Account
01. Incident and publication scope. This case documents a September 1, 2000 serious glass-bottle assault against a Cornell student at a parking lot identified by the Cornell Chronicle, citing Cornell University Police, as the Sigma Alpha Epsilon (SAE) fraternity parking lot. The published record relates to a fraternity-associated venue, not an adjudicated organizational hazing or assault disciplinary finding. The source's street address is disputed by independently documented fraternity property histories. The case is intentionally listed in the histories of both Cornell SAE and Sigma Phi Epsilon (SigEp) through different evidence-labeled chapter links.
02. Incident date. Cornell University Police attributed the altercation to September 1, 2000. This is the reported date of the underlying physical assault. The subsequent October 6, 2000 arrest and Cornell Chronicle story are later investigative and news milestones, not separate assaults.
03. Location described by Cornell. Cornell Chronicle reporter Simeon Moss wrote on October 6, 2000 that the assault occurred in the parking lot of the Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity at 109 McGraw Place, Ithaca, New York. The October 2000 university account explicitly names SAE and links the episode to its described parking lot. This original venue attribution grounds the case's primary SAE chapter relationship.
04. Reported mechanism and injury. Cornell Police alleged that, after a disagreement, a Cornell student struck another 19-year-old Cornell student in the face with a glass bottle, causing serious physical injury. The victim is unnamed in the public text. The specific wound, medical diagnosis, treatment duration and long-term consequences are not disclosed.
05. Alleged individual assailant. Cornell's October 6 report refers to the person arrested only by the surname Clark (the public web article appears to have omitted the preceding first name). Clark was described as a Cornell student. The article does not supply a verified full name or identify the accused as a member of SAE or SigEp. No speculative full name is assigned and no separate Named Party row is published.
06. Cornell police investigation. The report describes a month-long investigation by Cornell University Police. On October 6, 2000, police arrested Clark on a second-degree assault charge. The offense was described as a Class D felony. An arrest and charge are not written as a criminal conviction in this archive.
07. Court arraignment and release. The Cornell Chronicle states that Clark was arraigned in City of Ithaca Court on October 6, 2000 and released on his own recognizance. The court's final judgment, any plea, sentence or dismissal has not been found in the consulted public accounts.
08. Scheduled hearing. The same contemporary report said Clark was scheduled to appear before Ithaca City Court Judge John Rowley on October 17, 2000. The date is recorded as a scheduled appearance only; the court calendar or later result was not obtained.
09. University conduct referral. Cornell's report separately states that Clark was referred to the Cornell judicial administrator. The university disciplinary referral is not the same as a campus misconduct finding. No final university conduct determination was recovered.
10. Fraternity venue designation. Cornell's own October 2000 campus publication names Sigma Alpha Epsilon as the fraternity associated with the parking lot, and the user has directed that documented assaults at fraternity-associated locations be indexed under the named fraternity even when evidence of chapter sponsorship has not been established. Cornell SAE New York Alpha therefore receives a primary venue-identified link for this published location-linked incident.
11. Address discrepancy from SigEp's first-party history. The Cornell Sigma Phi Epsilon alumni association says its Cornell New York Beta chapter moved to 109 McGraw Place in 1966 and maintained a campus presence there until 2005. This timeline overlaps the 2000 assault and conflicts with the Chronicle's identification of 109 McGraw Place as SAE's parking area. It independently supports a historical-property link to Cornell SigEp, not a finding that SigEp members assaulted anyone.
12. SAE's separately documented house address. Cornell's Alumni Interfraternity Council identifies Sigma Alpha Epsilon's New York Alpha house, Hillcrest, as 122 McGraw Place. That source is a later directory and does not independently establish the exact footprint of SAE's parking arrangements on September 1, 2000. The address conflict may involve an inaccurate street number, differing property/parking descriptions or adjacency; no single explanation is treated as proven.
13. Cornell's current 109 McGraw Place page. Cornell's residential-housing page independently documents the property at 109 McGraw Place and says it was built as a fraternity house in 1965. This contemporary housing source supports the address and historic building type but does not by itself identify which fraternity hosted any particular 2000 event.
14. Distinct chapter relationships. The same single case is linked to SAE as 'Primary—Cornell Chronicle named parking-lot fraternity' and SigEp as 'Historical premises—109 McGraw Place alumni property history.' Both connections are source-backed and indexed under the two Cornell chapters. These relationships do not assert that the two chapters jointly ran an event or that an internal fraternity tribunal found either chapter responsible.
15. No duplicate incident creation. This is one September 1, 2000 assault and one Cornell University Police case, with two chapter-relationship records. A second published case with a different slug would double-count the single victim incident and make the archive less accurate. The two chapter links, source links and chronology keep it discoverable under both associated fraternity records.
16. Allegation and outcome status. The original Cornell report documents a serious-injury police allegation, second-degree assault felony charge, arraignment, release, scheduled follow-up and referral to university conduct administration. No ultimate criminal adjudication, university discipline against the charged student, or fraternity organizational sanction is established in available public records.
17. Missing original records. The Cornell Police incident report for September 1, 2000, October 6 police arrest report, contemporaneous McGraw Place property/parking map and City of Ithaca Court case docket are not available in the assembled sources. These are the highest-value records to clarify precise location, fraternity venue classification and ultimate individual case outcome.
18. Reporting accuracy pathway. Cornell's own description of SAE's parking lot and the SigEp alumni address history are displayed alongside each other, allowing readers to understand the evidence and dispute. The case can be reviewed through GreekLifeWatch's existing Report Inaccuracy feature; this is no reason to omit the documented assault from the chapter-associated incident archive.
Published as fraternity-venue-linked crime under both SAE (contemporaneous university-assigned parking lot) and SigEp (109 McGraw Place historical property) with differing evidence-labeled link roles. Neither organization's direct participation or sanction inferred.