Cornell Sigma Alpha Mu — 2024 Sexual-Assault Allegation, Member Removal Vote Reversed and Adviser Investigation

Sigma Alpha Mu's Cornell chapter president said in November 2024 that members voted to evict a man accused of sexual assault. An October 2026 Times Union investigation revealed that a senior fraternity adviser intervened, the decision was reversed in practice and the accused remained a member, as confirmed by national leadership. The adviser also made recorded claims about Cornell Police favors, which the newspaper could not independently substantiate; the national fraternity placed him on leave during an outside review. The alleged assault reportedly predated the accused man's fraternity membership.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning Cornell Sigma Alpha Mu — 2024 Sexual-Assault Allegation, Member Removal Vote Reversed and Adviser Investigation. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 19, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Alleged assault reportedly predated membership[02] Female student reported allegation to chapter circle[03] Accused member disputed the reported allegation[04] Student activism targets Sigma Alpha Mu house[05] Chapter president announces unanimous removal vote[06] President points to earlier, separate 2022 expulsion[07] Formal Cornell report not confirmed[08] December 2024 recordings obtained by Times Union[09] Adviser criticizes informal fraternity investigation[10] Chapter removal decision reversed[11] Member remains housed and affiliated[12] Police-favor claims appear in adviser recordings[13] National leadership disputes adviser-awareness account[14] Adviser disputes credibility of recordings[15] National Sigma Alpha Mu places adviser on leave[16] Investigative publication documents incomplete 2024 removal[17] No confirmed criminal or university assault adjudication
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Alleged assault reportedly predated membershipTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Allegation chronologyDate not recorded

The Times Union's interviews quote former chapter president Ramirez as saying the alleged sexual assault happened before the accused man became a member of Sigma Alpha Mu. Neither incident date nor location is supplied.

[02]Female student reported allegation to chapter circleTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Survivor reportDate not recorded

Former chapter leaders told the Times Union that a female student accused the man of sexual assault. The woman declined comment for the 2026 story. Her name and unreported personal details remain withheld.

[03]Accused member disputed the reported allegationTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Reported responseDate not recorded

According to Times Union interviews, the accused individual disputed the woman's account. An internal vote to ask a member to leave is not a finding of criminal guilt.

[04]Student activism targets Sigma Alpha Mu housewww.cornellsun.comCampus reactionNovember 11, 2024

The Cornell Daily Sun documented the vandalism of Sigma Alpha Mu and Chi Phi houses by activists criticizing a perceived fraternity sexual-violence culture. The advocacy assertions are recorded as the group's statements.

[05]Chapter president announces unanimous removal votewww.cornellsun.comLocal fraternity actionNovember 12, 2024

Cristobal Ramirez told the Daily Sun that Sigma Alpha Mu members had recently voted unanimously to evict a member in response to sexual-assault allegations.

[06]President points to earlier, separate 2022 expulsionwww.cornellsun.comIndependent older caseNovember 12, 2024

The same 2024 statement described another member expelled around 2022 while facing multiple active Title IX allegations. That retrospective event is independently indexed as GLW-REF-690.

[07]Formal Cornell report not confirmedTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026University reporting statusDate not recorded

Two former Sigma Alpha Mu chapter leaders later told the Times Union the alleged survivor had not formally reported this matter to Cornell. No specific university Title IX merits decision on the accusation is identified.

[08]December 2024 recordings obtained by Times UnionTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Documentary evidenceDate not recorded

The October 2026 investigation reviewed hours of conversations recorded by two former Sigma Alpha Mu leaders with senior adviser Dennis Paese during his December 2024 campus visit.

[09]Adviser criticizes informal fraternity investigationTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Adviser interventionDate not recorded

The recorded adviser argued chapter leaders had not followed the fraternity's own disciplinary rules and that allegations should be handled through university and law-enforcement processes rather than a rushed internal proceeding.

[10]Chapter removal decision reversedTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Later chapter reversalDate not recorded

Ramirez and two other former chapter leaders told the Times Union that Paese instructed them to reverse the decision to exclude the accused member. They said local leaders' initial decision was overruled.

[11]Member remains housed and affiliatedTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Membership statusDate not recorded

Former leaders reported the accused individual stayed at the house until the end of the academic year and retained membership afterward. National Sigma Alpha Mu executive director Andy Huston confirmed ongoing membership and said no formal expulsion request had been filed.

[12]Police-favor claims appear in adviser recordingsTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Contested police relationship assertionsDate not recorded

Paese claimed relationships with Cornell Police helped him obtain leniency for fraternity members in unrelated discipline matters. Times Union explicitly could not substantiate claims of police suppression or improper sharing of information.

[13]National leadership disputes adviser-awareness accountTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Conflicting fraternity statementsDate not recorded

Paese said university authorities were aware and national leadership would handle the allegation. Huston told the Times Union he learned of the claim from the student newspaper and said neither the adviser nor university had been aware, presenting a conflicting institutional account.

[14]Adviser disputes credibility of recordingsTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Adviser rebuttalDate not recorded

Paese challenged the allegations, criticized former president Ramirez and suggested the recordings might have been modified. The newspaper identified its recording sources and independently analyzed the materials.

[15]National Sigma Alpha Mu places adviser on leaveTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026National investigation announcementOctober 18, 2026

After the Times Union's investigation, national executive director Andy Huston said adviser Dennis Paese had been placed on leave while an outside lawyer investigated and condemned victim-blaming.

[16]Investigative publication documents incomplete 2024 removalTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Later investigative developmentOctober 18, 2026

Times Union's original October 18, 2026 story documents the December 2024 adviser intervention and member retention, materially changing the chronology that ended with the chapter's original November 2024 public vote.

[17]No confirmed criminal or university assault adjudicationTimes Union · Gabe Levin · October 18, 2026Public record limitsDate not recorded

No adjudicated sexual-assault finding, criminal charge or court disposition against the unnamed individual was established in reviewed materials. This case records the allegation, member's denial, fraternity responses and separately disputed police-related assertions.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

Cornell Sigma Alpha Mu — 2024 Sexual-Assault Allegation, Member Removal Vote Reversed and Adviser Investigation

Sigma Alpha Mu at Cornell University · NY

Reporting basis
Original Cornell Daily Sun November 12, 2024 statement from chapter president; original Albany Times Union October 18, 2026 investigation based on December 2024 recordings, former chapter leaders and national fraternity responses; existing national chapter-roll source
Incident type
Reported sexual-assault allegation and disputed fraternity internal response
Allegation status
Reported individual sexual-assault allegation, accused man's denial, chapter internal removal vote, later reversal and continued membership; adviser claims disputed
Investigation status
Former chapter officers say no formal report to Cornell. No publicly identified official sexual-assault adjudication or later criminal charge specific to this allegation in reviewed reporting
Legal status
No confirmed criminal charge, conviction or university merits judgment for this reported individual allegation; adviser/national review reported October 2026

Original assault date/place unknown and predated member joining, per former president. 2024 internal allegations distinct from 2022 former-member expulsion and Chi Phi incident. Times Union could not verify alleged police favoritism. No synthetic incident date.