Chico State Sigma Pi (Theta Mu) — February 2024 Spoiled-Milk, Alcohol and Degrading Hazing; University/National Charter Revocation

Chico State found Sigma Pi Theta Mu responsible for February 17, 2024 hazing that pressured pledges to consume spoiled milk and alcohol, subjected them to discriminatory verbal harassment, and imposed strenuous physical exercises under stress. The campus inquiry opened February 21 and closed March 6, 2024 with a responsibility finding. The university revoked recognition and reports that Sigma Pi national headquarters separately revoked the chapter charter; reinstatement review is not considered before Spring 2027. Chico State also identifies Phi Nu Chi as a later unaffiliated local organization formed by former Sigma Pi members.

The Case File

Sources &
Records

A source-linked archive of the published records, court filings, official statements, reporting, disciplinary history, current developments and relevant context concerning Chico State Sigma Pi (Theta Mu) — February 2024 Spoiled-Milk, Alcohol and Degrading Hazing; University/National Charter Revocation. Browse by topic, search the full archive, or sort the case file by source number and date.

Latest Additions

Nov 12, 2026

Latest case-file additions from the GreekLifeWatch case spreadsheet. Select a card to open its full record below.

Direct links to case updates and sections

Case sections

Individual source records

[01] Case scope and identity[02] February 17, 2024 reported incident date[03] Pressure to consume spoiled milk[04] Alcohol abuse in pledge activities[05] Discriminatory verbal harassment[06] Physical exertion under stress[07] Leadership and policy noncompliance[08] February 21 investigation opened[09] March 6 completed investigation and finding[10] University recognition revoked[11] National Sigma Pi charter also revoked[12] Successor local group Phi Nu Chi[13] No established 2024 criminal conviction or bodily-injury record[14] Recognized IFC absence and present-day status[15] Different prior Sigma Pi fatality in 2012[16] Campus-wide recruitment review in 2025–2026[17] Outstanding institutional and national records[18] Chico State currently recognized Interfraternity Council chapter directory[19] Chico State Student Life and Leadership — original organizational misconduct, reporting and appeals procedures
Source-language note: this archive distinguishes allegations from established findings. When conduct has not been established by a court, law-enforcement disposition or other adjudicative finding, the page uses terms such as alleged, reported or explicit attribution to the complainant, an attorney, the university, law enforcement or the reporting outlet.

Searchable Archive

All Case File Records

Select any record to read its full summary, source links, excerpts and notes.

[01]Case scope and identityCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State's Campus Hazing Transparency Report identifies Sigma Pi Fraternity's Theta Mu Chapter as responsible for a February 17, 2024 hazing incident. The university recognized the chapter at the time. This case concerns that specific 2024 hazing and revocation, not the separate 2012 death of Sigma Pi pledge Mason Sumnicht already documented elsewhere in the same West regional archive.

[02]February 17, 2024 reported incident dateCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The university dates the incident February 17, 2024. Its original report describes multiple forms of coercion and abuse during new-member activities. It is not possible from this short public summary to determine the precise minute, duration of each task, number of participating new members or the exact event location.

[03]Pressure to consume spoiled milkCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State says new members were pressured to drink spoiled milk. The degrading food-consumption allegation appears within the university's Found Responsible organizational hazing entry. The report does not specify the amount of milk consumed, whether any student vomited or developed a diagnosable illness, or a medical transport in this 2024 case.

[04]Alcohol abuse in pledge activitiesCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The university also identifies pressure to consume alcohol, and its mandatory campus transparency field answers Yes to abuse of alcohol. The public findings do not identify measured blood-alcohol levels, a particular beverage, individual underage drinking charges or a hospitalization. The finding is organizational; the case is not recast as an individual criminal prosecution.

[05]Discriminatory verbal harassmentCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State reports that pledges were subjected to verbal harassment, including discriminatory language. The public institutional entry does not quote the remarks or specify which protected group was targeted. The archive records the degrading treatment without inventing particular slurs or assuming an individual's identity.

[06]Physical exertion under stressCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

New members were required to perform demanding physical exercises while under stress, according to the university. The report does not specify exercises, repetitions, hours, weather, or individual injuries, so those details are not added.

[07]Leadership and policy noncomplianceCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The official report also identifies the chapter's failure to meet expectations set by the university and national organization. Chico State attributes the overall misconduct to inadequate oversight and a new-member environment that failed to protect safety and dignity. These are campus-level conclusions about the chapter, not judgments against all historical members.

[08]February 21 investigation openedCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The investigation began February 21, 2024, four days after the date reported for the incident. The underlying complainant statement, investigatory interviews, chapter defense, and precise evidence-collection methods are not provided in the currently available campus entry.

[09]March 6 completed investigation and findingCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State lists March 6, 2024 as investigation end and the date the organization was notified of violation and sanctions. It expressly reports Found Responsible. That is a completed campus organizational disciplinary outcome and must not be downgraded to an unresolved allegation.

