Case file
Cornell Chi Psi — 2014 Repeat Hazing, Recognition Revocation and Appellate Reduction
Chi Psi at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell official 2013–14 Hazing Violations Chi Psi record; March 5 2014 Cornell Chronicle suspension; May 2 Cornell revocation; May 19 Cornell appeal (effective May 15); contemporary Cornell Daily Sun March/May 2014 reports; August 2016 recolonization report; Cornell scorecard.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- Cornell University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board unanimously found chapter responsible for University Recognition Policy hazing violations; findings upheld on appeal.
- Investigation status
- Report and Cornell interim suspension March 5, 2014; review board recognition withdrawal May 2; appeal decision effective May 15; public appeal announcement May 19. May 2015 later acknowledgment and planned 2016 recolonization documented.
- Legal status
- University organizational disciplinary hazing finding and appellate recognition sanction; not a finding of individual criminal guilt.
Account
SEPARATE SPRING 2014 CHI PSI ORGANIZATIONAL HAZING CASE. Cornell University's 2013–2014 Hazing Violations report describes new-member hazing in the Cornell Chi Psi (Alpha Psi) fraternity house. It is separate from the chapter's Spring 2013 finding for forced servitude, basement conditions and humiliating trips to other fraternities.
UNDATED SPRING 2014 HAZING PRACTICES. Cornell received insider reports that new members were blindfolded, pushed around and yelled at during late-night fraternity-house activities. New members were assigned additional cleaning duties, made to memorize extensive information unrelated to legitimate fraternal knowledge, and subjected to oral quizzes deliberately designed to create intense intimidation. Cornell's public report protects the identities of insiders and does not list dates for every activity, hours of confinement, identified student respondents, or specific diagnosed injuries.
REPEAT MISCONDUCT DURING 2013 PROBATION. Cornell had imposed four calendar years of provisional (probationary) recognition effective May 17, 2013 in a separate case. The new Spring 2014 hazing conduct was reported and considered while that probation remained operative. The university routed the matter to the Fraternity and Sorority Review Board.
MARCH 5 REPORT AND CORNELL INTERIM SUSPENSION. Cornell's Fraternity and Sorority Life staff received a report on March 5, 2014 from confidential persons within Chi Psi. Cornell Chronicle confirmed that THE UNIVERSITY imposed an interim suspension that day for credible serious hazing allegations, pausing all chapter operations other than maintaining its residence. This is distinct from the prior 2013 restriction imposed by Chi Psi national headquarters. Contemporary March 5 Cornell Daily Sun reporting quoted associate dean Travis Apgar saying the source suggested hazing might have occurred over several weeks. No exact start date was established.
REVIEW BOARD FINDING. Cornell's official 2013–14 case summary records that the Fraternity and Sorority Review Board unanimously found the chapter in violation of Cornell's University Recognition Policy prohibition on hazing. The Dean of Students accepted that organizational finding. The published university account does not provide the date of the underlying hearing separately from the university's May 2 action.
MAY 2 ORIGINAL REVOCATION. Cornell announced immediate withdrawal of Chi Psi's university recognition on May 2, 2014 for a minimum of THREE years, initially directing that the chapter house close at the end of spring semester. Loss of recognition also ended recognized chapter benefits, including recruitment. The original terms were expressly subject to appeal and were superseded in material part.
MAY 15 CONTROLLING APPELLATE OUTCOME. Cornell's May 19 university announcement states that Vice President Susan Murphy's appeal decision became effective MAY 15, 2014. She UPHELD the unanimous hazing determination and revocation but REDUCED the minimum loss-of-recognition period from three years to TWO. There was a CONDITIONAL option for one year of lost recognition followed by one year probation if conditions were satisfied. After two years lost recognition, or one year lost plus one year probation if eligible, the chapter could APPLY for campus return. This was not an automatic reinstatement after one year or at the end of two years. If accepted, the chapter would serve TWO additional years of Provisional Recognition before it could qualify for full recognition.
APPEAL CONDITIONS. Cornell's detailed 2013–14 transparency entry specifies members' acknowledgment of the wrongdoing; undergraduate and alumni education about hazing under New York law and Cornell policy; continuing education and cultural reform; public commitment to a restructured FOUR-WEEK new-member program that eliminates abusive pledging power dynamics; complete abolition of lineups; and full implementation of a ten-point improvement plan created after the separate 2013 matter. These were compliance conditions attached to the return pathway, not evidence of their immediate completion.
HOUSE DECISION ON APPEAL. Although the May 2 notice initially required the house to close, the May 15 appeal returned authority to decide whether to close or keep the house open to the House Corporation, subject to requirements including a LIVE-IN ADVISER and NO SOCIAL EVENTS while the chapter lacked recognition.
MAY 19 PUBLIC STATEMENT. Cornell publicly summarized the May 15 effective appeal decision on May 19. These dates are different steps and are not interchangeable.
MAY 2015 ACKNOWLEDGMENT. Cornell's published academic-year report includes a later annotation that former student leaders of Chi Psi privately and publicly acknowledged responsibility for the acts in the 2014 proceedings and apologized in MAY 2015. Exact apology day is unspecified; no precise date should be inferred. Cornell notes plans for education involving students and alumni.
2016 PLANNED RECOLONIZATION AND CURRENT STATUS. The Cornell Daily Sun published an August 30, 2016 account of Chi Psi's planned recolonization after two years without recognition, supported by national and alumni efforts. August 30 is the newspaper publication date, not a proven exact university authorization or reinstatement date. Cornell's current University Organization Scorecard identifies the Chi Psi Alpha Psi Lodge at 810 University Avenue and lists it as Full recognition. Separate later incidents are not part of this 2014 case.
ACCOUNTABILITY SCOPE. Cornell's finding concerns the fraternity chapter. It does not assign individual responsibility to every student listed on an unrelated historic membership roster. GLW maintains the 2013 and 2014 cases separately, with distinct original findings and adjudications.
Spring2014 conduct dates unspecified; March5 was report receipt and university interim suspension. May2 revocation initial three-year minimum, not final. May15 effective appeal reduces minimum to two years with conditional alternative and later provisional period; May19 is announcement. May2015 acknowledgment month only. Aug30 2016 news date not exact reinstatement. Separate Spring2013 case not merged.