Case file
Cornell Sigma Phi Society (NY Epsilon) — 2024 Alcohol, Collusion and Noncompliance Findings; Two-Year Suspension
Sigma Phi Society at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell original Organization Scorecard Sigma Phi section; Cornell 2022–23 Hazing Violations source for separate earlier case; Epsilon Association April 2 2025 statement and January 2026 re-establishment materials; Cornell Alumni IFC Expansion Chapter listing
- Incident type
- Alcohol-related and organizational misconduct; collusion or complicity; failure to comply; two-year university recognition suspension
- Allegation status
- Cornell institutional organization-level findings: Alcohol Related Behavior; Collusion or Complicity; Failure to Comply; Misconduct Related to Student Organizations. No separately identified criminal conviction or 2024 hazing finding in this judicial entry.
- Investigation status
- Formal Complaint resolved through Alternate Resolution; final organizational outcome issued May 6, 2025; earlier complaint receipt and investigation-opening dates not published
- Legal status
- Two-year Cornell chapter suspension and withdrawal of recognized privileges/IFC, not merely a deferred sanction; no individually named criminal defendants, court judgments or felony convictions documented
- Incident start date
- 2024-02-01
- Incident end date
- 2024-05-26
Account
01. Scope and original determination. Cornell University's Sorority and Fraternity Life Organization Scorecard records a separate formal misconduct case for Sigma Phi Society, referred to as 'Sigma Phi' in the judicial-history entry. It gives three 2024 incident dates, February 1, May 8 and May 26, and a university outcome provided May 6, 2025. Cornell lists a Formal Complaint resolved by Alternate Resolution, with four organizational Code violations and an actual two-year suspension of the chapter. This is not the earlier spring 2022 hazing case.
02. Chapter identity. The relevant chapter is Sigma Phi Society, Epsilon of New York / New York Epsilon, founded at Cornell October 4, 1890. Cornell's alumni fraternity council and the local Epsilon Association identify the Cornell chapter and its historic house at 1 Forest Park Lane, Ithaca. That documented chapter residence is background; Cornell's scorecard does not assign any of the February or May 2024 alleged incidents to that building or to a specified event there.
03. First dated episode. Cornell's official scorecard lists February 1, 2024 among the alleged-incident dates. The public entry does not describe the exact action on that day or attribute any one of the four violation categories to that particular date. It is documented as one component of a single multi-date organizational proceeding, not as a separately adjudicated offense.
04. Second dated episode. Cornell lists May 8, 2024 as a second alleged incident date. The university does not disclose its specific location, witnesses, police response or distinct alcohol or complicity mechanism. No conduct from unrelated Sigma Phi or other Cornell fraternity incidents is projected onto this date.
05. Third dated episode. The same scorecard lists May 26, 2024 as the third alleged incident date, resolved along with the February and earlier May events under the May 2025 Alternate Resolution. No original individual testimony, event registration records, specific injuries or participants are included in the public summary.
06. Alcohol Related Behavior. Cornell identifies 'Alcohol Related Behavior' as a responsible organizational violation. The entry does not specify that members provided alcohol to minors, that a person was drugged, that consumption was coerced, or that anyone required emergency treatment. Those particulars are not inferred from separate 2019, 2020, 2023 or 2022 Sigma Phi disciplinary records.
07. Collusion or Complicity. The university's second violation category is 'Collusion or Complicity'. The scorecard does not provide underlying messages, names, original witness interviews, a particular cover-up timeline or any individual criminal obstruction charge. The case preserves Cornell's organizational Code classification without manufacturing the underlying mechanism.
08. Failure to Comply. Cornell lists 'Failure to Comply' as a third violation. The public record does not name the applicable instruction, policy, person issuing it or exact failure date. This is a university group finding and not evidence of disobeying a separately identified police or court order.
09. Misconduct Related to Student Organizations. Cornell's fourth violation is 'Misconduct Related to Student Organizations'. The public scorecard provides the category but not an itemized description of the precise prohibited conduct or the number of affected persons. The organization's responsibility for the listed category is established by the university outcome.
10. Formal Complaint and Alternate Resolution. Cornell classifies the matter as 'Formal Complaint - Alternate Resolution', with a final organization-level finding and sanctions reported for May 6, 2025. The initial complaint intake date, investigative start, any hearing-stage deadlines and original agreement signature are not published in the scorecard.
11. Two-year university suspension. Cornell's sanctioned outcome is 'Suspension (2 years)'. Unlike a disciplinary warning or deferred suspension, this is an actual loss of chapter privileges. The university record does not give a specific automatic reinstatement day, and no restoration of recognition is claimed. Later first-party alumni plans refer to a pause covering academic years 2025–26 and 2026–27, targeting fall 2027 return.
12. Prohibition on identifying chapter with Cornell. Cornell's suspension expressly requires Sigma Phi to stop identifying the chapter with Cornell and stop using the university's name in that capacity. This applies to the sanctioned chapter's university-affiliation privileges, not a ban on historians or journalists accurately identifying that the organization previously existed at Cornell.
13. Withdrawal from Cornell IFC. The outcome removes the chapter from the university's Interfraternity Council. This is a chapter membership/recognition sanction separate from the historical record that Sigma Phi was once in IFC and from its later alumni associations.
