuries after the fall, with the manner classified as an accident. News reporting on released autopsy findings noted that the medical examiner measured a postmortem alcohol concentration of 0.06%, while a separate police report estimated a significantly higher level earlier in the night, around 0.23%. These measures refer to different times; the report does not identify alcohol poisoning as the formal medical cause of death.

[04]SDSU publicly documented the emergency and suspended its Interfraternity CouncilSan Diego State UniversityInstitutional Initial ResponseDate not recorded

An official SDSU investigation page contains its University Police statement regarding the November 7 emergency and subsequent university restrictions. Effective November 8, 2019, SDSU suspended the Interfraternity Council and its chapter organizations pending institutional review. The campus-wide interim measure was different from, and years earlier than, the chapter-specific August 2020 organizational expulsion.

[05]The university clarified that Phi Gamma Delta had not been individually suspended in early NovemberSan Diego State UniversityPrior Institutional StatusDate not recorded

SDSU's January 2020 public update states that before the November 2019 emergency, Phi Gamma Delta was already being investigated for a separate, non-alcohol-related allegation. It was not itself under a specific interim suspension immediately before Hernandez's injury. This administrative distinction matters because subsequent campus-wide council restrictions and the later organizational expulsion should not be assigned to the wrong date.

[06]Hernandez's family publicly challenged aspects of the police investigationLos Angeles Times / San Diego Union-TribuneFamily Criticism and Unanswered QuestionsDate not recorded

The Hernandez family raised concerns in early 2020 about the scope and timing of the university police investigation, including whether potential communications evidence was pursued and how fraternity-member accounts were handled. Those concerns were documented in contemporary reporting. Allegations of deletion or obstruction involving particular students are attributed to the family; an individual criminal conviction is not documented by the organizational outcome letter.

[07]SDSU established task forces and expanded safety expectationsSan Diego State UniversityCampus Safety ReformsDate not recorded

SDSU's January and July 2020 announcements described presidential task forces on student activities/safety and alcohol/substance misuse, along with new recruitment, off-campus gathering and emergency-assistance expectations. The university introduced a recognized-student-organization Good Samaritan policy to encourage timely help during alcohol/drug emergencies. These broader reforms followed the death and investigations but are not additional case-specific counts against Phi Gamma Delta.

[08]University police and the district attorney completed their criminal review by July 2, 2020San Diego State UniversityCriminal Review and University JurisdictionDate not recorded

In its July 2, 2020 update, SDSU announced that University Police had completed a nearly six-month investigation into Hernandez's death in collaboration with the San Diego County District Attorney. The university explained that criminal investigation and campus organization accountability proceedings used different processes. Subsequent reporting indicates no criminal charges were filed; that status must not be confused with the distinct university finding of organizational hazing and other conduct violations.

[09]SDSU opened its separate administrative review after the police investigationSan Diego State UniversityAdministrative Investigation BeginsDate not recorded

The university's July 2 update announced that Student Life & Leadership would handle alleged organizational misconduct and the Center for Student Rights & Responsibilities would handle individual student conduct investigations. The detailed individual case results are not reproduced in the August organizational outcome PDF. The current GreekLifeWatch case records the institutional chapter decision, not undisclosed individual findings.

[10]The international fraternity's board held an August 7 chapter trialSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalNational Board Disciplinary TrialDate not recorded

The original national notice appended to SDSU's decision letter states that Phi Gamma Delta's Archons held a trial of Sigma Delta on August 7, 2020. The national board found the chapter guilty of fraternity bylaws and risk-management violations involving hazing, drug use, and alcohol misuse. These are expressly documented national organizational findings, independent of the university's August 13 findings.

[11]The national fraternity permanently suspended Sigma Delta's charterSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalNational Charter ClosureDate not recorded

Phi Gamma Delta International's August 13 letter explains that the board permanently, or indefinitely, suspended the local charter, effectively closing the Sigma Delta chapter. The notice said former undergraduate members were no longer authorized to recruit, initiate, represent the chapter or conduct activities under the fraternity's name. Its current chapter roster separately records Sigma Delta's closure in August 2020.

[12]The national organization requested that SDSU cancel a scheduled August 14 conferenceSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalProcedural Change Before OutcomeDate not recorded

Because the charter had been removed, Phi Gamma Delta's executive director told SDSU that undergraduate students could not represent the chapter during an August 14, 2020 informal conference. SDSU accepted the request and issued its administrative outcome letter instead. The university's action was not a dismissal of its own findings; the signed university letter expressly rendered an organizational decision despite cancellation of the planned conference.

