Florida State University Pi Kappa Phi (Beta Eta) — Andrew Coffey Fatal Hazing, Nine Criminal Cases, Civil Settlements and Andrew's Law (2017)

Andrew Coffey, 20, died of acute alcohol poisoning after Florida State Pi Kappa Phi Beta Eta's November 2, 2017 Big Brother Night. A Leon County grand jury documented pressured drinking and delayed emergency assistance. The national fraternity revoked the chapter charter and FSU later imposed disciplinary sanctions. Nine charged men entered differing plea agreements and received jail terms by June 2021; the family reached confidential civil settlements. Andrew's Law took effect October 1, 2019, and FSU continued Coffey-inspired hazing prevention through 2025.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning Florida State University Pi Kappa Phi (Beta Eta) — Andrew Coffey Fatal Hazing, Nine Criminal Cases, Civil Settlements and Andrew's Law (2017). Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 9, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Nov 2 — Andrew Coffey attends fatal hazing ritual[02] Nov 3 — Coffey found unresponsive and pronounced dead[03] Nov 6 — FSU suspends fraternity and sorority activities[04] Nov 10 — Pi Kappa Phi national organization revokes Beta Eta charter[05] Dec 19 — Leon County grand jury issues Coffey presentment[06] Jan 16 — Nine Pi Kappa Phi members charged with felony hazing[07] Jan 31 — TPD releases recorded 911 call[08] Feb 20 — Coffey family wrongful-death litigation publicized[09] Apr 16 — Five former members plead guilty to misdemeanor hazing[10] Jun 7 — Counsel announces confidential settlement[11] Jun 15 — 13 of 15 civil defendants reportedly settled[12] Mar 11 — Coffey parents call for stronger anti-hazing law[13] Oct 1 — Andrew's Law becomes effective[14] Jan 2 — First DCA restores felony counts in State v. Petagine[15] Aug 6 — State high court declines requested review[16] Nov 19 — Clayton Muehlstein pleads guilty[17] Dec 28 — Anthony Oppenheimer enters plea[18] May 28 — Final two defendants enter no-contest agreements[19] Jun 24 — Kluttz and Petagine sentenced to 60 days jail[20] Oct 7, 2025 — FSU documents Power of One prevention campaign[21] Jul 16, 2026 — FSU posts current hazing transparency framework[24] WCTV reproduces legal terms of final two no-contest agreements[27] Florida Statutes section 1006.63 current law[28] Florida House 2019 final analysis of SB1080/HB727[29] Florida DOE 2019 legislative review book covers Andrew's Law[30] FSU Student Senate endorses enhanced anti-hazing law[32] FSU maintains The Power of One and hazing prevention training[34] Pi Kappa Phi Beta Eta alumni site documents 1950 founding[35] Local report on grand jury and proposed accountability reforms[36] Tampa Bay Times reports family bottle and coercive culture[37] Plaintiffs' attorneys discuss felony-hazing appellate reversal
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Nov 2 — Andrew Coffey attends fatal hazing ritualLeon County Grand JuryPledge Big Brother NightNovember 2, 2017

Leon County grand jury describes 750 mL Wild Turkey 101 family bottle, binge-drinking pressures, and Coffey's subsequent incapacitation.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[02]Nov 3 — Coffey found unresponsive and pronounced deadLeon County Grand JuryDeath and police responseNovember 3, 2017

Emergency call placed after unsuccessful efforts to wake Coffey; medical cause later established as acute ethanol toxicity.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[03]Nov 6 — FSU suspends fraternity and sorority activitiesFlorida State UniversityFSU campus-wide actionNovember 6, 2017

President Thrasher imposes indefinite Greek-life suspension following Coffey death and other unrelated problems.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[04]Nov 10 — Pi Kappa Phi national organization revokes Beta Eta charterWCTV / Pi Kappa Phi statementNational fraternity chapter closureNovember 10, 2017