[10]University recognition revokedCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The university imposed recognition revocation. Its current recognized/unrecognized directory continues to list Sigma Pi as unrecognized for hazing and noncompliance, with no consideration of reinstatement before Spring 2027. That is an earliest potential review period, not automatic reinstatement or a confirmed 2027 return.

[11]National Sigma Pi charter also revokedCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Unlike the separate Phi Kappa Tau 2025 case, Chico State expressly reports that Sigma Pi national headquarters revoked the Theta Mu chapter charter in addition to campus sanctions. The public university entry does not supply the exact date of the national charter decision, so the March 6 university completion date is not misidentified as a separately verified national action date.

[12]Successor local group Phi Nu ChiCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State's current unrecognized-groups directory says Phi Nu Chi was formed by members from the revoked Sigma Pi chapter and is not affiliated with the university or any national organization. This is a later organizational development, not evidence of a nationally recognized Sigma Pi successor chapter or a separate proven hazing offense by Phi Nu Chi.

[13]No established 2024 criminal conviction or bodily-injury recordCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The original institutional disclosures describe spoiled milk, alcohol, abuse and forced exercise but do not state an individual criminal charge, prosecutor action, court judgment, hospital visit or named victim. The case presents the established campus disciplinary finding and does not fabricate an additional physical-injury outcome.

[14]Recognized IFC absence and present-day statusCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Sigma Pi is absent from Chico State's recognized IFC directory, consistent with university status revocation and national charter withdrawal. The campus-recognition directory is the more specific source for no return consideration before Spring 2027. No return application or outcome is documented.

[15]Different prior Sigma Pi fatality in 2012California State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Chico State's Sigma Pi history includes the separately reported death of Mason Lee Sumnicht in 2012 following birthday drinking in Chico. That case already exists as case_chico_sigma_pi_mason_sumnicht_20121103_fatal_alcohol. The 2012 death was not established as a ritual hazing violation in the reviewed source records and is not republished, merged, or attributed to the 2024 chapter misconduct finding.

[16]Campus-wide recruitment review in 2025–2026Duke University Campus Speech DatabaseCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

The university's December 2025 decision to pause Spring 2026 IFC recruitment and redesign recruitment safeguards followed multiple fraternity cases. This is broader administrative context, not a new finding specifically against Sigma Pi. The national charter had already been revoked according to the university's March 2024 case/status disclosures.

[17]Outstanding institutional and national recordsCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Rights and ResponsibilitiesCase file / original first-party investigationNovember 12, 2026

Original 2024 allegation and investigative reports, a signed March 6 university disposition letter, precise national charter revocation decision, member statements, medical records if any, and any subsequent appeal or reinstatement request have not been located. The official institutional transparency finding and current recognition directory provide direct evidence for the case as written.

[18]Chico State currently recognized Interfraternity Council chapter directoryCalifornia State University, Chico — Fraternity and Sorority LifeOriginal university current recognized-chapter listingDate not recorded

Official IFC directory lists recognized chapters such as Beta Theta Pi, Kappa Sigma, Sigma Nu and Tau Kappa Epsilon but does NOT list Pi Kappa Phi or Sigma Chi as 2026 campus-recognized members.

[19]Chico State Student Life and Leadership — original organizational misconduct, reporting and appeals proceduresCalifornia State University, Chico — Student Life and LeadershipOriginal university published organizational conduct and disciplinary proceduresDate not recorded

Original campus procedures describe incident intake, university organization conduct findings, sanctions, notice, administrative review and potential appeals. Procedural context only; not the case-specific signed Phi Kappa Tau or Sigma Pi outcome.

Case context & supporting details

Case file

Chico State Sigma Pi (Theta Mu) — February 2024 Spoiled-Milk, Alcohol and Degrading Hazing; University/National Charter Revocation

Sigma Pi at California State University, Chico · CA

Reporting basis
Original CSU Chico 2024 university responsibility finding and current 2026 unrecognized group register; separate original IFC chapter roster
Incident type
University-confirmed pledge hazing; coercive spoiled-milk and alcohol consumption; discriminatory harassment and physical exertion
Allegation status
Found responsible by university for hazing; drinking, humiliation and physical exertion in campus published determination; no identified criminal conviction
Investigation status
Campus inquiry February 21–March 6, 2024 with formal responsibility reported March 6
Legal status
University registration and national charter both revoked; earliest consideration for campus return Spring 2027; no criminal case outcome in published record
Incident start date
2024-02-17
Incident end date
2024-02-17

Historical 2012 Mason Sumnicht Sigma Pi case remains a separate previously published record; 2024 organizational findings do not establish new medical outcomes. Phi Nu Chi is independent local group, not national Sigma Pi chapter.