[13]The August 13 university decision relied on police reports, member admissions and imagesSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalEvidence and Proof StandardDate not recorded

SDSU's official outcome letter identifies the evidentiary sources for its organizational review: the University Police report, admissions by former chapter members, photographs and videos. Its director says the findings were made under a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard. The underlying reports and full exhibits are not attached or published in the three-page campus letter; precise conduct descriptions beyond the identified counts should not be invented.

[14]SDSU formally sustained aiding-and-abetting and alcohol violationsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalSustained Aiding/Abetting and Alcohol CountsDate not recorded

The university found the chapter responsible for aiding and abetting conduct violations and for alcohol-policy violations. These are distinct sustained organizational standards, not only allegations quoted by news articles. The PDF includes definitions of the provisions but does not associate a specific named student with each count or reproduce every incident item within the underlying evidence.

[15]SDSU expressly sustained hazing or conspiracy-to-haze violationsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalSustained Hazing FindingDate not recorded

The university's outcome letter lists Hazing or Conspiracy to Haze, provisions b(20)-1 and b(20)-2, among the organizational violations found. Thus this is a confirmed university organizational hazing case, unlike the informal-warning and dismissed matters in the UCSD research batch. The document does not make a distinct medical determination that hazing caused the fatal head injury; the medical examiner reported accidental blunt-force trauma from the fall.

[16]SDSU also sustained health/safety and illegal-drug policy violationsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalSustained Health/Safety and Illegal-Drug CountsDate not recorded

The signed decision includes Health and Safety (b(21)) and Illegal Drugs (b(22)-1 and b(22)-2) among the sustained categories. The letter defines the rules for conduct at organization-related events and facilities. It does not publicly identify the specific drug, person, toxicology chain or act supporting each provision, so GreekLifeWatch does not assert individual possession or intoxication unsupported by the original summary.

[17]The university found a conduct-procedure violation for case-related misrepresentationSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalSustained Conduct-Procedure ViolationDate not recorded

SDSU also sustained b(38)-1, relating to falsification, distortion or misrepresentation of information in a student-organization disciplinary matter. This was an organizational administrative finding. The letter does not name the student who made a particular false representation or state precisely which documentary communications were altered, and such identities are not inferred from the family's separate civil allegations.

[18]Phi Gamma Delta was expelled and barred from applying for expansion until August 2030San Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalUniversity Expulsion and 2030 EligibilityDate not recorded

SDSU sanctioned the organization to expulsion and barred it from participation in the Interfraternity Council expansion selection process until August 2030. The university made clear that eligibility for an eventual application or interview would not guarantee selection or recognition. This is not a suspension automatically ending with chapter reinstatement in 2030; university permission would be needed before reestablishment.

[19]Former chapter members were barred from future SDSU undergraduate chapter involvementSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalReestablishment SafeguardDate not recorded

One original sanction stipulation applies to former Sigma Delta members active during the 2017–18, 2018–19 and 2019–20 academic years who retain international membership. They may not engage with a newly established undergraduate chapter or become advisers, including after graduating. This requirement is a specific institutional protection on prospective reestablishment, not simply a restriction on the chapter's immediate operations.

[20]The university said its chapter decision did not determine individual proceedingsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalOrganizational vs Individual Case StatusDate not recorded

SDSU explicitly states that its August 2020 organizational decision has no effect on individual student conduct proceedings. The formal chapter sanctions therefore cannot be transformed into a criminal or disciplinary finding against every former member. Equally, the absence of a reported criminal charge does not reverse the institution's separate, sustained organizational conduct findings.

[21]The Hernandez family brought a civil wrongful-death lawsuitCourthouse News ServiceFamily Wrongful-Death LitigationDate not recorded

The family filed a civil lawsuit naming SDSU and other defendants after the 2019 death. Public reporting on the pleadings describes allegations of coerced alcohol consumption during fraternity big/little activities, failures to secure emergency assistance and alleged concealment or destruction of evidence. Those pleading details remain attributed civil allegations even where SDSU separately sustained hazing, alcohol and other organizational conduct violations.

[22]News reporting preserved the national fraternity's dispute with aspects of the lawsuitCourthouse News ServiceContested Litigation PositionsDate not recorded

Courthouse News reported that Phi Gamma Delta's national executive disputed claims in the family's lawsuit, arguing that parts were inaccurate, despite the national chapter disciplinary outcome. The disagreement is distinct from the written national board's chapter-level findings. The record preserves the institutional sanctions and the contested litigation positions without treating allegations against individual people as adjudicated facts.

[23]A $7.9 million settlement with SDSU was reported in March 2025FOX 5/KUSI, syndicated via Yahoo NewsCivil Settlement UpdateDate not recorded

On March 3, 2025, FOX 5/KUSI reported that SDSU confirmed its settlement with Dylan Hernandez's family for $7.9 million, funded through the CSU risk-management authority and private insurers. The report is evidence of the university-family civil settlement, not a criminal verdict or evidence that claims against every other defendant shared identical dispositions. No settlement terms beyond the reported amount and parties are invented.