National organization announces closure for chapter social-events policy violations.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[05]Dec 19 — Leon County grand jury issues Coffey presentmentLeon County Grand JuryGrand jury presentmentDecember 19, 2017

Primary grand jury document addresses pressured drinking, members' conduct, toxicology and response failures.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[06]Jan 16 — Nine Pi Kappa Phi members charged with felony hazingCBS News / APCriminal filingJanuary 16, 2018

Leon County prosecutors charge nine named defendants; these were initial charges, not convictions.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[07]Jan 31 — TPD releases recorded 911 callWFSUPolice evidence disclosureJanuary 31, 2018

Police release public emergency-call audio describing response to Coffey at the off-campus house.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[08]Feb 20 — Coffey family wrongful-death litigation publicizedCoffey family civil complaintFamily civil complaintFebruary 20, 2018

Family complaint names national fraternity and other parties, alleging negligence and hazing-related failures; allegations distinct from court outcomes.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[09]Apr 16 — Five former members plead guilty to misdemeanor hazingWJHG / WCJBFive criminal guilty pleasApril 16, 2018

Bauer, Birmingham, Hamlin, Ravelo and Ray plead; jail sentences reported as 30 days for Ravelo and 60 days for four others.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[10]Jun 7 — Counsel announces confidential settlementStewart Tilghman Fox Bianchi & CainCivil settlements announcedJune 7, 2018

Family attorneys say settlement reached with key civil defendants without disclosing monetary terms.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[11]Jun 15 — 13 of 15 civil defendants reportedly settledWCTVCivil case statusJune 15, 2018

WCTV reports settlement progress involving 13 of the fifteen original civil parties; do not assume remaining parties resolved.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[12]Mar 11 — Coffey parents call for stronger anti-hazing lawWFSUFamily legislative advocacyMarch 11, 2019

WFSU reports family legislative advocacy for immunity to emergency callers and broader accountability.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[13]Oct 1 — Andrew's Law becomes effectiveFlorida Senate Criminal Justice CommitteeAndrew's Law takes effectOctober 1, 2019

Florida legislative amendment to section 1006.63 expands hazing provisions and conditional immunity for qualifying emergency assistance.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[14]Jan 2 — First DCA restores felony counts in State v. PetagineFlorida First District Court of Appeal / JustiaAppeal reverses felony dismissalJanuary 2, 2020

Published appellate ruling reverses pretrial felony count dismissal; not a finding of guilt.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[15]Aug 6 — State high court declines requested reviewWFSU / News Service of FloridaFlorida Supreme Court rejects reviewAugust 6, 2020

Florida Supreme Court declines to review the 2020 appellate decision, leaving revived felony charging proceedings in place.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[16]Nov 19 — Clayton Muehlstein pleads guiltyWCTVMuehlstein misdemeanor pleaNovember 19, 2020

Muehlstein receives near-one-year jail sentence for misdemeanor hazing and agrees to cooperate with prosecution.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[17]Dec 28 — Anthony Oppenheimer enters pleaWCTVOppenheimer pleaDecember 28, 2020

Reported misdemeanor hazing plea carries 270-day jail term and withheld adjudication.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[18]May 28 — Final two defendants enter no-contest agreementsWCTVKluttz and Petagine pleasMay 28, 2021

Kluttz and Petagine plead no contest to felony and misdemeanor hazing charges with adjudication withheld.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[19]Jun 24 — Kluttz and Petagine sentenced to 60 days jailWCTVFinal criminal sentencingsJune 24, 2021

Last two defendants receive court sentencing; reporting describes education and other terms.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[20]Oct 7, 2025 — FSU documents Power of One prevention campaignFlorida State University NewsFSU prevention initiativeOctober 7, 2025

FSU cites Sandy Coffey's advocacy and reports interactive prevention/medical-amnesty education reaching more than 700 students.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[21]Jul 16, 2026 — FSU posts current hazing transparency frameworkFlorida State University Hazing Education InitiativeCampus-wide transparency publicationJuly 16, 2026

University publishes current reporting materials as broad policy context; not a new 2017 Beta Eta disciplinary outcome.

