Case file
Cornell Pi Kappa Phi — 2016 Photographed Underwear-and-Marker Hazing, Interim Suspension and Two-Year Provisional Recognition
Pi Kappa Phi at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell official 2015–16 Hazing Violations report (Spring 2016 Pi Kappa Phi finding); Cornell Daily Sun February 24 and June 3, 2016 reporting; separate official 2010–11 hazing archive and Cornell Chronicle January 16, 2013 for historical context; Cornell current Organization Scorecard and Alumni Interfraternity Council Pi Kappa Phi profile.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board determined that the Pi Kappa Phi chapter violated the Recognition Policy; Cornell's investigation confirmed photographed demeaning hazing. Initial broader allegations of intimidation, harassment, alcohol use and calisthenics were reported at suspension stage without separate detailed final findings for each.
- Investigation status
- OFSIL received Facebook-photo report February 22, 2016; university interim suspension began February 23; Fraternity and Sorority Review Board hearing May 5; by June 3, 2016 Cornell had lifted interim suspension and publicly confirmed the chapter's two-year provisional-recognition sanction.
- Legal status
- Cornell institutional organizational disciplinary finding and provisional recognition. The cited official finding does not document an individual criminal prosecution or conviction arising from the photographed 2016 hazing activity.
Account
Cornell University's 2015–16 Hazing Violations Transparency Report documents an investigation into Pi Kappa Phi's spring 2016 new-member activities. The record's central evidence was a Facebook photograph reported to the Office of Fraternities, Sororities, and Independent Living (OFSIL) on February 22, 2016. The university placed the chapter on interim suspension while investigators assessed the photograph and other reported allegations.
PHOTOGRAPHIC HAZING EVIDENCE: Cornell describes two new members posing with their respective fraternity 'Big Brothers' in a photograph that was shared on Facebook. The new members were wearing only underwear; their bodies had been drawn on with black markers, and both appeared wet, either from sweat or water. Cases of beer were visible near the group. Cornell's subsequent investigation confirmed that the photograph depicted demeaning hazing of the new members. The official published report does not specify the date the image was taken, the individuals' identities, whether the photograph documented forced alcohol consumption, or any medical harm resulting from the photographed incident. The documented presence of cases of beer is distinct from a finding that either pictured new member was forced to drink.
INITIAL BROADER ALLEGATIONS: A February 24 Cornell Daily Sun report quoted university statements identifying an initial set of hazing allegations against Pi Kappa Phi involving intimidation, verbal abuse, harassment, alcohol consumption and calisthenics. Those statements accompanied the interim suspension, when the investigation was still in progress. Cornell's subsequently published 2015–16 finding specifically describes and substantiates the demeaning photographed underwear-and-marker hazing. It does not separately provide findings establishing each earlier alleged practice. The broader allegations are therefore attributed to the initial university announcement and not presented as independently substantiated conduct in this case.
FEBRUARY 23 INTERIM SUSPENSION: Cornell placed Pi Kappa Phi on interim suspension effective Tuesday, February 23, 2016, according to contemporary Cornell Daily Sun reporting. During the suspension the fraternity was barred from chapter activities except those necessary for maintaining the residence. The report also concerned a separate interim suspension of Phi Gamma Delta; its February 2016 alcohol-medical-emergency findings belong to Phi Gamma Delta and are not attributed to Pi Kappa Phi. The Pi Kappa Phi interim suspension was temporary pending institutional review, not a permanent revocation of its charter.
MAY 5 REVIEW BOARD: Cornell's official transparency report identifies a Fraternity and Sorority Review Board hearing on May 5, 2016. The university Board found Pi Kappa Phi violated the Fraternity and Sorority Recognition Policy and changed the chapter's status from Full Recognition to Provisional Recognition for no less than two years. The stated minimum probationary term was scheduled to end May 5, 2018. The public report does not establish the specific date the final Board decision was transmitted, a separate appeal result, or a later compliance finding on May 5, 2018.
CONDITIONS OF PROVISIONAL RECOGNITION: Cornell required the fraternity to meet every goal in a chapter improvement document submitted at the May 5 hearing. The Board ordered a live-in advisor in the fraternity facility before the start of fall 2016 classes, with OFSIL assistance on advisor hiring and training as resources allowed. It also required a university-reviewed chapter-wide recruitment plan that was alcohol-free and aligned with fraternity and Cornell values, plus a member and new-member education and accountability plan. These conditions were part of the minimum two-year provisional status; the original report establishes the requirements rather than documenting completion of each item.
JUNE 2016 PUBLIC RESOLUTION: In a June 3, 2016 article updated June 5, The Cornell Daily Sun reported that Cornell had lifted the interim suspension after confirming hazing and had placed Pi Kappa Phi under at least two years of provisional recognition. The newspaper reported that the chapter could continue recruiting new members while on probation and faced immediate revocation of recognition if additional policies were violated during the provisional period. That account reflects the university's stated conditional sanction, not evidence that such a later automatic revocation occurred.
PRIOR, DISTINCT INSTITUTIONAL HISTORY: The fraternity had earlier Cornell findings unrelated to the February 2016 photograph. Cornell's 2010–11 hazing report records a police report received April 13, 2011 concerning a required new-member scavenger hunt. Cornell found a Level 1 Anti-Hazing Policy violation and imposed an official warning and New Member Education before the end of spring 2011 with at least 80 percent chapter attendance. A separate January 16, 2013 Cornell Chronicle announcement records at least four years of provisional recognition for Pi Kappa Phi, effective January 14, 2013, involving three incidents over 12 months and an underage-drinking-related hospitalization in November 2012. The public 2016 report nonetheless identifies the chapter's status immediately before its 2016 ruling as Full Recognition. The reviewed records do not explain every intervening status change. Those previous incidents and hospitalization are not attributed to the February 2016 photographic hazing finding.
LATER CHAPTER STATUS: Cornell's current Student & Campus Life Organization Scorecard identifies Pi Kappa Phi as the Psi chapter at 55 Ridgewood Road and lists its status as Full recognition. The scorecard also contains separate 2019, 2020 and 2022 chapter-disciplinary entries, including a March 2020 alcohol/event case that notes alleged hazing among several allegations, with its own resolution. Cornell's Alumni Interfraternity Council likewise lists the active Pi Kappa Phi Psi chapter and 55 Ridgewood Road property. Later recognition and other cases are context, not revisions of the 2016 hazing finding.
Cornell's 2016 ruling is a chapter-level administrative determination. The published record does not identify all people in the photograph, establish wrongdoing by every chapter member or report an individual criminal conviction arising from this photographed incident.
Photo report received February 22, 2016; the underlying act's exact day is unknown. The wider allegations quoted on February 24 were initial investigative allegations, whereas the final university report substantiates the photographed demeaning underwear-and-marker hazing. May 5, 2016 is the Board hearing date, and May 5, 2018 is the stated minimum provisional-recognition term end, not a verified final decision date or documented return to Full recognition. Prior 2011 and 2012–13 cases and later 2019–2022 matters are separate. A medical hospitalization mentioned in Cornell's January 2013 report relates to a November 2012 event, not this 2016 photographed hazing incident.