Case file
Cornell Zeta Beta Tau — 2017 Hazing-Policy Finding, Alleged Contest, 2018 Probation and Official Correction
Zeta Beta Tau at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell amended 2016–17 Hazing Violations Transparency Report, Zeta Beta Tau section; Cornell Faculty Senate February 14, 2018 presentation for procedural dates only; Cornell Daily Sun February 2 and September 9, 2018 reporting; ZBT national February 7 and September 5 statements; current Cornell organization scorecard.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- CORRECTED UNIVERSITY FINDING: More likely than not that someone associated with the chapter encouraged the alleged contest. Review Board did NOT find evidence that anyone acted on the encouragement or that the contest actually occurred. Chapter denied sponsoring or knowing of any such activity.
- Investigation status
- 2017 reports including March and November 15; Review Board hearing January 16, 2018; two-year probation decision January 23, 2018; university original statement February 2018; published correction July 9, 2018; Cornell reaffirms findings and sanctions September 2018.
- Legal status
- University organization-level recognition and membership-expectations findings and corrective probation. Cornell did not find an actual contest or resulting sex acts occurred; no individual criminal judgment asserted.
Account
AMENDED OFFICIAL FINDING CONTROLS THIS REPORT. Cornell University received three reports in 2017 involving its Zeta Beta Tau (ZBT) Kappa chapter. The allegation was that someone associated with the chapter encouraged new members to participate in a contest, sometimes called a 'pig roast,' in which sexual relationships with women could earn points. Cornell's CURRENT CORRECTED account states the Review Board found it 'more likely than not' that someone associated with ZBT ENCOURAGED participation in the alleged contest. The Review Board DID NOT find that any person acted on that encouragement and DID NOT find evidence that the contest actually took place. GLW does not report a sexual-activity contest as an established event.
THREE REPORTS AND 2017 INQUIRY: Cornell's amended 2016–17 hazing transparency page says the university received three reports during 2017, and the Review Board considered two non-anonymous reports. A contemporaneous February 14, 2018 Cornell Faculty Senate presentation identifies an anonymous tip submitted through Cornell's hazing website in MARCH 2017. The presentation says Title IX personnel found insufficient grounds to proceed at that stage and Sorority and Fraternity Life interviewed ZBT members without sufficient evidence to take further action. It identifies a further anonymous report on NOVEMBER 15, 2017. It does not supply the exact day of the March tip or separately date all three reports. A separate report count and the chronology of particular reports must not be conflated.
CHAPTER RESPONSE: Cornell's corrected account says ZBT denied the allegations, with leadership asserting that any incident would have been without its knowledge or chapter sponsorship. ZBT's February 2018 statements similarly rejected degradation of women and pledged internal and outside membership review. The chapter's denial is preserved alongside the Review Board's narrower sustained finding.
JANUARY 2018 REVIEW BOARD: Cornell's February 14, 2018 faculty presentation identifies the Fraternity and Sorority Review Board hearing on JANUARY 16, 2018 and a two-year probation sanction on JANUARY 23, 2018. These procedural dates are useful primary-source chronology. The same PRESENTATION also repeated an EARLIER, BROADER characterisation implying the alleged contest occurred. That portion of the presentation was overtaken by Cornell's later corrected public finding and is NOT treated as an accurate determination that any sexual acts or contest happened.
SUSTAINED ORGANIZATIONAL POLICY VIOLATIONS: Cornell's corrected 2016–17 transparency report states the board considered evidence including two non-anonymous reports and found it more likely than not that a chapter-associated person encouraged the alleged activity. On that limited finding, the board held the organization responsible for violating University Fraternity and Sorority Recognition Policy § E.17(b), which prohibits implementing or tolerating hazing, and Fraternity and Sorority Expectations of Membership § 11, concerning sexually abusive, demeaning behavior. These are organizational policy findings; the institution did not find an actual contest or individual sexual activity caused by the encouragement. The Board considered the chapter's broader disciplinary history, organizational health, and capacity for compliance in deciding on education-based sanctions.
