Cornell Phi Kappa Psi — Antonio Tsialas's Death Following 2019 Hazing Event

Antonio Tsialas, an 18-year-old Cornell freshman, disappeared after attending an unauthorized Phi Kappa Psi recruitment event on October 24, 2019. His body was found in Fall Creek Gorge two days later. Cornell found the chapter responsible for hazing and permanently withdrew its recognition.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning Cornell Phi Kappa Psi — Antonio Tsialas's Death Following 2019 Hazing Event. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 2, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Antonio Attends Phi Kappa Psi's Unauthorized Recruitment Event[02] Antonio's Body Found in Fall Creek Gorge[03] Cornell Acknowledges the Party and Greek-Life Misconduct[04] Cornell Announces Fraternity Reforms After Antonio's Death[05] Antonio's Parents File Civil Lawsuit Against Cornell and Phi Kappa Psi[06] Judge Allows the Family's Negligence Claim Against Cornell to Proceed[07] Cornell Permanently Revokes Phi Kappa Psi Recognition[08] Police Close Investigation; Family Announces Settlement with Cornell[09] GLW Archives Antonio's Case and the Family's Continuing Prevention Work[10] Police Close Investigation into Antonio Tsialas's Death Without Criminal Charges[12] Antonio Tsialas Remembered: Compassionate Leadership and Family Foundation[13] Cornell Hazing Prevention Timeline — Tsialas Family Participates in 2023 Panel
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Antonio Attends Phi Kappa Psi's Unauthorized Recruitment EventHazing at Cornell / Cornell UniversityHazing; original incidentOctober 24, 2019

Antonio Tsialas, 18, had been settling into his first semester at Cornell. On the night of October 24, 2019, after dinner with his mother during Family Weekend, he attended a recruitment event at Phi Kappa Psi. Cornell later found that the chapter had staged a prohibited event involving hard liquor, themed drinking games, hazing and heavily intoxicated first-year students. The chapter did not call emergency services for impaired participants.

Antonio did not make it back to his dormitory. His family has spent years seeking a complete account of his last hours.

[02]Antonio's Body Found in Fall Creek GorgeThe Cornell Daily SunStudent death; family searchOctober 26, 2019

When Antonio did not meet his mother on Friday, October 25, his family knew something was wrong. They began searching, hoping he could be found safe. On October 26, emergency personnel recovered his body from Fall Creek Gorge.

Antonio's parents, John Tsialas and Flavia Tomasello, lost their oldest child, a talented goalkeeper remembered for protecting and encouraging his teammates.

[03]Cornell Acknowledges the Party and Greek-Life MisconductCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityUniversity responseNovember 8, 2019

Cornell President Martha Pollack confirmed that an unregistered fraternity event took place on October 24, with alcohol served and first-year students attending. She described a continuing pattern of misconduct within the Greek system and endorsed student leaders' pause on social events.

The university's public acknowledgment came while Antonio's family was still trying to understand what happened to him.

[04]Cornell Announces Fraternity Reforms After Antonio's DeathCornell Chronicle / Cornell UniversityUniversity investigation and reformDecember 18, 2019

Cornell announced additional fraternity oversight and recruitment reforms. Pollack acknowledged Antonio had last been seen at Phi Kappa Psi's party and that police still could not account for his movements before his death.

The president also disclosed that Phi Kappa Psi had faced a disciplinary hearing only one day before the unauthorized October 24 party. The fraternity was under interim suspension at that point.

[05]Antonio's Parents File Civil Lawsuit Against Cornell and Phi Kappa PsiSupreme Court of the State of New York, Tompkins CountyCivil lawsuitJanuary 28, 2020

John Tsialas and Flavia Tomasello filed a civil complaint against Cornell, Phi Kappa Psi, its local chapter association and individuals. The lawsuit alleged that dangerous hazing practices and failures to address prior misconduct exposed Antonio and other first-year students to foreseeable danger.

The original court-filed complaint is linked in the record. Those allegations are the family's claims in litigation; Cornell's later disciplinary findings independently establish the chapter's hazing violations.

