Case file
Rutgers Alpha Sigma Phi — Two Students Shocked During 2025 Hazing; Dangerous House, Five-Year Ban and No Charges
Alpha Sigma Phi at Rutgers University–New Brunswick · NJ
- Reporting basis
- Rutgers official hazing transparency report; police/prosecutor-attributed reporting; national fraternity statements
- Incident type
- Confirmed university hazing finding with severe electrical injury
- Allegation status
- University finding of organizational responsibility; individual conduct reported and disputed in civil context
- Investigation status
- University case resolved March 2026; prosecutor investigation reportedly closed June 2026
- Legal status
- Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office closed 2025 hazing investigation in June 2026 without criminal charges, per June 9 reporting. National fraternity announced intention to pursue civil damages January 12, 2026; no filed court action verified.
- Incident start date
- 2025-10-15
- Incident end date
- 2025-10-15
Account
01. Two young people electrically shocked during October 15, 2025 hazing incident
At about 12:26 a.m. October 15, 2025, Rutgers University Police responded to a disconnected 911 call at the Alpha Sigma Phi house, 106 College Avenue, New Brunswick. Officers found an unresponsive 19-year-old undergraduate in grave condition while others were attempting to put him in a private vehicle. He was transported to Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital with critical electrical injuries. A second young man trying to help was also shocked, according to his mother's account and subsequent Patch reporting; his injuries were less severe and did not require hospitalization. The critically injured student's identity remains withheld. Prosecutors said on October 23 that he was out of critical condition, and January 2026 reporting stated he had been released from hospital.
02. Rutgers officially substantiates organizational hazing
Rutgers' Campus Hazing Transparency Report identified required new-member line-ups, calisthenics and other imposed conduct, an injury during a line-up, and compulsory activities at nonsanctioned off-campus locations. The university found Alpha Sigma Phi responsible for abuse/endangerment/hazing, noncompliance with university policies, and health and safety violations. The report specifically states alcohol/drug abuse or illegal use was not involved in this incident. This is an affirmative university organizational hazing finding, not merely an investigation or fraternity assertion.
03. Water, exposed wiring and response to the emergency
Alpha Sigma Phi national president Gordy Heminger stated its own inquiry found hazing during a line-up in which water became involved. Subsequent reporting attributed the electrocution to water and contact with exposed live wiring in the basement; neither the publicly available Rutgers transparency summary nor police statements conclusively reconstruct the exact electrical mechanism or each participant's actions. Heminger criticized an incomplete 911 call under fraternity medical-amnesty requirements. Police arrived after the disconnected call and found students attempting a private-car transfer. The early interrupted call and response delay are central accountability concerns.
04. Years of documented housing hazards before the injuries
Patch's review of New Jersey Department of Community Affairs inspection records identified 11 earlier violations in 2014 (cleared in 2016), 26 in 2020 including missing carbon monoxide detectors, and persistent unresolved problems in early 2023. In April 2024 inspectors documented 12 violations and a $9,000 penalty plus fees; September 2024 follow-up drew another $5,500 penalty. January 2025 unresolved flooring/door-hardware conditions brought a $10,000 fine. A May 2025 cyclical inspection identified 50 code violations, including exposed electrical wires in multiple rooms and carbon-monoxide issues. A September 2025 reinspection found 19 still unresolved and assessed $1,975. These conditions predated the October shocks and cannot be erased from the accountability record.
05. Housing control, warnings and family allegations
State property records reviewed by Patch identified the owner as the Rutgers Alumni Association of Alpha Sigma Phi (a fraternity alumni association distinct from the Rutgers University alumni association) and CLVEN Property Management as manager. A different resident's parents said they had repeatedly warned fraternity headquarters and management of leaking water and raw sewage, holes, fleas, mice, unsecured entry and water pooling in the basement. The parent supplied photographs and said many complaints were ignored, while CLVEN responded to some. She said the family had paid an $800 deposit and $4,000 for fall housing, despite her son leaving because of the conditions. These are attributed first-hand complaints, alongside separate state-recorded violations.
06. After condemnation, residents faced disputed continuing payment demands
New Brunswick building officials posted an unsafe-structure notice immediately after the October incident; the house was declared uninhabitable. Parents reported a national fraternity housing official's email stating residents remained contractually responsible for rent despite the closure, and that additional spring payments might still be due. Heminger responded that CLVEN would apply occupancy agreements, denied that maintenance requests had been neglected, and attributed some building damage to residents. The opposing accounts are preserved because housing safety and financial treatment of displaced students are material to accountability. The inspection citations and building closure are independently documented.
