Account
STONE JUSTIN FOLTZ — FATAL BOWLING GREEN STATE UNIVERSITY PI KAPPA ALPHA HAZING (MARCH 2021). Stone Foltz, a 20-year-old BGSU sophomore, died on MARCH 7, 2021 after severe alcohol intoxication during the MARCH 4, 2021 "Big Little" new-member event of Pi Kappa Alpha (PIKE), DELTA BETA chapter. The event occurred at an OFF-CAMPUS home commonly referred to as "the Bando," 318 North Main Street, Bowling Green, Ohio. The cause of death reported in the Lucas County Coroner findings was FATAL ETHANOL INTOXICATION during a hazing incident. This case covers the underlying March event, university organizational and individual findings, eight defendants' varied criminal outcomes, civil resolutions and later case developments through May 2025.
PREVIOUS WARNING AND ORGANIZATIONAL HISTORY. A December 4, 2019 BGSU conduct letter documents an earlier anonymous allegation that PIKE hazed new members during Big/Little. At that time the university found insufficient basis for further disciplinary action and sent a LETTER OF CONCERN; it did not impose a new substantive finding in that letter. Following Foltz's death, BGSU's later independent investigation also uncovered prior alcohol-related misconduct and deception by members surrounding a 2018 incident. In its April 9, 2021 decision the university said members had concealed information, misled investigators and failed to comply with prior corrective requirements. Do NOT retroactively describe the 2019 concern letter as a guilty finding, or treat historical organization membership as proof of individual culpability.
SPRING 2021 PLEDGE CLASS. Barnes & Thornburg LLP, retained as special counsel on behalf of BGSU by the Ohio Attorney General, conducted 32 interviews and reviewed university, police and fraternity materials. Nine new members had confirmed pledging on FEBRUARY 7, 2021. BGSU's description of PIKE's New Member Handbook listed Big Little as a mandatory program and identified attendance expectations. The summary says there was an entrenched, high-pressure tradition—documented at least from 2017—of new members finishing or trying to finish a 'family bottle' of liquor handed to them by an assigned older fraternity member. The independent investigators did NOT find documentary or testimonial evidence that finishing the entire bottle was a formally stated pledge requirement; they DID find social pressure, encouragement to binge drink and awareness among leadership of the customary practice. The absence of a formal rule does not negate the university's later hazing finding.
MARCH 4 EVENT AT THE BANDO. At approximately 8:30 p.m., nine pledges gathered outside the off-campus residence at 318 North Main Street. They were instructed to blindfold themselves with their ties, led through a basement tunnel of active members, exposed to loud music, pushing and yelling, and each introduced to an assigned 'Big.' Members supplied 'family bottles' of alcohol. Some brothers encouraged drinking; eight of the nine new members drank, most became sick and vomited, and the majority reportedly consumed all or almost the entire contents of their assigned bottle. One new member did not drink. Investigators described alcohol-related peer pressure and a fraternity practice inconsistent with written anti-hazing assurances.
STONE'S CONSUMPTION AND COLLAPSE. Foltz received a family bottle of EVAN WILLIAMS BOURBON and was witnessed finishing it. One account estimated about 20 minutes; other later reporting characterized the time as approximately 18 minutes. The independent investigation does not assert that every pledge drank the same amount or that a single blood-alcohol measurement was identical across all subsequent accounts. Foltz became extremely impaired, vomited and needed assistance to walk. Active members and a new member transported him to his apartment, carried/helped him to a couch and left after a short time. His roommate later found him unconscious, summoned friends, and those friends noticed abnormal breathing, tried to position and help him, contacted 911 and followed dispatcher instructions including CPR until paramedics arrived.
MEDICAL RESPONSE AND DEATH. The ambulance response occurred late on MARCH 4; the Lucas County medical records and university report note an injury date recorded as March 5 due to the overnight timeline. Foltz was taken to Wood County Hospital and then Toledo Hospital, placed on life support and pronounced dead MARCH 7, 2021. The Barnes & Thornburg executive summary cites a blood alcohol concentration of 0.35%, while a separate civil complaint cites a higher admission figure of 0.394 g/dL. These measures are attributed to their respective documents; the 0.35% figure is the investigator's quoted toxicology result, and the competing figures are not blended or asserted to be interchangeable. His organ donation has been publicly recognized by the family and university.
MARCH 5–APRIL 9 UNIVERSITY RESPONSE. BGSU placed PIKE on INTERIM SUSPENSION beginning March 5, suspended Greek new-member intake and social activities across its councils and initiated an independent review. On APRIL 2 it announced SIX organizational conduct charges: harm to others; four specified hazing provisions; and an organizational alcohol policy violation. On APRIL 9 it found the fraternity responsible for ALL SIX and PERMANENTLY EXPELLED the chapter, declaring that university recognition would not be restored. The campus disciplinary ban is independent from any national-fraternity charter decision or subsequent criminal adjudication.
MAY–JULY INDIVIDUAL UNIVERSITY CONDUCT CASES. On MAY 14 BGSU released the special-counsel executive summary and notified 21 students of possible violations including hazing, endangerment, alcohol, misrepresentation and shared responsibility. BGSU announced on JULY 30 that ALL TWENTY-ONE students charged were found responsible for a COMBINED EIGHTY-THREE university Code of Student Conduct violations. THREE were permanently expelled, SEVENTEEN suspended for three to eight years and ONE received a deferred suspension. This is university disciplinary accountability against individuals at varied levels; it is not a count of criminal convictions.
