Cornell Sigma Pi — 2006 Charles Holiday Hate-Crime Stabbing and 2013 Civil Reversal

On February 18, 2006, Cornell student Nathan Poffenbarger stabbed Charles Holiday, a Black visiting Union College student, after an escalating racist confrontation following Sigma Pi Mu's party. Holiday suffered a punctured lung and serious injuries. Poffenbarger pleaded guilty to felony assault as a hate crime and evidence tampering November 22, 2006, and received 1⅓–4 years in prison January 22, 2007. A 2011 jury allocated 35% civil fault to a Sigma Pi Mu entity under alcohol law, but the New York Appellate Division vacated that judgment and dismissed the fraternity's claims October 16, 2013.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning Cornell Sigma Pi — 2006 Charles Holiday Hate-Crime Stabbing and 2013 Civil Reversal. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 20, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Heavy drinking occurred at dorm before party[02] Fraternity hosted party at 730 University Avenue[03] Anti-Black slurs directed at Sigma Pi members[04] Chapter ejects aggressive guest[05] Alleged outside blows by chapter members[06] Holiday confronted further racist taunts[07] Sigma Pi member alerts Ithaca officer[08] Severe stab wound and intensive-care treatment[09] Assailant tampers with evidence[10] University suspends individual Poffenbarger[11] Five-count grand-jury indictment[12] Felony hate crime and tampering guilty pleas[13] Judge orders prison and restitution[14] Survivor describes continuing injury effects[15] Civil court denies early Sigma Pi dismissal[16] Chapter negligence claim dismissed[17] Jury finds 35% chapter fault, subsequently vacated[18] Appellate court vacates chapter's 35% liability[19] Negligence dismissal upheld[20] No proof chapter knowingly served intoxicating alcohol[21] Independent February 23 hazing finding not combined[22] Stabbing Has Had 'Galvanizing Effect' on Campus[23] Poffenbarger '08 to Be Sentenced
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Heavy drinking occurred at dorm before partyNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 17, 2006

Poffenbarger described drinking 12–15 shots of liquor before arrival at fraternity party.

[02]Fraternity hosted party at 730 University AvenueNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 17, 2006
[03]Anti-Black slurs directed at Sigma Pi membersNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Court recites racist abuse directed at Black member Anthony Majette and another member.

[04]Chapter ejects aggressive guestNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Poffenbarger removed from chapter after confrontation and refusal to leave.

[05]Alleged outside blows by chapter membersNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Court opinion recounts allegation members kicked/struck the guest during removal; no reviewed criminal adjudication against members.

[06]Holiday confronted further racist tauntsThe Cornell Daily SunCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Holiday and companions confronted the guest's racial language and argued while moving toward Baker Tower.

[07]Sigma Pi member alerts Ithaca officerNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Member Peter Strang warned Officer Michael Nelson, who approached during escalating confrontation.

[08]Severe stab wound and intensive-care treatmentThe Cornell Daily SunCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Holiday suffered punctured right lung, blood loss and lasting arm problems following assault.

[09]Assailant tampers with evidenceCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Poffenbarger burned blood-stained clothing after stabbing and later pleaded guilty to evidence tampering.

[10]University suspends individual PoffenbargerCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 18, 2006

Cornell temporarily barred defendant from campus; no linked chapter-level disciplinary finding.

[11]Five-count grand-jury indictmentCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityCase investigation and judicial dispositionMay 3, 2006

Prosecutor announced hate-crime assault and evidence-tampering counts; final plea was later narrower.

[12]Felony hate crime and tampering guilty pleasCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityCase investigation and judicial dispositionNovember 22, 2006

Poffenbarger pleaded guilty to assault as hate crime and evidence tampering in Tompkins County Court.

[13]Judge orders prison and restitutionCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityCase investigation and judicial dispositionJanuary 22, 2007

Judge sentenced Poffenbarger to 1⅓–4 years. Detailed Sun account reports $17,499.03 restitution.

[14]Survivor describes continuing injury effectsThe Cornell Daily SunCase investigation and judicial dispositionFebruary 19, 2007

Sun reports Holiday's rehabilitation, ongoing arm difficulty, punctured lung and academic delay.

[15]Civil court denies early Sigma Pi dismissalNY Supreme Court, Kings CountyCase investigation and judicial dispositionJune 9, 2009

Initial motion resolution left chapter claims alive without finding final negligence or alcohol-service liability.

[16]Chapter negligence claim dismissedNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionAugust 22, 2011

Civil court ruled chapter owed no negligence duty over off-premises stabbing; GOL §11-100 claim proceeded.

[17]Jury finds 35% chapter fault, subsequently vacatedNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionNovember 28, 2011

Trial jury temporarily attributed 35% fault to chapter under underage alcohol law; the verdict did not survive appeal.

[18]Appellate court vacates chapter's 35% liabilityNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionOctober 16, 2013

NY Appellate Division grants chapter summary judgment, reverses liability allocation and dismisses statutory alcohol claim.

[19]Negligence dismissal upheldNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionOctober 16, 2013

Court affirms location beyond chapter control meant no actionable duty to supervise assailant there.

[20]No proof chapter knowingly served intoxicating alcoholNY Appellate Division, Second DepartmentCase investigation and judicial dispositionOctober 16, 2013

Court cites shots in dormitory before party and an unaffiliated person's offered beer intercepted by friend.

[21]Independent February 23 hazing finding not combinedCornell University Alumni Interfraternity CouncilCase investigation and judicial dispositionDate not recorded

Separate already-published Cornell Sigma Pi new-member dragging/carrying case occurred five days later; different individuals and outcomes.

[22]Stabbing Has Had 'Galvanizing Effect' on CampusCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityOriginal contemporary reportingMarch 1, 2006

Cornell covers Rawlings's Feb28 forum and community concerns over anti-Black violence, student safety and alcohol.

[23]Poffenbarger '08 to Be SentencedThe Cornell Daily SunOriginal contemporary reportingJanuary 18, 2007

Sun reports confessed stabbing and racist slurs after ejection from Sigma Pi party; contemporaneous pre-sentencing context.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

Cornell Sigma Pi — 2006 Charles Holiday Hate-Crime Stabbing and 2013 Civil Reversal

Sigma Pi at Cornell University · NY

Reporting basis
2006 Cornell original indictment, plea and sentence reports; February 2007 Cornell Daily Sun survivor and witness investigation; NY Supreme Court Kings County June 2009 original opinion; October 2013 New York Appellate Division final reversal
Incident type
Hate-crime stabbing after fraternity-hosted party; convicted third-party attacker; reversed civil liability
Allegation status
Poffenbarger convicted of felony hate-crime assault. Sigma Pi members ejected hostile guest; one member summoned police. Separate alleged outside retaliation unadjudicated. 2011 chapter civil 35% allocation reversed in 2013.
Investigation status
Cornell Police, Ithaca Police; May3 2006 grand jury; Nov22 felony plea; Jan22 2007 sentence; civil index 38046/2006, Oct16 2013 appellate resolution
Legal status
Nathan Poffenbarger felony assault-as-hate-crime and evidence-tampering guilty plea, prison 1⅓–4 years. Mu Chapter's 2011 35% civil allocation VACATED Oct16 2013; chapter negligence and underage-alcohol claims DISMISSED.
Incident start date
2006-02-18
Incident end date
2006-02-18

The attacker was a guest ejected from party, not documented fraternity member. Interim 2011 civil 35% verdict VACATED, never represent as final. Separate Feb23 2006 Sigma Pi hazing case not combined.