- Reporting basis
- Original Cornell Daily Sun November 12, 2024 statement from chapter president; original Albany Times Union October 18, 2026 investigation based on December 2024 recordings, former chapter leaders and national fraternity responses; existing national chapter-roll source
- Incident type
- Reported sexual-assault allegation and disputed fraternity internal response
- Allegation status
- Reported individual sexual-assault allegation, accused man's denial, chapter internal removal vote, later reversal and continued membership; adviser claims disputed
- Investigation status
- Former chapter officers say no formal report to Cornell. No publicly identified official sexual-assault adjudication or later criminal charge specific to this allegation in reviewed reporting
- Legal status
- No confirmed criminal charge, conviction or university merits judgment for this reported individual allegation; adviser/national review reported October 2026
Account
01. Separate sexual-assault allegation involving a Sigma Alpha Mu member. Reporting by The Cornell Daily Sun on November 12, 2024 and the Albany Times Union on October 18, 2026 documented internal fraternity handling of a woman's sexual-assault allegation against a man who became a Cornell Sigma Alpha Mu member. The Times Union reported that the alleged assault happened before the accused man joined the fraternity. The exact incident day and place have not been made public.
02. University and community context, without conflating cases. Cornell student activists vandalized the Sigma Alpha Mu and Chi Phi houses on November 11, 2024. The activists criticized what they viewed as fraternities excusing sexual assault. Chi Phi's separate October 2024 drugging and sexual-assault case prompted the wider reaction; those allegations concern a different fraternity and are not assigned to Sigma Alpha Mu.
03. November 12 original chapter-president statement. In a written statement to The Cornell Daily Sun, Sigma Alpha Mu president Cristobal Ramirez said the chapter had recently voted unanimously to evict a member on the basis of sexual-assault allegations. He publicly described a zero-tolerance position and pointed to an earlier approximately 2022 expulsion over multiple Title IX allegations, preserved as separate GLW-REF-690.
04. Former leaders describe how the vote arose. The Times Union's original October 2026 investigation interviewed Ramirez and other former chapter leaders, who said a female student had accused the member of sexual assault. According to these leaders, the accused denied her claim and chapter leaders urged him to resign, then voted to ask him to leave. The newspaper reported that Ramirez said the alleged assault predated the man's membership.
05. The complainant's privacy. The Times Union said the woman declined to comment for the story and did not name her. Former chapter leaders told the newspaper she had not formally reported the allegation to Cornell. GLW does not speculate about her identity, her desired remedy or any unreported physical details.
06. December 2024 recorded conversations. The Times Union obtained hours of private conversations from December 2024 recorded by Ramirez and another former chapter leader during visits by Dennis Paese, the longtime Cornell Sigma Alpha Mu chapter adviser and vice president of the national Sigma Alpha Mu Foundation.
07. Adviser intervention and criticism of chapter process. Paese argued that chapter leaders had tried to sanction the accused member through an incomplete informal investigation that failed to follow fraternity disciplinary procedure. Former leaders told the newspaper he personally instructed them to reverse their decision. The chapter's original November announcement did not describe this later intervention.
08. Initial eviction decision overturned in practice. Former chapter leaders told the Times Union the member was permitted to stay in the chapter house until the end of the 2024–25 academic year. Ramirez reported he remained a fraternity member afterward; national executive director Andy Huston confirmed the individual remained a member. The national leader said no formal expulsion request was filed with the national fraternity.
09. Contradictory descriptions of university awareness. In the recordings, Paese claimed university personnel knew of the allegation, that Cornell Police had conveyed information to him and that national fraternity officials were involved. National executive director Huston offered a different account: he said he learned of the allegation from the newspaper article and asserted that neither the chapter adviser nor a university official previously knew about it. These accounts are attributed rather than presented as a resolved factual finding.
10. Alleged privileged access to police. In the recordings, Paese boasted of personal relationships with Cornell Police leaders and said he had obtained informal favors for members in unrelated matters including drug/alcohol misconduct and vandalism. The Times Union independently reviewed the recordings but explicitly said it could not establish that Cornell Police intentionally ignored complaints, improperly disclosed records, or helped him suppress any formal sexual-assault investigation.
11. Concern over chapter response. The Times Union reported that Paese said he wanted to reduce fallout from the allegation, while the former chapter leaders described being overruled. The disputed fraternity procedures and continued membership are documented organizational actions. Neither Paese's assertions nor the chapter vote amount to a criminal or university determination that the assault occurred.
12. National organization's response to the 2026 investigation. When the Times Union requested comment, national Sigma Alpha Mu executive director Andy Huston said Paese had been placed on leave while an external attorney investigated the recorded statements. Huston condemned victim-blaming and emphasized reporting violations. This is a reported national administrative response, not confirmation of police misconduct or a sexual-assault verdict.
13. Adviser challenged the recordings. Paese denied the Times Union's allegations, criticized Ramirez's credibility and suggested the recordings might have been altered. The newspaper identified the source of its recordings as two former chapter leaders. His response is retained alongside the recorded assertions and the chapter members' accounts.
14. 2025 chapter-leadership context. The newspaper reported Ramirez was removed from the Sigma Alpha Mu presidency in March 2025. This leadership change was described in connection with chapter concerns and his own account of his disengagement; the source did not establish that it was a university adjudication of the sexual-assault allegation or that it caused the accused member to leave.
15. October 18, 2026 investigative publication. Reporter Gabe Levin's Times Union investigation supplied a materially new chronology beyond the November 2024 Daily Sun public statement: the reported reversal, continued membership, the national director's confirmation and the claims captured in December 2024 recordings. Its publication date is not a newly alleged assault date.
16. Alleged conduct versus chapter process. The Times Union reported the accused man disputed the woman's account; no criminal charge, Cornell Title IX decision, court disposition or independently confirmed personal misconduct finding arising from this specific allegation was identified in the reviewed public records. The case concerns a reported sexual-assault allegation and documented/disputed chapter handling.
17. Chapter canonical relationship. Sigma Alpha Mu's Cornell Beta Chapter is an existing Northeast chapter under chap_sigma_alpha_mu_cornell_university. No new chapter, fraternity, university or URL alias is needed. The historical house-related discussion does not establish the alleged assault's location; the case does not assert that the alleged assault happened at the fraternity house.
18. Independence from other proceedings. Cornell's separate 2021 hazing finding and the approximately 2022 Title IX-related former-member expulsion reported by Ramirez remain distinct from the 2024 internal removal dispute. The Chi Phi 2024 allegation is also separate. This GLW case counts one later allegation/response episode and does not assign the Sigma Alpha Mu accused student to the Chi Phi investigation.
19. Evidence preservation. The November 2024 Daily Sun report and October 2026 Times Union investigation are already published as source records in Northeast for another Cornell case. This implementation reuses their original source IDs and links them independently to this case rather than creating duplicate source cards or changing the existing CornellSeven-derived cards.
Original assault date/place unknown and predated member joining, per former president. 2024 internal allegations distinct from 2022 former-member expulsion and Chi Phi incident. Times Union could not verify alleged police favoritism. No synthetic incident date.