TWO-YEAR PROBATION AND SPECIFIC CORRECTIVE STEPS: Cornell placed ZBT on Probationary Recognition for TWO YEARS. It required a complete brotherhood membership review and an external review by ZBT national headquarters with results communicated to university staff by MARCH 31, 2018; a university-approved live-in adviser hired by the start of fall 2018 for at least the balance of probation; Cornell's Intervene bystander training before the end of spring 2018; an OSFL-approved facility walk-through; ongoing sexual-violence education using community resources including at least one OSFL-approved program by APRIL 1, 2018; disclosure of the chapter's judicial history to members by FEBRUARY 1, 2018; an approved officer transition program by MARCH 15, 2018; 75 percent chapter participation in at least two Sexual Assault Awareness Week events APRIL 15–20, 2018; and monthly progress meetings with university fraternity staff during spring 2018. The official report documents these as ORDERS AND DEADLINES, not confirmation every step was finished on the deadline.
FEBRUARY 2018 INITIAL PUBLIC ACCOUNT: On FEBRUARY 2, 2018, the Cornell Daily Sun covered the university's early statement as if a sexual competition had been conducted. Other media repeated it, in reliance on Cornell's earlier phrasing. ZBT national headquarters issued a FEBRUARY 7 statement pledging its own review and possible removal of persons found involved. These early articles accurately document what was publicly alleged THEN but do not supersede the university's amended findings.
OFFICIAL JULY 9, 2018 CORRECTION: Cornell's published current hazing record explicitly acknowledges that the February 2018 version mischaracterized the Review Board findings and the chapter's role and omitted context for the sanctions. Cornell spokesperson John Carberry confirmed to The Cornell Daily Sun in September that the corrected online statement was posted JULY 9, 2018. Cornell explained that its review maintained the underlying narrower finding and sanctions. Thus the correction did not erase the organizational hazing and membership-expectations violations or end the two-year probation; it clarified that NO CONTEST WAS PROVEN TO OCCUR.
INDEPENDENT NATIONAL REVIEW AND SEPTEMBER PUBLIC RESPONSE: ZBT national fraternity said it commissioned a third-party investigator and challenged the university's broad early characterization. Its SEPTEMBER 5, 2018 statement welcomed the university's acknowledgment that there was no evidence the alleged contest occurred. In SEPTEMBER 9 campus reporting, Cornell confirmed the July 9 correction and affirmed the disciplinary outcome. The third-party report itself was not publicly released in that coverage, so its underlying evidentiary detail is not independently described here.
CURRENT STATUS: Cornell's current Student and Campus Life Organization Scorecard identifies Zeta Beta Tau's Kappa chapter at 1 Edgecliff Place as FULL recognition, recording separate later 2020, 2021 and November/December 2025 disciplinary matters. This status is current context, not proof of a specific date on which the two-year 2018 probation concluded.
SOURCE HIERARCHY AND PERSONAL ACCOUNTABILITY: Cornell's AMENDED official report has priority over its superseded February narrative, an uncorrected February Faculty Senate slide, original February articles, and any later summaries that omit the correction. Nothing in these official findings establishes that the alleged contest happened, that a specific individual engaged in sexual activity under it, or that every fraternity member was involved. GLW records the serious organizational policy violation actually adjudicated, while fully preserving the narrowed factual outcome and unchanged education sanctions.
Important corrected record: Cornell acknowledged February 2018 account mischaracterized results and posted correction July 9. The current institutional record found encouragement more likely than not but NOT any occurred sex contest or action on encouragement. Dates: March 2017 tip month only; Nov15 second tip; Jan16 hearing, Jan23 sanction per February faculty slides; dates of alleged encouragement not individually fixed. Probation and education sanctions unchanged by correction. Faculty slides and February reporting contain superseded allegations and must be identified as such.