Case file
Cornell Sigma Phi Epsilon — 2018 Hazing, Alcohol Poisoning and 2019 Four-Year Recognition Revocation
Sigma Phi Epsilon at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell 2018–19 Academic Year Hazing Violations, Spring 2019 Sigma Phi Epsilon report; Dean Vijay Pendakur Cornell University Statements archive announcement July 12, 2019; Hunter Seitz, Cornell Daily Sun July 26, 2019; Cornell official 2016–17 Sigma Phi Epsilon hazing finding and March 17, 2017 Chronicle announcement; Cornell Organization Scorecard.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- Cornell Sorority and Fraternity Chapter Review Board found organizational responsibility for significant hazing in Spring 2018 and violations of Recognition Policy, Event Management Guidelines and Expectations for Membership. Findings upheld on appeal.
- Investigation status
- Hazing behavior occurred spring 2018; university received the report fall 2018; organizational findings appear under spring 2019 in Cornell's transparency archive; recognition revocation publicly announced July 12, 2019, with July 26 contemporaneous reporting.
- Legal status
- University disciplinary and appeal proceeding against fraternity chapter. Cornell referred the matter for possible individual accountability; reviewed public sources give no outcomes of individual disciplinary cases or criminal judgments.
Account
Cornell University's official 2018–19 Hazing Violations Transparency Report places the Sigma Phi Epsilon (SigEp) disciplinary finding under Spring 2019 and identifies the underlying new-member conduct as Spring 2018. The Office of Sorority and Fraternity Life received a report in Fall 2018, when the chapter was already operating under provisional university recognition because of an earlier Spring 2017 hazing and alcohol-related disciplinary ruling. Cornell's Sorority and Fraternity Chapter Review Board investigated the new 2018 behavior and documented several distinct practices.
REPEATED NAME GAME: Existing members forced new members to form a circle and participate in a 'name game' lasting more than an hour, answering questions posed by a fraternity brother. Wrong answers were met with verbal scolding. Cornell specifically observed that an earlier Spring 2017 organizational hazing finding involved the same kind of name game; the 2018 episode is separate new misconduct, not merely a retelling of the 2017 investigation.
COMPULSORY PHYSICAL COMPETITION: New members were paired into teams for fitness contests, including wall-sits. Members of the losing team were required to attempt to lift 50-pound weights. When some could not lift them, other new members had to perform the lifting for them. Cornell described these as fraternity-imposed new-member activities rather than voluntarily chosen workouts.
DEGRADING PRESENTATIONS: The university found that members delivered health and nutrition presentations to new members containing demeaning images of women. The public record establishes the offensive instructional material but does not reproduce or attribute every image to a named person.
'BURNING HEART' OFF-CAMPUS CEREMONY: At a farm and cabin owned by a Sigma Phi Epsilon alumnus, the fraternity held a 'Burning Heart' ceremony. According to Cornell's official findings, some new members were blindfolded and instructed to run toward a tree line. Others were ordered to uproot a tree and carry it away using only their hands. One new member was required to wear a banana costume, and others were directed to wrap themselves in bubble wrap and roll on the ground. Cornell also determined the ceremony happened after the university-approved deadline for initiating new members. The report does not identify the farm's address, specific dates or participants responsible for each instruction.
'MAMA BEAR' DRINKING AND DUNKING EVENT: During the annual 'Mama Bear' initiation-related event, new members waiting in the chapter-house gym were required to consume a soup-like mixture including hot sauce, vodka, bread, grapefruit and other ingredients. They were encouraged to slide along a table coated with soap suds and then had their heads dunked into a bucket of water. Cornell found that large amounts of alcohol were consumed before and during this event. The university's published account documents that, after Mama Bear, one new member was transported by ambulance for medical treatment for alcohol poisoning. Contemporaneous Cornell Daily Sun coverage described transport to a hospital. No student is identified by name, and the sources do not publish individual blood-alcohol data, a diagnosis beyond alcohol poisoning or the student's subsequent clinical outcome.
PRIOR 2017 RECOGNITION STATUS: Cornell had already found Sigma Phi Epsilon responsible for hazing involving a name-game ritual in Spring 2017. After an interim suspension that began February 2, 2017, the university lifted that suspension March 17 and placed the chapter on Provisional Recognition for at least a year, requiring a chapter improvement plan, membership review, live-in scholar and reformed new-member and recruitment programs. Cornell's 2018–19 report expressly identifies this prior sanction as active context when the university received the separate Fall 2018 report. The 2017 findings are background, rather than additional unadjudicated 2018 conduct.
2019 ORGANIZATIONAL FINDINGS AND APPEAL: Cornell's Sorority and Fraternity Chapter Review Board found Sigma Phi Epsilon responsible for hazing under the fraternity Recognition Policy and violations of Event Management Guidelines, Expectations for Membership and additional non-hazing recognition requirements. The university states that the findings survived the chapter's appeal. Cornell withdrew university recognition for no less than four years. A future request to return after the suspension term required university approval; if approved, the chapter would remain on Probationary Recognition for no less than two calendar years and might face additional restrictions. The university also referred the case to the Office of the Judicial Administrator for consideration of individual accountability. The public institutional materials do not identify the outcome of any individual disciplinary referrals or separate criminal prosecutions.
DATED PUBLIC OUTCOME: Cornell's University Statements archive lists Dean of Students Vijay Pendakur's 'Sigma Phi Epsilon Fraternity recognition revoked' announcement on July 12, 2019. On July 26, 2019, the Cornell Daily Sun published a detailed follow-up reporting the revocation, prior 2017 probation, hazing conduct and the medical transport. Those dates are verified publication and announcement milestones; the university's detailed hazing transparency record does not give a separately verified exact Board vote or appellate decision date. The Case Outcome Date field is therefore left empty rather than substituting the announcement date.
CURRENT STATUS AND LIMITS: Cornell's current Organization Scorecard retains the chapter's Spring 2017 judicial-history entry but does not establish an independently verified present-day Full recognition designation for Sigma Phi Epsilon. The New York Beta Cornell affiliation remains documented historically. The 2019 case documents university organizational responsibility and does not mean every present or former member personally participated in each event.
Spring 2018 is the documented period of hazing activities; exact activity dates were not published. Cornell received its report in Fall 2018 and categorized the disciplinary finding under Spring 2019. A prior Spring 2017 name-game hazing case led to provisional recognition; it is distinct from the repeated Spring 2018 misconduct. The university's July 12, 2019 announcement and July 26, 2019 newspaper report are dated public milestones, not a verified exact Board or appeal ruling date. The current scorecard's Spring 2017 history listing is not proof of current chapter recognition status.