CRIMINAL INDICTMENTS AND DISPOSITIONS. On APRIL 29, 2021 Wood County prosecutors announced criminal charges against EIGHT individuals, with charges varying by defendant. The criminal trial of TROY HENRICKSEN and JACOB KRINN concluded MAY 27, 2022. The jury acquitted them of the more serious involuntary-manslaughter and reckless-homicide felony allegations while convicting them of various misdemeanor hazing, underage-alcohol and/or obstruction counts. On AUGUST 17, 2022, EACH received FORTY-TWO DAYS in jail and twenty-eight days of house arrest, along with other requirements. These acquittals do not describe the outcomes of the six other defendants, several of whom entered guilty pleas, including to reckless homicide.
JUNE 16, 2022 GUILTY-PLEA SENTENCES. JARRETT PRIZEL, DAYLEN DUNSON and BEN BOYERS pleaded guilty to reckless homicide and hazing-related counts; Dunson and Boyers also pleaded guilty to obstruction-related offenses, and Dunson to tampering with evidence. NIALL SWEENEY and AARON LEHANE pleaded guilty to tampering with evidence and hazing; Lehane also pleaded to obstructing official business. On JUNE 16, 2022 Prizel received 28 days in jail and two years' probation; Dunson 21 days in jail and three years' probation; Sweeney 14 days in jail and two years' probation, with each additionally ordered to 28 days house arrest. Boyers and Lehane received 28 days house arrest and two years' probation. Another defendant also resolved charges by guilty plea; the public accounts used here do not supply a reliable complete individual sentencing table for that defendant, so no sentence is invented.
DISTINGUISH THE FORMER PRESIDENT. DAYLEN DUNSON was former PIKE chapter president. Contemporary prosecutors said he attended the Big/Little event in that office and subsequently obstructed the investigation, including alleged false statements and deletion or encouragement of deletion of material. He pleaded guilty to reckless homicide, multiple hazing and alcohol-furnishing misdemeanors and obstruction/tampering crimes. His 2022 sentence included a suspended prison term contingent on community control; it was not an active three-year prison sentence. A MAY 8, 2025 WTVG report says Wood County court issued a STATEWIDE WARRANT after Dunson failed to appear for a scheduled hearing. That article documents the warrant ON THAT DATE; a later arrest, warrant clearance, hearing or revocation outcome was not established from sources reviewed for this update.
CIVIL CASE AND JANUARY 2023 UNIVERSITY SETTLEMENT. Stone's parents CORY AND SHARI FOLTZ pursued a wrongful-death action, alleging BGSU failed to prevent known hazing risks. BGSU initially disputed the family's claims. On JANUARY 23, 2023 the family and BGSU announced a $2.9 MILLION SETTLEMENT, with cooperation on anti-hazing prevention. A separate set of civil agreements involving Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity entities and individuals was reported to bring previously resolved portions of litigation to more than $7 million before the university agreement; contemporaneous reporting described combined settlements exceeding $10 million. A news report also described a $1 million agreement involving PIKE; settlement totals should not be added together blindly because reports refer to overlapping defendants and different subsets. The settlement amounts are neither criminal fines nor an evidentiary substitute for individual verdicts.
DECEMBER 2024 CIVIL DAMAGES ORDER AGAINST DUNSON. Fraternal Law Partners described a DECEMBER 12, 2024 Franklin County Court of Common Pleas MAGISTRATE ruling assigning $6.5 MILLION in civil damages against Daylen Dunson, who had not participated in the underlying proceedings. The publication describes approximately $175,000 survivorship, $6 million wrongful death and $350,000 punitive damages. This is a separate individual damages order involving a remaining defendant; it is not the university's 2023 settlement, not a new cash payment proved collected, and not proof the judicial process had reached a nonappealable final outcome.
POST-INCIDENT LAW AND PREVENTION. The Foltz family's advocacy helped renew Ohio momentum for COLLIN'S LAW, named after Collin Wiant, another student who died in an earlier hazing episode. Governor DeWine signed Senate Bill 126 on JULY 6, 2021; its relevant provisions took effect OCTOBER 7, 2021. The statute expanded hazing definitions, increased criminal consequences in specified circumstances and required reporting, prevention policies and educational programs. The enhanced statutory provisions were enacted AFTER the March Foltz incident and did not retroactively create the March defendants' convictions. BGSU's presidential working group issued an anti-hazing framework on JULY 30, 2021 based on independent consultation and campus reform recommendations.
ACCOUNTABILITY AND LIMITS. The verified institutional outcome is permanent BGSU chapter expulsion. The confirmed medical outcome is Foltz's death from fatal ethanol intoxication. Criminal outcomes varied between felony guilty pleas and felony acquittals with misdemeanor convictions; each is attributed to named persons and date. The civil amounts reflect distinct settlements versus a later magistrate damages order, not one aggregated single recovery. No individual is called culpable solely because they belonged to the historical Delta Beta chapter or attended BGSU. This historical file was checked November 6, 2026 using BGSU original records, its special-counsel executive summary, state legislation and dated criminal/civil reporting; reported May 2025 warrant is not automatically treated as present-day outstanding.
Independent BGSU report explicitly did not establish a formal rule requiring completion of bottle, but confirmed a sustained high-risk tradition and peer pressure. Toxicology in special-counsel executive summary is reported as .35%, whereas family court filing cites .394 g/dL; label sources rather than blend. April2021 university permanent expulsion separate from fraternity national charter status. Do not conflate 2022 felony acquittals of two individuals with felony guilty pleas of others. December2024 $6.5m magistrate damages order separate from 2023 $2.9m BGSU settlement and earlier multi-party settlement; do not infer payment. Collin's Law effective after fatal incident. May2025 warrant status dated, not necessarily current.