07. Previous chapter misconduct before the critical incident
Rutgers' Fall 2024 Fraternity/Sorority Conduct Summary lists Alpha Sigma Phi responsible for September 14, 2024 alcohol/other-drug and university-policy violations; it imposed disciplinary probation and chapter officer education, with case closed October 21. A separate Rutgers Fall 2025 organizational report lists a September 7, 2025 policy noncompliance incident, a Responsible outcome and disciplinary probation plus social restrictions, with notice shown as 03/10/2025 (day/month formatting, October 3). These are earlier separate institutional cases and are presented only as relevant disciplinary context, not merged into the October 15 incident.
08. National closure and the university's five-year removal
Following interim action, Alpha Sigma Phi International announced October 24, 2025 that its investigation found hazing and immediately closed the Rutgers chapter, recommended residents' removal and threatened expulsion of directly or indirectly involved members. Rutgers publicly lists Alpha Sigma Phi as closed in Fall 2025. Its Stop Hazing report identifies an October 15 reporting date, December 17, 2025 conduct investigation start, February 19, 2026 end/charge, March 4 notification/resolution, and a five-year removal sanction. A separate Rutgers Fall 2025 organizational report also records a 'Non-compliance with the Law' university-policy category for October 15 and referral to the governing department; this is an organizational university finding, not a criminal conviction, and the report's notice date is printed 09/02/2026 in mixed-format records.
09. National fraternity's threatened civil damages and institutional accountability debate
On January 12, 2026, Alpha Sigma Phi's own press release said it had retained counsel and intended to pursue civil damages from former student members alleged to have participated directly or indirectly, including alleged bystanders. It described training less than a month before the incident. Reporting called this an intended lawsuit; no filed complaint, docket number or monetary judgment was verified. Victims' lawyer Doug Fierberg publicly questioned whether this approach could divert responsibility from national fraternity leadership and toward teenagers ahead of a potential injury claim. The corporate strategy must not be misrepresented as a civil judgment in favor of the injured students or as proof that the national organization adequately supervised the chapter.
10. No criminal charges despite official university finding
News 12 reported June 4, 2026 that the Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office closed its investigation without explaining charging status. New Jersey 101.5 reported June 9 that no criminal charges were filed. That outcome is recorded alongside, not in place of, Rutgers' affirmative organizational hazing findings and severe injury. The injured student's anonymity, survivor welfare, and questions about the prosecution and housing response remain central.
11. Related aftermath and sources
Rutgers warned students in January 2026 against unrecognized Greek organizations while Alpha Sigma Phi's letters were removed from the building. The public case has linked original Rutgers reports, contemporaneous prosecutor-attributed reporting, state-record inspection reporting, family interviews, the actual national litigation-intent press release and 2026 follow-up. Separate 2024 and September 2025 misconduct incidents remain historical context, not extra October 15 incidents.
Original Rutgers findings: https://stophazing.rutgers.edu/campus-hazing-transparency-report/ ; https://studentconduct.rutgers.edu/sites/default/files/student-orgs-fall-2025.pdf ; House records and family reporting: https://patch.com/new-jersey/newbrunswick/amp/33093195/rutgers-frat-house-where-student-was-critically-hurt-has-history-of-code-violations ; https://patch.com/new-jersey/newbrunswick/amp/33122703/alpha-sigma-phi-where-teen-was-electrocuted-ignored-parents-complaints-about-sewage-leaks-mom-says ; National announcement: https://fraternallaw.com/newsletter2/alpha-sigma-phi-announces-intent-to-pursue-civil-damages-in-rutgers-hazing-case ; Charge outcome: https://nj1015.com/rutgers-hazing-incident-update/
Two injured students (one critically); distinguish police, university and national fraternity findings. State inspection records identified 50 violations in May 2025 and 19 unresolved in September. National housing operation and disputed parent complaints are material.
Recorded outcome
Rutgers found organizational hazing/endangerment and health-safety violations, ordering five-year campus removal on March 4, 2026. Alpha Sigma Phi international closed its local chapter in October 2025. No criminal charges were filed after the 2026 prosecutor closure.
Alpha Sigma Phi at Rutgers University–New Brunswick
New Brunswick
NJ