Account
01. Student and chapter: Andrew 'Drew' Coffey, 20, was an FSU transfer student from Lighthouse Point, Florida studying civil engineering and hoping to serve in the U.S. Navy. He joined the Pi Kappa Phi Beta Eta chapter. Beta Eta was founded in 1950; the national organization revoked its charter November 10, 2017. Current alumni activity is not evidence of a currently recognized undergraduate chapter.
02. Historical hazing practices: The Coffey family's 2018 complaint alleges longstanding pressure to drink excessively and degrading pledge activities. Those are plaintiff allegations, distinct from the grand jury's findings and FSU organizational discipline. The original complaint also describes an earlier November 1 lead-up event, apart from the November 2 fatal event.
03. Big Brother Night, November 2, 2017: According to the Leon County grand-jury presentment and court reporting, pledges were paired with Big Brothers at an off-campus Buena Vista Drive residence in Tallahassee. The fraternity tradition involved a high-proof 'family bottle' of liquor, with social pressure to finish it. Coffey's Big Brother, Connor Ravelo, provided a 750 mL bottle of Wild Turkey 101 bourbon. The presentment describes coercive expectations even without physically forcing liquid into a pledge's mouth.
04. Intoxication: After drinking, Coffey became severely impaired and was placed or moved among places including a porch and couch. Testimony described continued socializing while he was unresponsive. The legal significance of the group's conduct and individual knowledge must be based on the presentment and each person's court record rather than attributed to every member by association.
05. Discovery and emergency response, November 3: When another pledge attempted to wake Coffey the next morning he found him unresponsive. Phone records described in the grand-jury presentment show members contacted other members before calling 911, with an approximately 11-minute delay between discovery and emergency call. Police later released the 911 recording. The grand jury criticized the members' response and noted the difference between the delay before 911 and the much longer period in which the severely intoxicated student was not given medical assistance.
06. Medical examiner: Cause of death was acute alcohol toxicity. The postmortem blood-alcohol concentration was reported as 0.447 g/dL; other fluid samples produced an estimated possible earlier peak around 0.558 g/dL. They are distinct measures, and no single peak BAC is asserted as an independently verified blood test.
07. Immediate university and national action: FSU President John Thrasher suspended recognized Greek social functions campus-wide in November 2017, also citing unrelated fraternity concerns. On November 10, Pi Kappa Phi national headquarters revoked Beta Eta's charter after finding the chapter had violated policies governing social events. National closure is distinct from the university's subsequent internal conduct action.
08. Grand-jury presentment: Filed in December 2017, the Leon County grand jury detailed the drinking ritual, emergency-response failures and widespread noncooperation with investigators. Some witness statements and refusal to cooperate are described in the presentment. Recommendations and grand-jury conclusions are not themselves convictions of any named person.
09. Criminal charges: In January 2018, nine members were charged with felony hazing: Kyle Bauer, Brett Birmingham, Christopher Hamlin, Luke Kluttz, Clayton Muehlstein, Anthony Oppenheimer, Anthony Petagine, Connor Ravelo and John 'Jack' Ray. The original charges differed from final plea agreements.
10. First five pleas, April 16, 2018: Bauer, Birmingham, Hamlin, Ravelo and Ray pleaded guilty to misdemeanor hazing. Reporting records 30 days' jail for Ravelo following cooperation and 60 days for each of the other four, with probation, education or other requirements. They are not described as felony-convicted.
11. Civil claim and 2018 settlements: Coffey's parents, Tom and Sandy Coffey, brought a wrongful-death civil action in February 2018 naming national fraternity interests, chapter members and others associated with the event. Attorneys announced confidential settlements in June. A contemporaneous court report says 13 of 15 original civil parties settled by June 15, 2018. No aggregate award or final later resolution for two other parties was verified in the consulted reporting. The civil complaint's allegations are separate from the court pleas.
12. Appellate felony-hazing issue: Defendants challenged whether charged facts satisfied then-existing Florida felony hazing law. In State v. Petagine, Florida First District Court of Appeal case 1D18-2086, the majority reversed dismissal of felony counts in January 2020; a dissent disagreed about statutory construction. It was a decision on pretrial charging sufficiency, not an adjudication of guilt. Florida Supreme Court declined discretionary review in August 2020.
13. Muehlstein's plea: Clayton Muehlstein pleaded guilty in November 2020 to misdemeanor hazing, receiving a custodial sentence of nearly one year with cooperation conditions, as reported by WCTV.
14. Oppenheimer's plea: Anthony Oppenheimer entered a misdemeanor hazing plea in December 2020, with a 270-day jail sentence and adjudication withheld as reported by WCTV. A withheld adjudication must not be labeled a formally adjudicated conviction.
15. Final two defendants: Luke Kluttz and Anthony Petagine entered no-contest pleas in May 2021 involving felony and misdemeanor hazing counts. The signed terms provided for withheld adjudication. Each was sentenced June 24, 2021 to 60 days' jail with further conditions. Thus all nine original defendants had court-reported dispositions by June 2021, but not all were convicted felons, and legal statuses differ.
16. University conduct findings: FSU's historical scorecard, explicitly updated in October 2019, lists Pi Kappa Phi Beta Eta responsible for hazing, endangerment and alcohol-related violations. It records that FSU dismissed the chapter for seven years in 2018 and that national headquarters closed it in 2017. This archival status is not independent evidence of recognition in 2026.
17. Greek-life reform: FSU's Moving Forward Together plan addressed the campus-wide 2017 suspension with new-member education, chapter scorecards, adviser involvement, national-organization oversight, and alcohol/risk-management expectations. These changes were broader prevention measures rather than individual criminal punishments.
18. Andrew's Law: Tom and Sandy Coffey advocated for increased hazing accountability and protections when an observer summons emergency help. Florida enacted Chapter 2019-133, commonly known as Andrew's Law, effective October 1, 2019, amending section 1006.63. It includes defined conditions for first-caller and aid-related immunity as well as expanded hazing and planning liability. This legislation did not apply retroactively to Coffey's death in 2017.
19. Later prevention work: FSU's 2025 Power of One program, inspired by Sandy Coffey's advocacy, focused on bystander intervention, hazing recognition and medical-amnesty education, reaching hundreds of students. FSU's July 2026 campus transparency reporting concerns a broader compliance framework and later incidents at other organizations; it must not be presented as new Beta Eta misconduct.
20. Reporting boundaries: This file distinguishes the grand-jury presentment, original charges, guilty pleas, no-contest pleas, withheld adjudication, confidential civil settlements, national charter closure, historical FSU sanctions and subsequent legislation. No undisclosed dollar figure is invented, and no current chapter status is inferred from the alumni association or a 2019 scorecard. Private records and authenticated complete court dockets were not obtained as of November 9, 2026.
2019 FSU scorecard not a current-status record. Confidential settlement amounts unreported. Andrew's Law not retroactive. Withheld adjudication for specified plea defendants is not a formal felony conviction.