SDSU Delta Upsilon — Spring 2020 New-Member Adviser Compliance and Formal Warning

SDSU investigated Delta Upsilon's Spring 2020 new-member meetings and inaccurate adviser-attendance documentation. After a December 10, 2020 conference, its February 12, 2021 organizational decision sustained only b(16) Failure to Comply, not the separately alleged hazing or health/safety counts. SDSU imposed a Formal Warning with Stipulations requiring advance planning with the Fraternity and Sorority Life advisory team and alumni oversight of new-member activities. The original PDF includes a confusing Spring 2021 reference within the Spring 2020 chronology.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning SDSU Delta Upsilon — Spring 2020 New-Member Adviser Compliance and Formal Warning. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 10, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] The original allegation concerned March 8, 2020 new-member meetings[02] SDSU confirmed in-person meetings occurred before COVID restrictions moved activities online[03] Adviser coverage during new-member activities was the central issue[04] A chapter education schedule contained inaccurate adviser information[05] The letter contains an internal academic-year inconsistency[06] The university held an informal conference December 10, 2020[07] Only the failure-to-comply charge was sustained[08] The outcome was a formal warning with stipulations[09] Chapter leaders had to plan oversight with university advisers[10] The university required collaboration with alumni advisers[11] Further violations could result in interim suspension[12] GreekLifeWatch editorial: narrow findings should remain narrow[13] SDSU Student Life & Leadership — Judicial Reports and Completed Organization Sanctions
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]The original allegation concerned March 8, 2020 new-member meetingsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaOriginal ComplaintDate not recorded

The university's Feb 12, 2021 letter identifies an alleged March 8, 2020 incident at Delta Upsilon's former fraternity residence, reported to SDSU in November 2020. The complaint cited failure to comply, hazing and health/safety, but not all were sustained.

[02]SDSU confirmed in-person meetings occurred before COVID restrictions moved activities onlineSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaNew-Member MeetingsDate not recorded

The source says Delta Upsilon held new-member meetings in Spring 2020 at its former 5545 Hardy Avenue residence until activities transitioned to virtual formats. It identifies the fraternity facility, not a specific injury or ritual.

[03]Adviser coverage during new-member activities was the central issueSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaAdviser SupervisionDate not recorded

University and task-force guidance required new-member meetings within 9 a.m.–9 p.m. and an adviser throughout. Interviews did not conclusively establish an adviser attended every meeting, forming the basis of the sustained compliance finding.

[04]A chapter education schedule contained inaccurate adviser informationSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaSchedule AccuracyDate not recorded

SDSU describes an April 14, 2020 submitted schedule incorrectly identifying adviser presence at activities. The administrative decision does not make a separate dishonesty count under a different code provision.

[05]The letter contains an internal academic-year inconsistencySan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaOriginal Record Date AmbiguityDate not recorded

The February 2021 decision repeatedly says Spring 2021 meetings while describing a 2020 incident and April 2020 submitted schedule. GreekLifeWatch notes the inconsistency instead of silently rewriting the original or assigning unsupported exact 2021 incident days.

[06]The university held an informal conference December 10, 2020San Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaUniversity ConferenceDate not recorded

SDSU met the chapter on December 10 to discuss failure-to-comply, hazing and health/safety allegations. Investigation included chapter members and witnesses, with university and national anti-hazing policy also discussed.

[07]Only the failure-to-comply charge was sustainedSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaActual University FindingDate not recorded

The signed February 12, 2021 decision explicitly found Delta Upsilon responsible for code b(16) Failure to Comply. Hazing and health/safety were allegations discussed during review, but not listed among sustained findings.

[08]The outcome was a formal warning with stipulationsSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaUniversity SanctionDate not recorded

SDSU imposed a Formal Warning with Stipulations—not chapter suspension or expulsion. This is a formal organizational responsibility decision under b(16), unlike a nonculpable informal warning.

[09]Chapter leaders had to plan oversight with university advisersSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaAdviser Oversight PlanDate not recorded

Before the next new-member education process, chapter education officers were ordered to meet the SDSU Fraternity & Sorority Life advisory team, explain session content and designate advisers for each new-member activity.

[10]The university required collaboration with alumni advisersSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaAlumni Adviser RoleDate not recorded

The chapter's alumni board was to help ensure adviser attendance at new-member and chapter meetings. The PDF does not provide completed meeting logs, agenda or adviser roster.

[11]Further violations could result in interim suspensionSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaConditional WarningDate not recorded

SDSU warned that new misconduct or failure to complete stipulations could trigger further investigation or immediate interim suspension. It was conditional, not evidence that an interim suspension subsequently occurred.

[12]GreekLifeWatch editorial: narrow findings should remain narrowSan Diego State University Student Life & Leadership — Matthew H. GarciaGreekLifeWatch EditorialDate not recorded

Supervision and accurate reporting of new-member programs are important safety safeguards. The SDSU formal warning establishes a failure-to-comply violation, but this record cannot be reported as a substantiated hazing or physical-injury case.

[13]SDSU Student Life & Leadership — Judicial Reports and Completed Organization SanctionsSan Diego State University Student Affairs and Campus DiversityCurrent official SDSU case-letter index and historical sanction summaryDate not recorded

University's completed-sanctions index links Delta Chi August 2023 decision and lists Sigma Chi November 2023 probation through March 4, 2024; separate Sigma Chi June 2025 proceeding is also listed. Historical sanction entries are not proof training completion.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

SDSU Delta Upsilon — Spring 2020 New-Member Adviser Compliance and Formal Warning

Delta Upsilon at San Diego State University · CA

Reporting basis
Official original SDSU historical organizational decision PDF and SDSU judicial-report index. Internal original document date/party-name inconsistencies explicitly noted rather than silently fixed.
Incident type
Sustained organizational failure-to-comply finding regarding new-member adviser oversight; hazing not sustained
Allegation status
Only Student Organization Code b(16) Failure to Comply sustained. Alleged hazing and health/safety discussed but not found as sustained violations in the original decision.
Investigation status
Reported Nov 2020 regarding March 8, 2020 incident; Dec 10, 2020 conference and witness interviews; signed SDSU Feb 12, 2021 decision.
Legal status
Student-organization administrative disciplinary finding, not named student criminal conviction.
Incident start date
2020-03-08
Incident end date
2020-03-08

Source filename includes 20200212 although letter dated Feb 12, 2021. Spring 2021 references in letter conflict with Spring 2020 incident and schedule details; neither an additional 2021 incident nor an actual hazing finding is established.