Case file
Cornell Phi Kappa Psi — Antonio Tsialas's Death Following 2019 Hazing Event
Phi Kappa Psi at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell official hazing findings and presidential statements; filed civil complaint; contemporary reporting; police investigation outcome; family counsel's public settlement announcement
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- University substantiated organizational hazing and multiple policy violations; circumstances of fatal fall questioned by family
- Investigation status
- Cornell University Police investigation closed November 2020; university disciplinary proceeding concluded in permanent chapter derecognition
- Legal status
- No criminal charges filed in Antonio's death; family filed civil negligence and wrongful-death action in January 2020; settlement with Cornell announced December 1, 2020
- Incident start date
- 2019-10-24
- Incident end date
- 2019-10-26
Account
Antonio Tsialas had only recently begun his freshman year at Cornell University. A talented soccer goalkeeper and the oldest of three children, Antonio was known by his family and teammates for looking out for others.
On October 24, 2019, during Cornell's Family Weekend, Antonio attended an invitation-only Phi Kappa Psi recruitment event after having dinner with his mother. The fraternity called the event “Christmas in October.” Cornell's subsequent investigation found that the chapter had arranged an unauthorized event with themed rooms, hard liquor and drinking games. Students were encouraged to drink heavily, and some became so intoxicated that they blacked out, vomited or lost their bearings. The fraternity did not use Cornell's medical amnesty protocol or call 911 for the severely impaired participants.
Antonio never returned to his dormitory. When he failed to meet his mother the following morning, his parents began searching for him. On October 26, emergency personnel recovered his body from Fall Creek Gorge.
His parents, John Tsialas and Flavia Tomasello, spent the following year pushing for answers about what happened after Antonio left the fraternity event. In January 2020, they filed a civil lawsuit against Cornell, Phi Kappa Psi, its local chapter association and individuals. The complaint described dangerous hazing practices and alleged that Cornell failed to prevent misconduct despite earlier warnings about the chapter.
Cornell's own disciplinary investigation subsequently found Phi Kappa Psi responsible for hazing and multiple fraternity-policy violations. In 2020 the university permanently withdrew the chapter's recognition. It said the organization could not apply to return.
Cornell University Police concluded its investigation in November 2020, determining that Antonio died in an accidental fall. The district attorney filed no criminal charges. Investigators said they could not establish Antonio's route from the fraternity house to the gorge or why he reached the overlook. His family and their attorneys questioned whether the investigation had uncovered the full account of his final hours.
In December 2020, the family's attorneys announced a civil settlement with Cornell, including compensation, disclosure of the university police investigation file, a permanent scholarship honoring Antonio and hazing-prevention commitments. The family went on to establish the Antonio Tsialas Leadership Foundation, sharing his story and promoting compassionate leadership.
Antonio's parents' search for answers, Cornell's documented findings against the chapter, and the university's permanent sanctions remain part of the record. The fraternity's established violations are not the same thing as a criminal finding that anyone caused Antonio's fatal fall.
Cornell's hazing determination concerns the fraternity event; police classified the death as an accidental fall. The family's attorneys publicly questioned whether all circumstances were known. Civil claims and settlement are separate from criminal findings.