14. Withdrawal from recruitment programs. Cornell removes Sigma Phi from university membership-solicitation programs and separate monitored membership-solicitation arrangements. The original wording references Campus Activities and/or the Pre-Professional Fraternity Council. It does not certify any successful approved on-campus restart during the suspension.
15. Loss of student-organization activities. The sanction also withdraws chapter access to university educational, social, philanthropic/service and athletic/intramural programs for recognized student organizations. This is a broad restriction on recognized chapter activities, not merely a limitation on social parties.
16. Prohibition on chapter use of university facilities. Cornell requires the sanctioned organization to stop using university facilities for any purpose in the chapter's name. Separately, the Epsilon Association described retaining contractual control of access to 1 Forest Park Lane and potential room rentals. These are not assumed to erase the university's chapter-use sanctions.
17. April 2, 2025 alumni acknowledgement, before university outcome. Epsilon Association leadership publicly said it had decided to pause the active chapter for two academic years after months of deliberation over behavioral and leadership problems. The source describes weak undergraduate house leadership, seniors and juniors living elsewhere, reluctance to take leadership roles except social chair, and a perceived lack of respect for Cornell administrators and the alumni organization. The letter said formal university approval of its proposed approach was still pending as of publication. This is the alumni body's stated reasoning, distinct from the subsequently issued Cornell disciplinary decision.
18. Alumni operational plan for 2025–27. The same April 2 announcement says the pause would encompass academic years 2025–26 and 2026–27, alongside significant renovation of the house and chapter culture reforms. It anticipated fall 2027 as the goal for full chapter operations. The chapter's public plan is not a Cornell recognition approval or a university directive granting early recruitment rights.
19. Alumni recruitment planning and restrictions. The 2025 letter proposed new-member recruitment by alumni leadership and the national Standing and Advisory Committee during the 2026–27 year, particularly January 2027, with professional outside assistance. The plan is not evidence that any banned university recruitment was permitted, completed, or accepted before eligibility to return.
20. January 2026 first-party progress statement. The Epsilon Association's January 2026 'Rebuilding the Brotherhood' statement says it retained a professional recruiting firm and local alumnus, initiated a capital campaign, and planned a refurbishment and eventual house reopening for August 2027. It describes a $3.5 million multiyear fundraising goal, including first-phase renovation costs and a proposed leadership institute. These facts are later alumni planning and financing, not a new Cornell misconduct finding or evidence recognition was restored.
21. Current independent chapter listing. Cornell's Alumni Interfraternity Council website labels Sigma Phi Society an 'Expansion Chapter', explaining it is being re-established and directs inquiries to Cornell's Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life. The directory gives Epsilon of New York and its historical house location. This contemporaneous public status aligns with a rebuilding plan and does not say the undergraduate chapter has already regained active university recognition.
22. Earlier 2022 university hazing case is separate. Cornell's 2022–23 Hazing Violations report established a separate spring 2022 Sigma Phi NY Epsilon case involving excessively long required attendance at the house, alcohol made available to new members, lineup interviews, and confiscation of phones plus undisclosed off-campus transport during a COVID-restricted bid day. Cornell imposed DEFERRED suspension through fall 2023, with a conditional two-academic-year suspension upon a further Code violation during that deferred period. That conditional 2023 sanction is not the same as the ACTUAL two-year suspension ordered May 6, 2025. The publicly available 2025 scorecard does not state it was activated under the 2023 deferred term.
23. Other past incidents do not supply details here. Cornell's scorecard additionally lists a separate February 17, 2023 alcohol/social event determination and older 2021, 2020 and 2019 event-management incidents. Their event details, sanctions, dates and hypothetical recurrence findings remain outside this 2024–25 dossier. Only the three specified 2024 dates and May 6, 2025 outcome are treated as one case.
24. Absent individual or criminal evidence. The original 2025 Sigma Phi entry does not identify victim or respondent names, a particular drink or drug, medical injury, assault/rape/hazing violations for THIS proceeding, criminal indictment, plea or conviction, a police incident number or a detailed incident venue. No Named Parties or Case Parties are created based on the chapter roster or speculation.
25. Integrity and case indexing. The 2024 incidents and the resulting 2025 suspension are published as one distinct canonical case under the existing Cornell Sigma Phi Society chapter ID. Cornell's organizational findings, broad restrictions and the first-party alumni acknowledgment and attempted rebuilding are documented with separate sources. The 2022–23 hazing case and every earlier published card remain unchanged.
Cornell provides EXACTLY three 2024 alleged incident dates, but not which Code violation attaches to which day. April 2 2025 alumni operational reset PROPOSED before May 6 formal university suspension. Epsilon Association later planned Jan 2027 alumni recruitment; not proof campus authorization. Separate 2022 hazing/2023 deferred-suspension case GLW prior published, unchanged. No arbitrary suspension end calendar day.
Recorded outcome
Actual two-year university suspension; chapter prohibited from identifying itself with Cornell or using university name, withdrawn from IFC and university membership-solicitation programs, excluded from recognized group educational/social/service/athletic programs, and prohibited from using university facilities in chapter name. Epsilon alumni planned operational pause 2025–26/2026–27 with fall 2027 restart goal; alumni plan not confirmed university restoration.