Account
01. Separate September 6 complainant, not the September 13 case
IU Police spokesperson Hannah Skibba expressly distinguished the September 6 rape allegation, reported on September 15, from a September 13 allegation at SAE. The students were different complainants, although Noah Apgar was identified as suspect in both. GLW-REF-535 covers the September 13 case and is not being duplicated.
02. Original alleged conduct date versus reporting date
The alleged incident was dated September 6, 2024. IU Police said the reporting student came forward September 15, after a different September 13 report. This case therefore uses September 6 for occurrence and September 15 for first confirmed police reporting.
03. North Eagleson Greek-house description from IUPD
The September 20 Indiana Daily Student article quotes IU Police describing the alleged offense as occurring at an unnamed Greek house on North Eagleson Avenue. The police spokesperson did not name a house, fraternity, sorority or specific venue address in that statement.
04. First-person allegations summarized in court reporting
The complaint described nonconsensual sexual activity allegedly committed by an IU student after an evening involving Greek residences. The original signed charging affidavit has not been obtained here; detailed allegations in reporting are attributed to the complainant and alleged facts, not established as criminal guilt.
05. September 5 fraternity-party context
Herald-Times reporting described the September 6 reporting student meeting the accused at a fraternity-party event the preceding evening, September 5. The article's indexed account then places the assault report in a sorority room; this is distinct from an independent institutional finding against the fraternity host.
06. Fox News account describes more than one fraternity site
Fox Digital quotes a probable-cause affidavit describing an initial fraternity-house encounter and later travel to SAE, where an assault was alleged. That account provides potential SAE venue association for the September 6 sequence, but conflicts with other reports and does not identify the first fraternity house conclusively.
07. Sorority residence description also appears in reporting
A syndicated Herald-Times article and later WIBC summary characterize one of the incidents as a sorority residence rather than a fraternity house. Whether these reporters refer to different alleged acts in the same nighttime sequence or incompatible descriptions is unresolved without the primary affidavit and case reports.
08. No forced chapter identity from a street or accused affiliation
A North Eagleson location alone does not establish ownership or chapter sponsorship. Even though SAE was connected to the accused and some affidavit reporting, the school police's Sept. 6 venue description was unnamed, and sources disagree. The case's Primary Chapter ID is intentionally blank.
09. Accused's SAE affiliation and headquarters action
The Indiana Daily Student reported Apgar had formerly been a Sigma Alpha Epsilon member and was suspended. Fox also quoted SAE headquarters saying it suspended a member after learning of allegations and was cooperating. That is an attributed organizational response, not a finding that all members participated in or approved assaults.
10. September 15 follow-up to campus police
IU Police stated the September 6 reporting student notified authorities September 15, two days after the different Sept. 13 case became public. The difference between occurrence and report dates is retained in the case chronology.
11. September 17 arrest was based on combined allegations
Noah Apgar was arrested Tuesday September 17 on charges involving two women. The September 6 case is not an additional arrest, and the seven initial felony counts should not be counted as seven separate survivor incidents.
12. Initial felony charges across two reports
WFIU reported five rape counts, one strangulation count and one confinement count spanning both complainants. Apgar entered a not-guilty plea. Individual counts cannot be confidently assigned to September 6 without original court docket and count-level charging documents.
13. Camera, interviews and forensic references
WFIU cited a probable-cause affidavit describing witness interviews, surveillance footage from a fraternity property and a sexual-assault evidence kit associated with one woman. These source descriptions cannot be mechanically assigned as proof of each alleged event or of which woman supplied evidence.
14. Police spokesperson and court-file descriptions differ
The direct IU Police description reproduced by IDS and Fox names only a North Eagleson Greek residence for September 6; WFIU described both reports as SAE-house incidents; the Fox affidavit account and syndicated Herald-Times narrative describe movement involving other Greek housing. Their differences are preserved explicitly.
15. October 2024 dismissals and limits of count mapping
IDS reported Judge Valeri Haughton dismissed six of the original seven counts after prosecutors acknowledged evidentiary shortcomings, leaving one rape count pending at that time. It referred to 'second victim' without matching that trial count reliably to Sept. 6 or Sept. 13.
16. 2026 records describe two distinct trial tracks
The August 2026 Indiana Daily Student reporting said the proceedings involved separate complainant trials. It also described six charges potentially involved in a separate case, unlike the 2024 report of six dismissals. Without a live court docket or refiling orders, this archive does not infer restoration, convictions or automatic linkage of counts.
17. August 2026 hung jury is not a September 6 verdict
One Apgar trial ended in a hung jury and mistrial in August 2026. WIBC explicitly associated that trial with the September 13 reporting student and described the September 6 track as separate. The mistrial is related criminal context, not a completed September 6 trial verdict.
18. Reported September 14, 2026 hearing is a schedule, not an outcome
In August 2026, WIBC reported a trial regarding the September 6 complainant was scheduled for September 14. The Indiana Daily Student separately described September 14 as retrial timing for the mistried count. No official hearing minutes establish what actually happened that date.
19. Different media accounts of 2026 scheduling
August 24 Herald-Times coverage said the other trial had no date or judge, while the August 21 WIBC item said a second trial was scheduled Sept. 14. These accounts cannot both be treated as a verified completion record. The precise Sept. 6 trial calendar and subsequent disposition remain unverified.
20. No confirmed chapter-wide rape sanction or individual conviction
The publicly available reporting establishes two reported incidents, multiple criminal charging stages, one related mistrial and inconsistent venue accounts. It does not establish a jury conviction tied to September 6 or a university finding that a named chapter committed sexual assault as an organization.
21. Separate April 2024 SAE restrictions predate these reports
Indiana University's disciplinary listing records SAE social restrictions during 2024, but the existing April restrictions occurred before September 6 and September 13. They are not represented as a punitive finding for either later rape report.
22. Original records required for venue resolution
The most important follow-ups are the full September 2024 probable-cause affidavit, exact case and count numbers, IUPD reports, signed court dismissals and August–November 2026 docket entries, including Sept. 14 scheduling. Until verified, neither a named chapter nor a final Sep. 6 legal outcome is manufactured.
GLW-REF-535 is the prior separate September 13 SAE case. September 6 case is not assigned a Primary Chapter ID due source conflict (IUPD unnamed North Eagleson Greek house versus alternative SAE and sorority-room reports). 2024 SAE restrictions predating the report are separate.
No published chapter records are available.