Case file
Cornell Chi Psi — Spring 2013 Servitude, Psychological Hazing and Four-Year Provisional Recognition
Chi Psi at Cornell University · NY
- Reporting basis
- Cornell 2012–13 Hazing Violations report, 2013 Chi Psi entry; Cornell Chronicle March 3 and June 27, 2013 university statements; contemporaneous Cornell Daily Sun March 3; Cornell current scorecard; Cornell's May 2014 appeal decision only as separate later-case context.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- Cornell University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board found organizational responsibility for recognition-policy violations involving hazing.
- Investigation status
- National suspension February 28, 2013; Review Board hearing April 26, 2013; provisional recognition effective May 17, 2013; university publicly announced outcome June 27, 2013.
- Legal status
- Organizational university disciplinary hazing determination; not a finding of individual criminal guilt; later 2014 recognition revocation is separate.
Account
Cornell University's 2012–13 Hazing Violations report documents a Chi Psi Alpha Psi organizational hazing finding concerning new members during the spring 2013 semester. The university's report unexpectedly files the entry under 'Fall 2012', although its narrative expressly says Spring 2013. Cornell's contemporaneous March and June 2013 announcements also establish the spring 2013 timeline. No precise day of each hazing activity is known.
SERVITUDE AND REQUIRED PERSONAL FAVORS: Cornell found that new members were made to perform excessive chores and other menial duties exceeding obligations of initiated members. They also had to perform favors for existing members, including driving services. The published record does not identify individual students who demanded the chores or rides.
BASEMENT SLEEPING AND LOUD MUSIC: New members were required to spend extensive time in the fraternity house's basement. They sometimes ate there, slept on hard surfaces and were repeatedly subjected to loud music. Cornell described these practices as parts of the coercive new-member program but did not specify exact durations, medical injuries or participant identities.
BACKWARD STAIR-WALKING: Cornell found that new members had to walk backwards while ascending stairs. The university included this requirement in the account of the chapter's hazing activities.
DEGRADING OFF-CAMPUS TRIPS: New members were required to visit Chi Psi chapters on other campuses. Cornell found they were demeaned and exposed to mentally or emotionally abusive treatment there. The report describes pressure to consume a beer-and-pickle-juice mixture falsely presented as urine. It does not say that the substance actually contained urine, name the visited universities or establish that every new member swallowed the mixture.
NATIONAL FRATERNITY SUSPENSION: Cornell's March 3, 2013 Chronicle reports that Chi Psi national headquarters suspended the chapter effective February 28, 2013, following credible serious hazing allegations. Chapter activities required approval from its national organization and Cornell's fraternity office. This was the NATIONAL organization's suspension, distinct from Cornell interim suspensions imposed on Sigma Nu and Delta Phi in the same university announcement. The university does not give Chi Psi's precise online-report receipt date.
REVIEW BOARD HEARING: Cornell's June 27, 2013 Chronicle dates the Chi Psi University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board hearing to April 26, 2013. The Board found that the Alpha Psi chapter violated the university Recognition Policy as applied to hazing. The Board is not interchangeable with Cornell's separate peer-run Greek Judicial Board, which considered other chapters that year. This is a disciplinary finding against the chapter, not a criminal adjudication of individual students.
FOUR-YEAR PROVISIONAL RECOGNITION: Cornell's 2012–13 official hazing entry establishes May 17, 2013 as the EFFECTIVE date of Provisional Recognition for no less than four CALENDAR years. This was probationary recognition, not revocation. Conditions described by Cornell included restructuring chapter leadership and practices; providing hazing-policy education for all members; collaborating with the international organization, alumni and OFSIL on a compliant orientation program; employing a live-in adviser; and appearing before the Review Board after one year to assess progress and continued recognition. The report confirms the requirement for review, not that the later review occurred.
RECRUITMENT CONDITIONS: Cornell allowed Chi Psi to take part in fall 2013 and January 2014 new-member recruitment during provisional status but removed one day of January 2014 formal recruitment. It does not identify which recruitment date was lost.
JUNE 27 PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT: Cornell publicly reported the April 26 hearing, chapter-level finding and required reforms on June 27, 2013. The June date is publication, not the May 17 effective date.
LATER, DISTINCT 2014 PROCEEDING: A new spring 2014 hazing investigation resulted in March 2014 university interim suspension and May 2 revocation of recognition. Cornell's May 19 public statement says an appeal ruling effective May 15, 2014 upheld the NEW revocation but revised its duration and conditional return path. The 2014 recognition-loss sanctions are not the 2013 four-year provisional-recognition sanction; they superseded the 2013 chapter-status trajectory. Contemporary August 2016 reporting documents recolonization following the later suspension, and the current Cornell Organization Scorecard lists Chi Psi Alpha Psi (The Lodge, 810 University Avenue) with Full recognition. The independent 2014 violations and appeal belong in their own GLW case.
The official findings describe chapter conduct, not personal guilt for every person who ever belonged to the fraternity. Cornell did not name the involved new members or personally adjudicate historical roster members in this published entry.
Cornell's transparency report labels this section Fall 2012 but expressly dates Chi Psi conduct Spring 2013; 2013 contemporary coverage corroborates Spring. Exact conduct days and tip receipt unknown. February 28 national (not university) suspension; April 26 university Review Board hearing; May 17 effective provisional status; June 27 announcement. 2014 loss of recognition and appeal are separate.