[24]The current university disciplinary registry still lists Phi Gamma Delta as unrecognizedSan Diego State University Student Affairs and Campus DiversityCurrent University Recognition StatusDate not recorded

As of the November 2026 research check, SDSU continues to list Phi Gamma Delta under unrecognized organizations, with the August 2030 expansion eligibility date and the national charter indefinitely suspended. The university says it has received no reports of the former chapter operating. Neither that statement nor chapter history justifies claiming the group currently recruits or operates under the Phi Gamma Delta name.

[25]National chapter records independently confirm the Sigma Delta charter identity and closurePhi Gamma Delta International FraternityNational Chapter HistoryDate not recorded

The fraternity's official historical chapter directory identifies the SDSU organization as Sigma Delta, originally chartered in 1986, rechartered in May 2013 after an earlier closure, and ceased in August 2020. This corroborates the organization affected by the SDSU outcome. The separate university August 2030 date refers to eligibility to seek a new SDSU chapter, not an automatic international reinstatement.

[26]Earlier university discipline is documented in independent reporting but requires separate original-file reviewLos Angeles Times / San Diego Union-TribunePrior Campus Conduct ContextDate not recorded

The Union-Tribune's 2020 retrospective describes chapter-level concerns and university disciplinary activity stretching back to 2016–2019, including 2017 probation and additional alcohol-related complaints. Those older matters are historical context, not additional charges automatically sustained by the August 2020 Hernandez-related outcome. Their underlying SDSU letters should be collected separately if later assigned their own case investigations.

[27]The first original PDF is available, but several supporting original records remain to be obtainedSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalOriginal-Document Collection InventoryDate not recorded

The principal August 13, 2020 SDSU outcome letter and the attached national charter-suspension notice are accessible as one original PDF. Potential additional case-specific primary documents include the complete university police report, medical examiner's original report, family civil complaint and settlement record, original November 2019 presidential statements, and the 2020 task force reports. Publication and redaction status must be assessed individually; no private evidence is invented.

[28]GreekLifeWatch editorial: a substantiated hazing case and a student's death demand a durable recordSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership / Phi Gamma Delta InternationalGreekLifeWatch EditorialDate not recorded

Dylan Hernandez's death and the university's subsequent organizational findings warrant careful public preservation. The confirmed university violations, national charter action and family settlement show multiple institutional responses, while the medical examiner's accidental head-trauma determination and the status of individual proceedings require equally precise representation. GreekLifeWatch supports transparent original documents, survivor/family dignity and meaningful fraternity risk-management accountability.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

SDSU Phi Gamma Delta — Dylan Hernandez Death, Confirmed Hazing and 2020 Expulsion

Phi Gamma Delta at San Diego State University · CA

Reporting basis
Original SDSU August 13, 2020 outcome letter and attached Phi Gamma Delta International decision, official SDSU investigation updates and current judicial sanctions register. County medical examiner findings as reported in contemporary journalism; original media and family's civil suit/2025 settlement updates explicitly source-attributed.
Incident type
Death following fraternity event; sustained organization-level hazing, alcohol, illegal-drug, health/safety and administrative misconduct findings
Allegation status
SDSU officially found Phi Gamma Delta Sigma Delta responsible for aiding/abetting (b1), alcohol (b2), hazing or conspiracy to haze (b20), health and safety (b21), illegal drugs (b22), and violations of Student Organization Conduct Procedures (b38). The original medical examiner classified death as accidental blunt-force head injuries; SDSU outcome does not make a separate medical causation adjudication. Family's civil pleadings alleged coercive drinking and concealment; individual criminal liability is not inferred.
Investigation status
SDSU University Police and San Diego County District Attorney criminal review completed by July 2, 2020, followed by institutional conduct investigation; Phi Gamma Delta International board trial August 7, 2020; SDSU administrative findings and order August 13, 2020.
Legal status
Sustained university organization misconduct and national fraternity charter action. County Medical Examiner accidental death finding. Subsequent reporting indicates no criminal charges in death investigation. Hernandez family brought civil wrongful-death suit; SDSU confirmed $7.9 million settlement in March 2025, separate defendants' outcomes not established here.
Incident start date
2019-11-06
Incident end date
2019-11-08

The campus hazing, alcohol and illegal-drug organizational findings are confirmed in a primary signed SDSU PDF. The medical examiner found accidental blunt-force head trauma, rather than a medical cause of death labeled alcohol poisoning. Police alcohol estimates from the prior night differ from later autopsy toxicology. A 2025 university-family civil settlement does not supply criminal guilt or an automatic finding against every civil defendant.