Case file
Penn State — Joseph Dado 2009 Fatal Fall, Alpha Tau Omega Conviction and Phi Gamma Delta Charges
Alpha Tau Omega at Pennsylvania State University · PA
Phi Gamma Delta at Pennsylvania State University · PA
- Reporting basis
- Penn State joint police announcement and coroner statement; Associated Press court report; 6abc sentencing; This American Life recorded firsthand interview
- Incident type
- Fatal accidental fall associated with fraternity alcohol furnishing
- Allegation status
- Medical accidental fall established; police charged both organizations; ATO convicted furnishing alcohol; FIJI final criminal disposition unverified
- Investigation status
- Joint campus/borough police investigation concluded October 29, 2009; ATO trial and sentencing resolved 2010–11
- Legal status
- ATO convicted of furnishing alcohol to minor. FIJI charged; final disposition not verified. No homicide conviction documented.
- Incident start date
- 2009-09-19
- Incident end date
- 2009-09-21
Account
1. Incident and location. Joseph Dado, 18, a first-year student at Pennsylvania State University, went missing after drinking with friends during September 19–20, 2009. University maintenance employees discovered his body around 6 p.m. Monday September 21 at the bottom of a campus stairwell near the Hosler/Steidle buildings, approximately 75 yards from the Phi Gamma Delta fraternity house. He was last seen leaving that fraternity's house on North Burrowes Road in the early hours of Sunday September 20.
2. Medical ruling. Centre County Coroner Scott Sayers ruled the death accidental, attributable to head trauma from a fall. The October 29 joint Penn State/State College Police statement gave Dado's blood alcohol concentration as 0.169 percent and concluded excessive alcohol consumption played a major role. The medical cause is traumatic injury from the fall, not a coroner diagnosis of alcohol poisoning.
3. Drinking sequence. Contemporary first-person audio journalism by This American Life recounts drinking in a dormitory, drinking beer at Alpha Tau Omega, and later whiskey at Phi Gamma Delta (FIJI). FIJI member Jack Townsend, identified in the police release as a charged individual, acknowledged supplying Dado whiskey in a recorded interview. His public interview is relevant firsthand evidence, not evidence of a final criminal judgment.
4. Police investigation and October 29 charges. After a five-week joint investigation, campus and borough police charged Alpha Tau Omega and Phi Gamma Delta as separate organizations under 18 Pa.C.S. §6310.1 and the Pennsylvania Liquor Code for furnishing alcohol to underage Dado September 19–20. The same statement identified a distinct FIJI September 12 allegation involving another underage individual. That earlier allegation is not a second Dado fatality.
5. Individual defendants. Original police notice separately named FIJI member John 'Jack' Townsend for furnishing alcohol to Dado September 20 and Penn State student Jennifer E. Clifford for furnishing alcohol to Dado September 18. Charges are distinguished from convictions. Original final court dockets for Townsend, Clifford and the FIJI chapter were not recovered in this research; no final guilt finding is assigned to those parties.
6. Immediate institutional response. In September 2009, the Penn State Interfraternity Council placed FIJI on social probation during the investigation, as documented in contemporaneous reporting. Social probation does not itself establish criminal conviction or the ultimate university adjudication. Later retrospectives discuss organizational suspension and alcohol policy revisions, but do not substitute for the missing complete disciplinary decisions.
7. ATO defended its furnishing charge. Alpha Tau Omega disputed organizational responsibility, arguing the gathering was not a chapter-sanctioned event. On December 14, 2010, Centre County Judge Thomas King Kistler found the fraternity guilty of furnishing alcohol to the minor; Associated Press reported the decision December 15. This is a specific criminal alcohol-furnishing outcome, not an adjudication of homicide.
8. ATO sentencing. On January 25, 2011, the court sentenced Alpha Tau Omega following the December ruling, imposing a $500 fine and reported community service. A January 26, 2011 6abc report verifies the $500 amount and underlying judicial outcome. No person or organization is described as convicted of killing Dado.
9. Distinct organizations, one fatality. ATO has a confirmed criminal furnishing-alcohol conviction and sentence. FIJI is the last fraternity Dado visited, named in independent furnishing charges and the firsthand account of Townsend. Those positions are represented by two Case Chapters associations for the same Case ID. The separate FIJI September 12 charge is not counted as a separate fatality or represented as a final conviction.
10. Context and follow-up. Penn State's 2009 alcohol policy debate and subsequent coverage situate Dado's death within the university's drinking culture. Context does not independently establish a forced-pledging hazing ritual, intent to injure, or homicide charge. Outstanding record leads: original Centre County docket entries for FIJI, Townsend, and Clifford; original university disciplinary adjudications; ATO sentencing order and any appellate history.
One fatal accident and two chapter links. September 12 FIJI charge relates to distinct other alcohol furnishing, not another Dado incident.
University Park
PA
University Park
PA