Case file
Cornell Phi Delta Theta — Multiyear Hazing, Forced Drinking, Blindfolding, Oil Wrestling and 2026 Suspension
Phi Delta Theta at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell University OSCCS 2025–26 Hazing Violations Transparency Report, Phi Delta Theta section; Cornell SFL Organization Scorecard; Phi Delta Theta national headquarters March 6, 2026 statement; Cornell Alumni Interfraternity Council dormant-charter listing.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- Organizational responsibility established by Cornell Alternate Resolution for alcohol-related behavior, assault/endangerment, hazing and student-organization misconduct.
- Investigation status
- OSCCS investigation started August 14, 2025, temporary suspension imposed September 5, 2025, formal investigation concluded with findings/outcome January 26, 2026.
- Legal status
- University organizational disciplinary resolution and national chapter suspension acknowledgment; the cited public records do not establish a criminal prosecution or conviction for any named individual in this matter.
Account
Cornell University's Office of Student Conduct and Community Standards (OSCCS) formally investigated hazing by the Phi Delta Theta chapter. Cornell's 2025–26 Hazing Violations Transparency Report identifies alleged conduct beginning on or about spring 2022 and continuing through spring 2025. However, Cornell's current Organization Scorecard identifies a different beginning—March 1, 2024, continuing through the spring 2024 and spring 2025 semesters. Both descriptions are reproduced as officially published; the conflict has not been resolved, so no exact incident start day is assigned. Cornell received a report in fall 2025, initiated investigation on August 14, 2025, and imposed an interim temporary suspension September 5, 2025. A formal complaint and investigation were completed; Cornell OSCCS, the complainant and Phi Delta Theta's national headquarters agreed via Alternate Resolution that the chapter had violated the Student Code of Conduct provisions on alcohol-related behavior, assault and endangerment, hazing, and misconduct related to student organizations or groups.
ALCOHOL AND DRUG PRESSURE: The official university finding describes encouragement, coercion or force directed at new members to consume alcohol during the new-member process and lineups, including drinking to the point of blacking out. Members required new members to perform plays before the fraternity brotherhood after consuming alcohol. The finding also states that new members were encouraged to consume unspecified drugs until they were 'too high.' Cornell does not name the substances or provide medical records or a specific number of affected individuals in its published chapter-level account.
LINEUPS, TESTING AND PHYSICAL PUNISHMENT: New members had to line up and recite the Greek alphabet; errors required push-ups or restarting the exercise. They filled in personal questionnaires and memorized one another's answers; errors in subsequent quizzes were punished. The chapter required push-ups and wall sits during the new-member process and, as penalties, required chugging nonalcoholic beer, taking a bite of an onion or completing additional physical activity. Cornell additionally described a 'Fitness Test' before initiation requiring new members to run a mile as a group and/or complete push-ups and other physical tasks.
FOOD-RELATED COERCION: Cornell documented a trip to Spring Buffet in Ithaca where new members were made to eat as much as possible before returning to the fraternity house for 'Taco Night,' where they were pressured to eat tacos while tacos were thrown at them. This is a documented humiliating/coercive practice; the public finding does not specify that an eating-related hospitalization occurred.
BLINDFOLDING, ABANDONMENT AND SURPRISE TRAVEL: New members were blindfolded and dropped at random locations during nighttime hours. Other blindfolded new members were led around the chapter house, including up and down stairwells, and to a chapter ceremony where they received a 'pledge name.' Cornell found that new members were taken on trips without advance notice of their destinations, including to another university and a casino. The university does not identify which school or casino, establish an injury from these activities or publish their exact dates.
'OLIVE MAN' AND OTHER ACTIVITIES: Cornell describes a practice called 'Olive Man' that happened across multiple semesters, requiring new members to strip to their underwear or shorts, cover themselves in olive oil and wrestle fraternity members significantly larger than they were. New members were also given wood and told to start a fire in a backyard fire pit without initially being given a lighter; after several minutes one was provided. Cornell describes these acts as part of the substantiated organizational misconduct, but does not provide specific dates for each activity or name individual participants.
UNIVERSITY DISCIPLINARY RESOLUTION: Cornell's investigation concluded with a finding and outcome delivered January 26, 2026. Through Alternate Resolution, OSCCS, the complainant and Phi Delta Theta headquarters agreed to the organizational findings. The chapter was suspended from university recognition/registration effective immediately through the end of fall semester 2027, losing the privileges and benefits of university recognition. The earliest eligibility to SEEK university permission to return is spring 2028; reinstatement is not automatic. Cornell's current official scorecard lists the chapter as Suspended, and its alumni IFC profile lists the New York Alpha charter as dormant.
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS CONFIRMATION: On March 6, 2026, Phi Delta Theta national executive vice president and CEO Sean S. Wagner publicly identified New York Alpha at Cornell among three chapters whose suspensions followed risk-management violations. That communication corroborates the national organization's sanction acknowledgment; it does not provide a separate Cornell-specific factual list of hazing acts or evidence that any particular student was expelled.
SEPARATE SCORECARD RECORDS: The Cornell scorecard also lists a September 1, 2025 alcohol and student-organization misconduct case resolved September 29, 2025, as well as older organization-policy entries. The September 2025 incident is separately adjudicated from this January 2026 hazing resolution. It is not silently added to the hazing allegations. All findings here are institutional chapter-level findings, not individual criminal convictions.
Official university date discrepancy: Cornell Hazing Violations Transparency Report says misconduct began 'on or about Spring 2022' and continued through spring 2025; current Cornell Organization Scorecard says 'March 1, 2024' and through spring 2024 and spring 2025. Exact Case Incident Start Date intentionally left empty rather than choosing a conflicting official date. The 2025–26 transparency page places this case in Spring 2026 because of 2026 disposition, not because misconduct is specifically found to have begun in 2026. A distinct September 2025 alcohol-related scorecard proceeding must not be merged into this adjudication. The institutional 'Assault and Endangerment' category is a Code violation, not proof of individual physical assault or conviction.