For fuller facts, the source linked to this entry identifies whether the event is an official institutional finding, a published legal ruling, a reported criminal proceeding, a family civil pleading or a general campus prevention development. Historical status and current status are not conflated.

[24]WCTV reproduces legal terms of final two no-contest agreementsWCTVContemporaneous news / court reportingJune 24, 2021

No-contest pleas to felony and misdemeanor counts with adjudication withheld

[27]Florida Statutes section 1006.63 current lawFlorida LegislatureOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceDate not recorded

Codifies Andrew's Law conditional immunity for emergency call and aid; later amendment not retroactive

[28]Florida House 2019 final analysis of SB1080/HB727Florida House of RepresentativesOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceDate not recorded

Official staff analysis of planning liability, felony definitions and first caller emergency exemption

[29]Florida DOE 2019 legislative review book covers Andrew's LawFlorida Department of EducationOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceDate not recorded

Official executive summary of Chapter 2019-133; effective October 1, 2019

[30]FSU Student Senate endorses enhanced anti-hazing lawFlorida State Student GovernmentOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceMarch 27, 2019

Resolution supporting legislation in response to Coffey death

[32]FSU maintains The Power of One and hazing prevention trainingFlorida State University Hazing Education InitiativeOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceDate not recorded

Student training guidance and family-inspired 'The Power of One' initiative

[34]Pi Kappa Phi Beta Eta alumni site documents 1950 foundingBeta Eta alumni associationOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceDate not recorded

1950 founding and ongoing alumni group, distinct from active undergraduate recognition

[35]Local report on grand jury and proposed accountability reformsWJHGContemporaneous news / court reportingDecember 20, 2017

Presentment criticizes member refusal to assist investigation

[36]Tampa Bay Times reports family bottle and coercive cultureTampa Bay Times / WRALContemporaneous news / court reportingJanuary 18, 2018

Court-record description of forced social expectations and Wild Turkey 101 bottle

[37]Plaintiffs' attorneys discuss felony-hazing appellate reversalStewart Tilghman Fox Bianchi & CainOfficial, legal or firsthand sourceJanuary 3, 2020

Counsel commentary on felony charging standard; not a guilt verdict

Case context & supporting details

Case file

Florida State University Pi Kappa Phi (Beta Eta) — Andrew Coffey Fatal Hazing, Nine Criminal Cases, Civil Settlements and Andrew's Law (2017)

Pi Kappa Phi at Florida State University · FL

Reporting basis
Grand-jury presentment; official FSU historic conduct scorecard; national fraternity closure statement; First District Court of Appeal State v. Petagine; Tallahassee and Leon County court reporting; 2018 family civil complaint; Florida 2019 statutory amendments
Incident type
Fatal alcohol-related fraternity hazing
Allegation status
Grand jury findings of coercive drinking and response failures; individual felony charges resulted in differing misdemeanor guilty and no-contest pleas with some withheld adjudication
Investigation status
Tallahassee Police investigation, 2017 Leon County grand jury, nine criminal defendants charged Jan2018 and sentenced by Jun2021; FSU historic scorecard lists 2018 seven-year dismissal
Legal status
Nine felony hazing indictments/charges filed January 2018; five misdemeanor guilty pleas April 2018, Muehlstein misdemeanor plea Nov2020, Oppenheimer misdemeanor plea and withheld adjudication Dec2020, and Kluttz/Petagine no-contest felony/misdemeanor pleas with withheld adjudication May–June 2021; 2018 confidential civil settlements
Incident start date
2017-11-02
Incident end date
2017-11-03

2019 FSU scorecard not a current-status record. Confidential settlement amounts unreported. Andrew's Law not retroactive. Withheld adjudication for specified plea defendants is not a formal felony conviction.