[06]Judge Allows the Family's Negligence Claim Against Cornell to ProceedThe Cornell Daily SunCivil court rulingSeptember 4, 2020

A Tompkins County judge rejected Cornell's attempt to dismiss the family's negligence and premises-liability claim, allowing the lawsuit to continue. The court's September 4 ruling was publicly reported September 17.

This was a meaningful procedural development for Antonio's family, though the court had not yet decided the case after a trial.

[07]Cornell Permanently Revokes Phi Kappa Psi RecognitionHazing at Cornell / Cornell UniversityUniversity findings and sanctionsSeptember 30, 2020

Cornell's organization misconduct board found Phi Kappa Psi responsible for hazing and multiple university-policy violations arising from the October 2019 event. The official findings describe intoxicated participants, vomiting and blackouts, dangerous drinking games and no call for emergency medical attention.

Cornell permanently withdrew the New York Alpha chapter's recognition. The university stated that the chapter could never apply to regain recognition. September 30 is the publication date of contemporary coverage; Cornell's official report places the decision in fall 2020.

[08]Police Close Investigation; Family Announces Settlement with CornellStewart Tilghman Fox Bianchi & Cain, P.A.Police outcome and civil settlementDecember 1, 2020

By November 30, Cornell University Police reported completing their investigation into Antonio's death. Investigators classified it as an accidental fall, said they could not determine Antonio's route to the gorge and found insufficient grounds for criminal charges. His parents and their attorneys continued to ask whether the full story had been uncovered.

On December 1, the family's lawyers announced a settlement with Cornell. It provided compensation, access to the police investigation file, a scholarship in Antonio's name, and university hazing-prevention commitments.

[09]GLW Archives Antonio's Case and the Family's Continuing Prevention WorkLos Angeles MagazineArchive update and memorialNovember 2, 2026

November 2, 2026 — GLW archive update.

We added the original complaint, Cornell's formal hazing findings, reporting on the police investigation and civil settlement, and material remembering Antonio's life. Cornell's own 2023 prevention timeline records Antonio's parents joining George Desdunes's mother at an anti-hazing film screening and discussion.

An October 14, 2026 retrospective also examined the university's earlier warnings and court filings surrounding Phi Kappa Psi. The publication dates of those sources are preserved separately; November 2 is the date GLW updated this archive.

[10]Police Close Investigation into Antonio Tsialas's Death Without Criminal ChargesThe Cornell Daily SunContemporary police-case outcome reportingNovember 30, 2020

Cornell University Police concluded its investigation, classifying the death as an accidental fall while acknowledging they could not determine Antonio's route to the gorge. Prosecutors filed no criminal charges. Police also reported student conduct referrals.

[12]Antonio Tsialas Remembered: Compassionate Leadership and Family FoundationUniversity of Virginia Gordie CenterFamily memorial and prevention profile2021

A family-centered memorial article describes Antonio as a soccer goalkeeper and supportive teammate, his parents and siblings, and the Antonio Tsialas Leadership Foundation created to prevent hazing and encourage compassionate leadership.

[13]Cornell Hazing Prevention Timeline — Tsialas Family Participates in 2023 PanelHazing at Cornell / Cornell UniversityOfficial university prevention timelineDate not recorded

Cornell records that Antonio's parents, John Tsialas and Flavia Tomasello, joined Marie Andre, mother of George Desdunes, for a 2023 film screening and panel during National Hazing Prevention Week.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

Cornell Phi Kappa Psi — Antonio Tsialas's Death Following 2019 Hazing Event

Phi Kappa Psi at Cornell University · NY

Reporting basis
Cornell official hazing findings and presidential statements; filed civil complaint; contemporary reporting; police investigation outcome; family counsel's public settlement announcement
Incident type
Hazing
Allegation status
University substantiated organizational hazing and multiple policy violations; circumstances of fatal fall questioned by family
Investigation status
Cornell University Police investigation closed November 2020; university disciplinary proceeding concluded in permanent chapter derecognition
Legal status
No criminal charges filed in Antonio's death; family filed civil negligence and wrongful-death action in January 2020; settlement with Cornell announced December 1, 2020
Incident start date
2019-10-24
Incident end date
2019-10-26

Cornell's hazing determination concerns the fraternity event; police classified the death as an accidental fall. The family's attorneys publicly questioned whether all circumstances were known. Civil claims and settlement are separate from criminal findings.