Case file
University of Colorado Boulder Chi Psi — Gordie Bailey's 2004 Fatal Hazing, Criminal Pleas and Civil Settlement
Chi Psi at University of Colorado Boulder · CO
- Reporting basis
- Gordie Center; CU Boulder; AP; Colorado Supreme Court; settlement terms
- Incident type
- Fatal hazing
- Allegation status
- Fatal poisoning confirmed; hazing acknowledged in 2009 settlement
- Investigation status
- Chapter suspended then dissolved in 2004
- Legal status
- Alcohol-furnishing guilty pleas and civil wrongful-death settlement
- Incident start date
- 2004-09-16
- Incident end date
- 2004-09-17
Account
01. September 16 initiation: The Gordie Center states Bailey and 26 other pledges were blindfolded and taken to Arapaho–Roosevelt National Forest and encouraged to consume whiskey and wine around a bonfire. The reported collective supply is not a measure of Bailey's individual consumption.
02. Return and fatal delay: Bailey returned visibly intoxicated and was placed on a couch around 11 p.m. Brothers wrote on him with markers. No emergency call was made before he was discovered dead around 9 a.m. September 17, according to the Gordie Center.
03. Cause of death: Contemporary reporting attributes the death to acute alcohol poisoning based on the coroner's determination.
04. Institutional sanctions: CU Boulder announced September 17 that IFC suspended Chi Psi recognition and Greek-house social activities. October 2004 reporting documents closure of the Boulder chapter by Chi Psi national headquarters; CU confirmed dissolution in 2008. Current CU listings identify a later Chi Psi chapter as unaffiliated, not continuously closed.
05. Criminal outcomes: Contemporary AP reporting confirms ten former Chi Psi members pleaded guilty to furnishing alcohol to a minor by May 19, 2005. These were criminal alcohol-supply dispositions, not homicide convictions.
06. Civil complaint: According to the Colorado Supreme Court, Leslie Lanahan filed a wrongful-death complaint on April 26, 2006 against Chi Psi, Alpha Psi Delta Corporation and seven members, alleging fatal hazing.
07. Supreme Court, January 22 2008: Lanahan v. Chi Psi Fraternity, 175 P.3d 97, held Colorado's statutory noneconomic damages cap applies per wrongful-death claim rather than per defendant. This was an interpretation of the damages statute, not a trial finding deciding all liability.
08. March 2009 resolution: Published settlement terms state Chi Psi agreed that Bailey was hazed September 16 in violation of fraternity and CU policies, and accepted education, reporting, officer-accountability and risk-management commitments. Exact monetary settlement amount not asserted.
09. Prevention legacy: CU Boulder documented memorial prevention programming in 2008; the Gordie Center preserves the family's public education and alcohol-poisoning prevention work.
Original chapter closed in 2004; later Chi Psi listed as unaffiliated at CU Boulder