Case file
Cornell Tau Epsilon Phi — 2012 Forced-Alcohol and Sexual Humiliation Hazing, Two Hospitalizations and Four-Year Recognition Revocation
Tau Epsilon Phi at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell 2012–13 Academic Year Hazing Violations, Tau Epsilon Phi findings; Cornell Chronicle November 8, 2012 and January 16, 2013; Cornell Daily Sun January 8, 2013; Tau Epsilon Phi national historical chapter list.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- Cornell Fraternity and Sorority Review Board established organizational responsibility for dangerous hazing involving coerced alcohol consumption and sexual humiliation; found chapter noncompliance with university recognition requirements.
- Investigation status
- Interim suspension announced by November 8, 2012; fraternity review board convened December 17, 2012; university recognition revoked effective January 9, 2013.
- Legal status
- Cornell university disciplinary determination withdrawing fraternity recognition; original university and campus press records do not describe individual criminal convictions arising from this adjudication.
Account
Cornell University's 2012–13 Hazing Violations Transparency Report records that the Fraternity and Sorority Review Board met December 17, 2012 to examine misconduct involving Tau Epsilon Phi at its house at 306 Highland Road in Cayuga Heights, New York. The university established a hazing incident involving three sophomore new members in October 2012. The detailed transparency report names October 21, 2012, whereas Cornell's January 16, 2013 Cornell Chronicle states October 12, 2012. Both official dates are preserved in this record because the public university documents conflict.
FORCED ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION: Cornell found that full fraternity members required three students participating in the pledge process to consume a large amount of alcohol, including hard alcohol. The drinking preceded an initiation-related activity the Review Board classified as sexually humiliating, mentally abusive and physically dangerous. The university does not publicly establish the exact amount consumed by each student or provide individual identities.
SEXUAL HUMILIATION: Cornell's detailed finding describes a required activity in which new members were made to remove all clothing other than underwear, followed by participation in an activity during which their underwear could be forcibly torn off. A January 8, 2013 Cornell Daily Sun account paraphrased a university official as describing underwear being ripped off. The administrative report's formulation identifies an activity with the threat or possibility of removal, and the Daily Sun reports the official's stronger description. The public university record characterizes this conduct as hazing and sexual humiliation; it does not document a separate sexual-assault conviction of an individual.
ALCOHOL-RELATED MEDICAL EMERGENCY: During the night, two of the three new members developed signs of alcohol-related illness and physical distress. The chapter president, who was studying elsewhere on campus, was contacted and returned to the house, assessed the situation and immediately called 911. Cornell's January 2013 Chronicle confirms that both affected pledges were hospitalized. Dean of Students Kent Hubbell specifically acknowledged the chapter's use of emergency medical assistance, while explaining that calling for help did not eliminate responsibility for the underlying hazing.
INVESTIGATION AND INTERIM ACTION: On November 8, 2012, the Cornell Chronicle publicly reported that Tau Epsilon Phi, Acacia and Pi Kappa Phi had been placed on interim suspension during investigations of dangerous hazing and alcohol-related allegations. The report says all chapter activities were suspended pending investigations. That announcement identifies an interim restriction, distinct from the final loss of recognition.
DISCIPLINARY DETERMINATION: Cornell's Fraternity and Sorority Review Board convened December 17, 2012 and found that Tau Epsilon Phi failed to comply with all expectations and requirements of the university's Recognition Policy. Cornell's January 16, 2013 Chronicle explicitly dates the withdrawal of recognition to January 9, 2013. The published final sanction withdrew university recognition for no less than four years, required chapter members to vacate the fraternity house following spring semester 2013, and provided that any subsequent university-approved re-recognition would entail at least two calendar years of Provisional Recognition. The university reported that the chapter was barred from recruiting without university recognition. Future approval was not automatic.
CONTEMPORANEOUS REPORTING: The Cornell Daily Sun published an early account January 8, 2013 describing the disciplinary decision and quoting associate dean Travis Apgar on the sexual humiliation and seriousness of the incident. The university's January 16 Chronicle subsequently supplied the January 9 effective recognition-withdrawal date and explicitly confirmed two hospitalizations. These report publication dates differ from the original October 2012 incident and the December 2012 Review Board meeting.
CHAPTER HISTORY AND PRESENT RECORD: Tau Epsilon Phi's national historical chapter roll identifies Cornell as its Delta chapter, founded in 1913, without marking the chapter currently active. GLW's existing Cornell chapter relationship is retained; the historical record does not establish that the chapter has current university recognition. The 2012 ruling establishes organizational responsibility, rather than misconduct by each person ever affiliated with Tau Epsilon Phi.
Two official Cornell publications conflict on the incident date: October 21, 2012 in the full hazing transparency finding and October 12, 2012 in Cornell Chronicle January 16, 2013. Exact Incident Start Date intentionally unassigned because the two official records disagree. December 17, 2012 is the Review Board meeting; January 9, 2013 is the university-confirmed effective recognition-withdrawal date. The university's detailed finding describes a stripping activity where underwear could be forcibly removed, while contemporaneous newspaper reporting quotes a university official describing actual removal.