- Reporting basis
- Cornell University 2010–2011 Academic Year Hazing Violations, Alpha Delta Phi IFC chapter (May 10 Review Board, February and March reports, April 1 observed activity and full sanctions); separate Cornell 2009–2010 Academic Year entry for earlier independent case context.
- Incident type
- Hazing
- Allegation status
- University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board found Alpha Delta Phi responsible for violating Anti-Hazing Policy and the Fraternity and Sorority Recognition Policy.
- Investigation status
- Reports received February18 and March29, 2011; April1 observed cold-weather Goat House lineup; May10, 2011 Review Board recognition hearing and findings; two-year provisional recognition through spring2013.
- Legal status
- University organizational hazing and recognition-policy violation; public archive does not establish personal criminal convictions for the observed men.
Account
SPRING 2011 UNIVERSITY REVIEW BOARD CASE. Cornell University's original 2010–11 Hazing Violations Transparency Report states its UNIVERSITY FRATERNITY AND SORORITY REVIEW BOARD met on MAY 10, 2011 to review Alpha Delta Phi's recognition status after several specific new-member incidents. It found the chapter responsible for violating the Anti-Hazing Policy and thus failing to comply with its Fraternity and Sorority Recognition Policy. This proceeding is DISTINCT from the separate spring2010 disciplinary probation for compulsory pledge lineups.
FEBRUARY 18 REPORT AND EMAILS. Cornell's Office of Fraternity and Sorority Affairs (OFSA) received a hazing report on FEBRUARY 18, 2011. It included EMAILS between initiated Alpha Delta Phi members outlining INTENTIONS to get new members highly intoxicated and conduct a 'LINE UP.' Those intentions need to be distinguished from proof that the threatened high alcohol consumption occurred as planned. The university says emails also clearly indicated new members were being deprived of sleep, deceived, intimidated and verbally abused, with possible physical abuse described conditionally. GLW does not transform uncertain physical abuse into a specific established assault.
MARCH 29 HELL-WEEK REPORT. Cornell received an additional online report on MARCH 29, 2011 that fraternity brothers were conducting 'HELL WEEK' and hazing new members, even while the chapter was on SOCIAL PROBATION. Cornell does not specify the precise conduct dates, exact activities or duration alleged in that separate report. This complaint was one of several components considered together by the May Board, not a second independent May disposition.
APRIL 1 — THE GOAT HOUSE LINEUP. At approximately 4:30 P.M. on FRIDAY, APRIL 1, 2011, a Cornell staff member driving along McGraw Place witnessed about TEN TO TWELVE men around the Alpha Delta Phi GOAT HOUSE. They wore SUITS AND TIES WITHOUT WEATHER PROTECTION. Conditions were windy, rainy and cold, with temperatures in the UPPER 30s Fahrenheit. The men were spaced approximately ten to fifteen feet apart, stood at attention facing the building, and periodically moved together to new locations around the building before resuming the stance.
POLICE RESPONSE. A witness notified OFSA and Cornell University Police. Cornell's account records that Cornell Police and Ithaca Police arrived, after which the men filed into Alpha Delta Phi's chapter house. The public report does not identify those students, exact length of the observation, separate arrests, health injuries or whether any individual was personally charged. Nor does it prove that all twelve were pledges simply because they stood near the Goat House.
MAY 10 REVIEW BOARD FINDING. Cornell's University Fraternity and Sorority Review Board found the organization violated the Anti-Hazing Policy and chapter recognition requirements. The original Cornell account identifies MAY 10 as the Board meeting date; it does not separately provide a written-order issuance or provisional-status effective date. A numbered hazing severity level is not stated.
TWO YEARS PROVISIONAL RECOGNITION. Cornell imposed TWO YEARS of PROVISIONAL RECOGNITION, through SPRING 2013. The Board warned that future university or Greek-policy violations would result in immediate referral back to the Review Board with a RECOMMENDATION of lost recognition for no less than FOUR years. This was a threatened future consequence, NOT a four-year recognition withdrawal actually imposed for the 2011 matter.
LIVE-IN ADVISER. Cornell required the chapter to EMPLOY A LIVE-IN ADVISER on an ongoing basis. The official report does not specify the adviser's identity, hiring date or whether the position was filled by a particular deadline.
ALCOHOL EVENT RESTRICTIONS THROUGH SPRING 2012. Cornell removed Alpha Delta Phi's PRIVILEGE TO HOST EVENTS WITH ALCOHOL through SPRING 2012. Resumption also required completion of earlier sanctions, passing an Interfraternity Council Event Management Guidelines training, and showing ability to manage each type of registered alcohol event through simulation. The stated term must not be mistaken for an outright chapter recognition revocation.
NEW-MEMBER EDUCATION PLAN AND MONTHLY OVERSIGHT. The chapter had to REVIEW AND REVISE its new-member education process and submit it to OFSIL by DECEMBER 15, 2011. Leaders also had to meet MONTHLY with OFSIL staff for progress reports and organizational advising through SPRING 2012. Cornell lists obligations and deadlines without confirming the date each requirement was met.
POLICE SAFETY AND RISK-MANAGEMENT TRAINING. Cornell further ordered the chapter to arrange safety and risk training with ITHACA POLICE and/or CORNELL POLICE by OCTOBER 15, 2011. The online summary gives a deadline rather than documentary proof the training occurred on that date.
ALUMNI AND NATIONAL MEMBERSHIP REVIEW. Cornell's Board HIGHLY RECOMMENDED that alumni and national fraternity personnel conduct a member-by-member membership review. It was a recommendation, not a separately confirmed completed expulsion review. The chapter's members were not all individually adjudicated in this organizational proceeding.
INDEPENDENT 2010 HAZING PROBATION. In spring2010, Cornell separately imposed three semesters of DISCIPLINARY PROBATION (through the start of spring2012) for an earlier required pledge lineup. The 2011 proceeding had its own report dates, April observation and two-year PROVISIONAL RECOGNITION, ending spring2013. The original sources do not explicitly decide whether the earlier probation was terminated or ran concurrently; GLW does not invent a combined duration.
DATE AND INDIVIDUAL ACCOUNTABILITY. Only the February18 and March29 reporting days, April1 observed activity and May10 hearing day are established exactly. The anticipated February alcohol-intoxication plan in members' emails should not be presented as proof the drinking occurred. The observation describes ten to twelve men, but does not adjudicate each individual. Exact completion dates for training, adviser hiring, plan approval and recognition-status restoration remain undisclosed.
Feb18 report includes emails showing intention to intoxicate; don't report intended intoxication as proven completed act. Mar29 hell week is report date, Apr1 Goat House activity is actual observed conduct date, May10 is Review Board meeting. Police arrived but no individualized arrest reported. Later 4-year recognition loss was prospective recommendation for future violations, not sanction imposed in 2011. The independent 2010 three-semester disciplinary probation remains separate.